What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - John F

On the Service Schedule for our 2008 (A94F) - EB2ADTS/EU63 1200 3 CYL PETROL under 'Authorised Engine Oils' it says...

00W20 B71 2010 (C5) - 00W30 B71 2312 (C1C2)

Why are two viscosities offered? Which is best? Is the 'thinner' one for colder countries, e.g. Scotland ;-) Is 00W20 now recommended for newer engines? Would a 'thinner' oil protect more against carbonisation?

No-one at the Peugeot dealer could answer these questions; they just replaced the factory oil with 00W30 at the first service, because that's all they had in stock.

I wonder if there are any oil experts out there who know the pros and cons?

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Andrew-T

I thought the two numbers represent summer and winter viscosities, and where the summer and winter temps are very different (e.g. Canada, or Scotland in a bad year) you use an oil with bigger diff between the two figures. The zero to 10 oils are thin, the 20 to 30 oils thicker.

Or am I under a misapprehension ?

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Lee Power

Correct oil spec for the PSA Purecrap engine in the UK is PSA B71 2312

Forget the viscosity - it just has to be PSA B71 2312 spec

Some other areas of the world use a different PSA spec depending on climatic conditions.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Andrew-T

Correct oil spec for the PSA Purecrap engine in the UK is PSA B71 2312

Most Peugeot handbooks I have ever seen (a few) offer a choice of oil grades for petrol or diesel engines. I have never seen one advising only one grade - tho if I ask the local ATS to change my oil, they tell me what PSA recommends and are unwilling to use anything different. Despite my asking them to use 10/40, which the car had lived with for 10 years or more (one of the grades advised in the handbook). I went elsewhere.

I think there is a lot of dogma around. No doubt the advised grade is excellent, but it doesn't follow that anything else is asking for trouble.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Lee Power

The Purecrap uses a wet timing belt - use of the wrong spec oil is just asking for Peugeot to reject any warranty / 6 year goodwill claim when the belt fails.

For a Purecrap engine in the UK Its not about viscosity, its all about the oil being approved to PSA B71 2312 spec.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Metropolis.
Lee Power, i think it id slightly poor form to be dissing the engine on another members car, when they are not actually reporting an issue.

John: I thought all cars had these different temperature ranges?

On the discovery 2 v8 owners manual it gives two options, which I ignore and use 20/50:

10W/30 will protect from -10oC to +30oC 10W/40 will protect from -10oC to +50oC.

For the td5 they say 5w30, 40 or 50 if I recall correctly.

I would also factor in your style of driving, is it lots of short trips or long runs?
Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - _

Just in the process of buying the new kia..

Oil has changed 2021 onwards for the 1.0 Kappa tgdi from ACEA C2/c3 0w 30 to API. SN 0w20.

Wonder which one the car gets being serviced as they have bulk oil..

Edited by _ORB_ on 26/09/2021 at 06:09

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Lee Power
Lee Power, i think it id slightly poor form to be dissing the engine on another members car, when they are not actually reporting an issue. John: I thought all cars had these different temperature ranges? On the discovery 2 v8 owners manual it gives two options, which I ignore and use 20/50: 10W/30 will protect from -10oC to +30oC 10W/40 will protect from -10oC to +50oC. For the td5 they say 5w30, 40 or 50 if I recall correctly. I would also factor in your style of driving, is it lots of short trips or long runs?

I've owned my Purecrap 130 powered 308 since May 2018, its had to have the inlet valves decoked at just 34k miles due to a known design flaw ( which Peugeot UK where reluctant but eventually paid for )

It's also been recalled for the JZR timing belt check due to another known design flaw.

A mechanic friend of mine had to replace the timing belt on his wife's 2017 Purecrap 110 powered 208 as it was starting to break up but pasted the JZR recall check - he found out Peugeot are now on generation 4 timing belts which is the kit he fitted to it ( 4th time lucky, maybe, who knows? )

A work colleague had to pay to have a replacement timing belt & the oil strainer cleaned on his 2017 Purecrap 130 powered 308 as it was built after the JZR recall cut off point with a generation 3 belt but it still failed at 42k miles with a full Peugeot main dealer service history & Peugeot wasn't interested in an out of warranty goodwill claim.

Go have a look on the various Peugeot / Citroen forums & see the amount of unhappy owners that have had failures / little to no help from Peugeot / Citroen.

These engines in my opinion are total garbage because of known design flaws that have now showing up & ill never buy another Stellantis product ever again.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Andre Grandjean

I too own a Peugeot 308 with a 1.2 Purecrap engine.

I had the vavles decoked af 30K after my Peugeot dealer said I needed a new engine!. It was just out of warranty and Peugeot would not pay for mine.

In March this year I had the JZR recall and it 'passed'. Last week my timing belt broke and trashed the engine. How can this happen after being checked?

I now have to find £5400 for a new engine.

I have logged a new complaint with Peugeot but do not hold out any hope.

I totally support your view that the 1.2 Puretech engine has several design faults and is crap!

Peugeots customer service is non existent with regards to problems many drivers are experiencing with this engine.

I will NEVER buy another Peugeot again!

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - John F
10W/30 will protect from -10oC to +30oC 10W/40 will protect from -10oC to +50oC.

I have never really understood how a few degrees change in ambient air temperature from a hot summer day (30deg) to an exceptional heatwave (40deg) would affect the oil temperature (110 - 125) in a 90 - 105deg pressurised water cooled engine).

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Andrew-T

For a Purecrap engine in the UK Its not about viscosity, its all about the oil being approved to PSA B71 2312 spec.

Fine. Perhaps I didn't make my earlier point clear - Pug usually advises more than one viscosity grade for each engine. Maybe different grades meet the B71 2312 spec ?

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Lee Power

For a Purecrap engine in the UK Its not about viscosity, its all about the oil being approved to PSA B71 2312 spec.

Fine. Perhaps I didn't make my earlier point clear - Pug usually advises more than one viscosity grade for each engine. Maybe different grades meet the B71 2312 spec ?

Most if not all PSA B71 2312 spec oil I've seen are 0w30.

As I've repeatedly said, the viscosity isn't important any more, the vehicles manufactures oil specification for the engine concerned is what's important.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - John F

Most if not all PSA B71 2312 spec oil I've seen are 0w30.

As I've repeatedly said, the viscosity isn't important any more, the vehicles manufactures oil specification for the engine concerned is what's important.

If you read my original post carefully you will see that I have clearly been offered two different Peugeot approved specifications - B71 2312 and B71 2010. They are different viscosities. If viscosity 'isn't important', why is there a choice? If it is to allow for different climates, surely there should be some advice as to which is best for which country? If , as purported by some oil providers, 0w20 is a better oil, why not just recommend that as first choice? At the next oil change, what would you use - and why?

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Lee Power

Email Peugeot UK & ask them which oil is best for your vehicle VIN so this nonsense thread can be put to bed.

I know what the answer will be & I can guess you will just ignore the manufacturers advice & use a 0w20 oil instead thinking thinner is better.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - craig-pd130

I suspect the differences are to allow for different countries' climates. Eg. Spain / Portugal should probably use the 0W30 variant because of their higher average ambient temps.

In the UK I would probably use the 0W30 too because it should retain higher viscosity under high load conditions, while still giving rapid circulation at cold starts.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Brit_in_Germany

The thinner oil may have been specified to lower the engine internal friction and hence improve economy for the government figures. It would not necessarily be the oil providing the best long term protection.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - S40 Man

The thinner oil may have been specified to lower the engine internal friction and hence improve economy for the government figures. It would not necessarily be the oil providing the best long term protection.

You may well be right

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - focussed

The thinner oil may have been specified to lower the engine internal friction and hence improve economy for the government figures. It would not necessarily be the oil providing the best long term protection.

You may well be right

On my past experience you are probably correct.

I bought a new FN3 Honda Civic 2.2 CTDI in 2007 - the spec oil was then 5W-30.

A year or so later the oil spec was changed to 0W-30, no reason given.

IMHO Purely to achieve a marginally improved emissions performance from around the zero degree cold-start condition - thinner oil when cold - less resistance - etc etc.

I used both specs at different times when changing the oil after the warranty ran out.

I found that using 0w-30 it would use about half a litre over the oil change period.

When using 5w-30 it would burn very little if any between changes.

The mileage was during our long forays into france before moving here, so was being driven moderately hard - autoroutes - etc.

I sold the car in 2016 to a local lady here in france, it's been no trouble at all to her.

Both oil specs were Castrol Edge.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - sammy1

"""

A year or so later the oil spec was changed to 0W-30, no reason given.

IMHO Purely to achieve a marginally improved emissions performance from around the zero degree cold-start condition - thinner oil when cold - less resistance - etc etc."""

All these modern oils seem to be thinner than the choice of oil years ago when on an ice cold morning you could almost sense the drag as an engine turned over and over before it started. The same engine once warmed up started immediately.

I wonder with all these modern oils when running at optimum engine temp have any real difference, they all seem to run like "water" when they are drained hot.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - edlithgow

For a Purecrap engine in the UK Its not about viscosity, its all about the oil being approved to PSA B71 2312 spec.

Fine. Perhaps I didn't make my earlier point clear - Pug usually advises more than one viscosity grade for each engine. Maybe different grades meet the B71 2312 spec ?

Most if not all PSA B71 2312 spec oil I've seen are 0w30.

As I've repeatedly said, the viscosity isn't important any more...

You'll have to repeat that an awful lot more to overcome physical reality, unless you are a wizard and its some kind of magic incantation..

Perhaps you meant "viscosity isn't the only thing that's important any more" That'd be OK, though its very very old news.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - edlithgow

I thought the two numbers represent summer and winter viscosities, and where the summer and winter temps are very different (e.g. Canada, or Scotland in a bad year) you use an oil with bigger diff between the two figures. The zero to 10 oils are thin, the 20 to 30 oils thicker.

Or am I under a misapprehension ?

Yes

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - edlithgow

Why are two viscosities offered?

Higher viscosity gives marginally better protection with a marginal fuel economy penalty. Hot countries and "performance" oriented driving.

Since in these uber skinny oils the hot viscosity is probably mostly achieved with viscosity modifiers, which can break down, the 30 MIGHT tend to clog your rings more

Which is best?

Depends what you want, and on secrets that you probably wont be able to find out, but I'd pick the 0W30.

Is the 'thinner' one for colder countries, e.g. Scotland ;-)

Not necessarily, because the engine operating temperature should be controlled and thus the same apart from in extreme heat.

Is 00W20 now recommended for newer engines?

Some, but thats mostly for fuel economy

Would a 'thinner' oil protect more against carbonisation?

Why would you think that? Thinner oil will tend to pass the rings more, so more carbon. OTOH, as above, the thicker stuff may have a higher VI loading which MIGHT tend to clog the rings more at high mileages.

I wonder if there are any oil experts out there who know the pros and cons?

Perhaps working for the oil company, but they'll have non-disclosure agreements in place

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - edlithgow

My choice of the probably more protective 0W30 (Of those two. I'm currently on about 25W45 and hope never to have to use an oil starting with zero) was a bit knee jerk irrational, though, and influenced by running a 35 year old engine.

I doubt many Puretech's will make it to 35, whatever the oil, so picking the slightly more fuel efficient 0W20 will make more sense for most people.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - John F

I wonder if there are any oil experts out there who know the pros and cons?

That's what I was hoping for, but thanks for this detailed reply anyway. Incidentally, I did email Peugeot - but no reply so far. On other cars I've had, acceptable oils with different viscosities are accompanied by a table of temperature ranges.

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - edlithgow

I wonder if there are any oil experts out there who know the pros and cons?

That's what I was hoping for, but thanks for this detailed reply anyway. Incidentally, I did email Peugeot - but no reply so far. On other cars I've had, acceptable oils with different viscosities are accompanied by a table of temperature ranges.

I believe member Peter Growcott was an oil formulator, and is retired, so might feel able to speak more freely than someone still in the industry. That's probably as good as you'll get

See link below to the Mannol Oil discussion

www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=116156

Though not specific to your car and those oils (a bit of an ask) his reply to my "thick versus thin" question gets pretty close in general terms

Edited by edlithgow on 01/10/2021 at 11:36

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Xileno

Oilman from opieoil was our resident expert but hasn't visited for ten years. However his sticky thread is still at the top of this forum and I updated it back in April as someone sent some for info (it might even have been him)

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - Manni76
The only oil on the Puretech 6.2 and 6.3 is the b712310 spec. This is the oil that was in your car from production. For a short time you could use the b712312 spec as a 2nd option. This is now not the case. Your dealer should have the b712310 and is the only oil for 1.2l 6.3 and dv5r engines .

Edited by Manni76 on 16/12/2022 at 11:25

Peugeot 2008 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT6 - Which oil? - gordonbennet

What a lot of faff, why bother buying into silly designs like this in the first place, as daft as BMW making Diesels with the timing cahin at the back of the engine, better off owning simpler proven engineering.

Its not as if these companies are known for extending warranties in case of failure for these designs on properly serviced cars, say to 10 years or 100,000 miles, which Toyota have done mutliple times when weaknesses in their designs have manifested.