What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Braking pointers

Could you please clarify the position regarding the use of automatic transmission when stationary at traffic lights. I seem to recall your advice given some time ago, was to select neutral and hold on the brake for any long stationary period, to prevent the gearbox working unnecessary. This is the practice that I use, and consider it to be correct. However I have just received my latest copy of the advanced drivers magazine, and the advice is different. Someone wrote a letter, stating that when in Australia he was told he would fail a test if he put the car into neutral at traffic lights, he then asked for the editors comments as to how it applies in the UK, and I quote. "When stopping at traffic lights in an automatic car I would criticise you for slipping the the vehicle into neutral. The vehicle should hold its position without creep with the handbrake on if it is correctly maintained. The principle of an automatic vehicle is that it is automatic-so it does the work, not you. To emphasise this point there are automatics in the commercial world which do not have a neutral position available to the driver." This is perhaps a matter of preference, but I would appreciate your comments.

Asked on 17 January 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
When you are last to stop in a line, sit on the footbrake so anything
coming up behind can see you are stationary. As soon as it does, select neutral, pull on the parking brake and get your foot off the footbrake so you don't blind the driver behind. The IAM advice makes sense as long as the car is correctly maintained and nothing goes wrong. But no one can rely on this, so it’s safer to select neutral and put the parking brake on. Too many people are injured or even killed by runaway automatics.
Similar questions
Sadly the majority of motorists seem to forget the Highway Code. 90 per cent of them use the footbrake to remain stationary at traffic lights, not the handbrake, even though they will have a wait of several...
Please could you comment on this statement on the IAM website as I always assumed you should put an auto into neutral at a standstill to minimise wear. 'When stationary in traffic, even for many minutes,...
I've just taken delivery of a 1.6 Golf Bluemotion automatic as a company car. As I've driven countless automatics over the last 30 years I didn't anticipate the problems I'd encounter with the stop start...