February 2007

Jack Regan

Hello,

Car:- Audi A4 Avant 1.9tdi 130SE.

In December, I noticed that the glowplug light on the dash was flashing. It only flashed for about a minute then the light went out. It has not flashed since, just illuminated when I am about to start the car, like it should. However, 1000 miles on, during my journey home today, it flashed again for a few minutes.
I've looked in the manual and it says there may be an engine management problem and to get the engine serviced A.S.A.P.

The car only had its long life service in September so I don't fancy shelling out another £300.

Any ideas what the problem may be ?

Cheers
Read more

Jack Regan

Cheers mate.

sb01

My 51000 mile '02 Citroen C5 HDI 110 Auto has, in the last 2000 miles, developed a thirst for coolant - about a litre in 250 - 300 miles. The header tank remains under significant pressure long after the engine and coolant have cooled - on releasing the pressure cap first thing in the morning (-4 degrees C) the water level rose in the header tank by about 2 inches! The engine is also rougher than previously, particularly noticeable when stopped against the brakes and in gear. My local Citroen dealership has ben unable to identify a leak, nor have I. The logical conclusion appears to be head gasket failure, but Citroen claim this is an unheard of failure at this mileage . . . .anyone have any suggestions or comments on this?

{slight tweak to header to incorperate drop down menu that wasn't available when this question was first posted - DD} Read more

Mondaywoe

I traded in my early C5 for a 2006 ex Citroen management VTR last July. It's never been back to the dealership for a single thing and I've now done 18,000 miles (it had done 10,000 when I got it) And not one single drop of coolant has been used!

Good luck!

Graeme

guygamps

After some recent reliability scares, my wife and I decided to replace our Ford Galaxy (S REG Ghia X, fully loaded) with something newish.

Our budget was decided to be max £13K, and we wanted something 2years old or less with 20,000 miles on it or less.

Our family is 2 Adults and 4 children. The elder two teenages are obviously adult size, and the younger two are now passed the childseat phase, though do sit on small booster cushions.

So we regularly need to carry 6, and if we go away for a holiday, we need to be able to carry 6 plus luggage. To carry a extra 7th is a necessity as well, since we are regularly entertaining school friends etc at pick up time.

BUT, we wanted something where the rear seats fold down in to the floor, since even getting small bike in to the Galaxy is a nightmare, despite the large size of the car.

For the readers of this forum, I though it might be interesting to here what we arrived at and why.

Renault Espace: hard to find newish examples in our price bracket. Getting in to back row is tricky, children cannot tip the seat up themselves it requires two hands. Rear seats don?t fold in to floor leaving all the hassle that we have with the Galaxy seating arrangements still to live with.

Peugeot 806 / Citroen C8. My wife LOVED the sliding doors, but again the seating arrangements are no advance whatsoever on the Galaxy. E.g. like the Galaxy you cannot even tip up one of the rearmost seats unless it is slid backwards first, and seat in front is slid forwards. Meaning you forever have to move from back to side adjusting the seats before you can tip one up, exactly the kind of hassle we want to get away from.

Renault Grand Scenic. Darned fine car, but better suited to a family with younger/smaller kids, e.g. felt a bit cramped when fully loaded up, leg room in middle and back row not great. Terrible sales technique though, in front of my 6 year old, the salesman said ?be careful tipping the seat up before you climb in the back, lots of children hurt their fingers on the mechanism?? from that point on whenever we discussed the car, Antonia (age 6) piped up ?please don?t get that one, I don?t want to hurt my fingers?. It is essential for us that the children can get themselves in and out of the backrow. E.g. stopping to pick up an additional passenger, one child my quickly hop in the back to allow another in the middle row.

Ford Galaxy MkII. Our budget would only get us a used Zetec, unless we settled for something older. Much better interior trim quality than the Mk I, but no advance in seating arrangement. Zetec doesn?t even have elec windows in rear.

Ford S-MAX. Out of our budget obviously but we decided to look at it due to the rave reviews. I was thinking that if my wife fell in love with it, then maybe we could finance it differently. The demo car had the rearmost seats folded in to the floor when we first went to it. A couple of minutes fiddling around, and we could not find how to pull up the seat. Salesman came over, he couldn?t do it either, fiddled with this and that and got the seat up. Then a flappy bit of trim was hanging off the back of the seat, and needed clipping in to place, but the clip was broken. Since we will be very regularly putting these seats up and down, we walked away very disillusioned with the ?Car of The Year?. Not even interested.

Chrysler Voyager. What a waste of space (for us anyway). The seating arrangement is 2 + 2 + 3, meaning you cannot carrtymore than 4 people without using rear most seats. So six plus luggage is a real challenge whilst even all the 2+3+2 arranged vehicles you can remove or fold down (if possible) a seat accounting for half with width of the boot, so giving a 2+3+1+luggage arrangement. Or 5 +loads of luggage. The Voyager is therefore a complete non starter.

Vauxhall Zafira. Don?t like the middle bench seat arrangement which has to be slid forward before the rears can be dropped in to the floor. Never liked that, and was surprised they kept that when they went to Mk II. Too ?mumsy? you simply see too many of them at the school gates. We wanted something a bit more distinctive.

What else did we look at:

Honda FRV, only seats 6, not really capable of taking 4 adult sized and two smaller ones regularly, just too small. Same with Fiat Multpla. Citroen Picasso C4, too new, out of budget. Toyota Previa ? seating arrangements not suitable, plus too expensive for what you get.

So that leaves us with

Mitsubishi Grandis.

First thing to note was that there are plenty of Elegance models (top model) on dealers forecourts, all under 2 years old and in budget. Rear most seats feel comfortable for full sized adults, plus a) there is good luggage space behind them even when both are up, and b) they both fold in to floor regardless of position of middle row. Folding mechanism is a complete cinch, they are counterbalanced, and there are no flappy bits to secure in place (take note Mr Ford). Middle row is a 60/40 bench, but operating the mechanism to get in/out of the very back row is a doddle. Single lever, or foot switch from behind and the whole thing slides forward and tips to let you climb in to back. Good leg room in back and middle rows. Although not 3 individual seats across the middle row ? it still seats 3 comfortably across that row, permitting the 2+3+1+luggage mode we want occasionally. Diesel is out of our price bracket, but we are low mileage users and the petrol costs on our Galaxy never crippled us, Grandis should be a little more economical. My wife fell in love with the Warrior, leather stitched seats, flip down DVD player (to keep the kids happy), sports kit, etc. Dealer offered us a 21 month old car with 14,000 miles on it for £13,000, still with 15 months manufacturers warranty. Feels exclusive ? you don?t see many of them around, lovely to drive, a bit brisker than the 2.3 auto Galaxy, and a little more car like. Deal done, bought it, love it, and can?t help but think it is a very well kept secret and badly promoted by Mitsubishi.


Comments welcome Read more

Brian Tryzers

Following various comments (including mine) on the Grandis diesel, I noticed this written about Mitsubishi's Outlander, which currently uses the same diesel as the Grandis:

The 138bhp VW engine will not live long in the nose of the Outlander, as a decidedly more powerful 150bhp 2.2 litre PSA Peugeot-Citroën motor is to replace it in November.

If that means the Grandis will get it too - and if Mitsubishi can install it properly in a vehicle that wasn't designed for it, which I suspect is part of the problem - that ought to make a Grandis an attractive proposition again. I hope so - I get a little frisson when I see one, which I think means that my subconscious would rather like to have one. And it's one of those rare cars that really do look good in Ubiquitous Silver - but that's another thread.

milkyjoe

what would be the best torque wrench to get for use on a small hatch back? ive seen a few but the ranges seem a bit useless ie 20-150 lbs ft, as some need to be less than 20 lbs ft, is there a one size fits all on the market? or should i need to buy 2, a low range and a high range, also advise needed on what would be an appropriate bearing puller for when i do the wheel bearings? thanks Read more

Aprilia

Should add a useful tip - when you've finished using your torque wrench always unwind the spring (i.e. set it to '0' torque setting) - that helps keep it in calibration.

GazKaz

Hi all

My vectra has had this annoying knocking noise from the front suspension for a while now and it's time it was fixed!

It only happens mainly when going over sleeping policemen.

Any ideas guys (or gals)

Thanks in advance

GazKaz Read more

GazKaz

Hi all

Problem sorted!

As mentioned in an earlier post by Deryck Tintagel, I have replaced both anti-roll bar drop links (the passenger side one had a split rubber gaiter on one end of it) and it is now thankfully silent again!

It has only taken me around 2 months to finally find time to sort it!

Thanks for your help

GazKaz

loveylaura

hi i have a renault clio whose exhaust is making a lot of noise so i have booked it in for an early MOT on thursday. i have just realised that i am getting it done on the 8th February and it doesnt run out until 8th March. does this count as a month or is it one day over a month?

i wanted to get the exhaust fixed but didnt want to pay out for it if the car wasnt worth the MOT but am now extremely confused about the dates of MOT's and dont want to lose a month on MOT for the sake of one day!! Read more

Dynamic Dave

a900ss,

Yes, but you will need to take your registration document as proof of when the vehicle was first registered.

www.direct.gov.uk/en/Motoring/OwningAVehicle/Mot/D...2

maz64

Hi- I couldn't help but notice that despite my nice new Leon FR having traction control, it still seemed quite easy to spin the front wheels when pulling away from standstill in wet conditions. I asked the dealer to look at the TC, which he did, but said there wasn't a problem. He told me that it only cuts in when it senses a difference in speed between the 2 wheels, so it probably won't when setting off in a straight line on a flat road.

Can anyone with knowledge and/or experience of VAG traction control systems verify this?

Cheers
John Read more

maz64

Does the button say ASR or ESC?
The ASC just has TC & EDL, and the ESC has
stability control too.
I have the ASR and don't think it's much good, tending
to just brake alternate front wheels in quite an undignified fashion.


ESP (=ESC?)
mare

One of those things you hear about, but rarely see, until today - white W reg Clio on the side of the road with the bonnet wrapped around the windscreen. Seen this on Watchdog, apparently the bonnet catches don't catch and one day, wallop!

Fair play to the driver getting over to the side of the road blind, and what a horrible experience that must have been for them. Read more

Nonny

Bleeding obvious init. If you do not have this problem on other makes/models why is it a major problem on this car only. I never grease my bonnet locks on my Hyundai or Mazda. Never had such a problem on all the cars I have had over the last 29 years. Bleeeding obvious init. What other things should I make sure I have done before I drive my car. Gearbox bolted down? Engine block tied down Wheels on every corner. Where do you start checking and where do you finish . Get real!

snipquote. Please don't quote the entire message to which you're replying to, and DON'T quote it after typing your reply - which in cyberland is called top posting, and is one of my many pet hates

Rattle

When my Fiesta 1.1 is cold there is little smoke, after about 6-7 miles the smoke gets quite bad, its not burning fuel and there is not a single bit of miss fire, but the smoke gets quite bad almost emberassingly so.

As with my previews threads my mechanic reckons its the camshaft which is damaged but is there any short term solution to reduce the smoke a bit?

The service has not mad any difference whats so ever :( Read more

Rattle

I am niot convinced these restore oils won't just block oil ways and water ways though. I am not trying anything like that until a last resort, i.e I need a new engine anyway. For now while the car is running perfectly fine I will just wait till the MOT if the engine lasts that long.

Happy Blue!

I decided today to check the Outback over as I'm off the London on Tuesday. It also needed a clean, so the car got a good once over for the first time since I bought it. Everything was fine until I checked the tyres. Rear tyres were checked first and were absolutely spot on with the recommendations.

Front tyres which should have been at 2.0bar were at 3.9bar - yes 3.9bar - both of them. I checked with three gauges! I've lowered them to the correct level and again checked with all three gauges. I haven't drive the car since Friday afternoon and won't until Monday morning. Tyres look OK. Apart from feeling the road properly, and possibly worse fuel consumption (unlikely to make much difference!), I wonder what I should worry about???

I assume that the garage I bought the car from in November (I know I shouldn't have left it too long) did not check the tyres properly or the technician simply got it wrong big time. It is a Subaru dealer, but only a short time in the network. Read more

Happy Blue!

Weird thing is that there has been no noticeable difference in handling and a very minor improvement in ride. The only obvious difference (as I said above) is the rattle which has disappeared. The steering is perhaps very slightly heavier, but with the emphasis on very slightly.

I would have said that it was my gauge at fault, but I checked all four tyres with two pencil guages and with the digital gauge attached to my compressor and all three read 2.0bar on the rears and 3.9bar on the fronts.

What I did notice about my trip to London yesterday was that my economy on Shell V-Power was better than using BP regular unleaded. A full tank of Shell V-Power got me to London and 1/2 the way back at an average of 28.8mpg cruising at over 80mph. I got the same economy on BP but at no more than 75mph for half the return trip.