What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Bourbon or Lemon Puff - JOGON

Forget Hobnobs and Digestive. Now and again it's good to buy a decent pack of decent biscuits. Old fashioned ones like your Aunty had. I can easily put a packet of Fig Rolls away with 1/2 pint of tea. But is it the chocolatey smoothness of the Bourbon, or the citrus lemon tang of a Lemon Puff. There's some awful american new biscuit where your supposed to a*** about breaking it up, then licking salt off the back of your hand, then taking a shot of Tequila and having a glass of milk....I don't think!! If there are even better choices do let me know. 21.15HR, time for bed.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - unthrottled

The plainer a biscuit is, the better imo. Can't get decent fig rolls for love nor money-not sure if they count as a biscuit (like the old jaffa cake debate). Just sick of the image of a fat, juicy fig not bearing any resemblence to the sad looking fig flavoured pastry inside!

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - JOGON

I much prefer

Oh yeah, there's that wonderful VAT Court Ruling -if I may sum up:-

McVities defended its classification of Jaffa Cakes as cakes in court, producing a 12" (30 cm) Jaffa Cake to illustrate that its Jaffa Cakes were simply miniature cakes. McVities argued that a distinction between cakes and biscuits is, among other things, that biscuits would normally be expected to go soft when stale, whereas cakes would normally be expected to go hard. It was demonstrated to the Tribunal that Jaffa Cakes become hard when stale. Other factors taken into account by the Chairman, Potter QC, included the name, ingredients, texture, size, packaging, marketing, presentation, appeal to children, and manufacturing process. Potter ruled that the Jaffa Cake is a cake. McVities therefore won the case and VAT is not paid on Jaffa cakes in the UK. [8]

Edited by Jog-on on 13/07/2011 at 22:28

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - unthrottled

The going hard when stale was the killer for HMRC which highlighted the rather arbitrary nature of VAT-it being payable on chocolate coated biscuits but not plain ones.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Avant

What's happened to plain chocolate Hobnobs? Haven't seen them for ages.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - jamie745

Its a shame it wasnt the other way around because i'd have loved to see someone make a 12" Hob Nob!

Its the fact VAT is payable on tax is what gets me, the underlying scandal of our modern times. Hardly "luxury items, goods or services" is it?

I love a nice choccy bourbon. Some Fox's biscuits are top notch too.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - JOGON

Lumme, I've verred into HMRC, Vat. Tax on tax is a bummer. My F. in law twaddles on about how 'his petrol station is fleecing him'. I've gently pointed out that approx 5% of price is Forecourt cost + profit. Oil cost (find it, drill it, transport and refine it) maybe 35% with then Fuel Duty & Vat at least 60%

Edited by Jog-on on 14/07/2011 at 09:37

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - jamie745

If you really want to make his blood boil, point out that the 59p duty rate is included when they add 20% on for the VAT. VAT charged on fuel duty. Very much a have, cake, eat etc

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Bobbin Threadbare
You can't go wrong with a Hobnob or a chocolate digestive. I like ginger biscuits as well. You can get through a lot of Hobnobs and tea in one sitting. I recommend a book called 'A Nice Cup of Tea and a Sit Down' by Nicey and Wifey. www.amazon.co.uk/Nice-Cup-Tea-Sit-Down/dp/07515376...1

I have this book and it is an excellent discourse on the state of biscuits in the UK today, and some further afield. There's a section on tea and coffee and a small discussion of cake, but let's face it, compared to a biccie, cake can be a bit up itself.
Bourbon or Lemon Puff - unthrottled

cake can be a bit up itself.

Thast is the most nonsensical juxtaposition of words I've ever seen, yet I know exactly what you mean! Most cakes are too sickly, dry or sweet and have nothing to be pretentious about. I'll make an exception for a good, moist coffee and walnut, but for everyday, a plain simple nice takes some beating.

-Very economical

-doesn't melt in your hand

-doesn't leave swathes of congealed crumbs in hard to reach areas of the mouth (unlike hobnobs)

- mild taste doesn't clash with the beverage

The Peugeot 405 Estate 1.9 XUD engine of confectionary.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - JOGON

Re: Cake. Light and fluffy is to be avoided. 'Heavy' is good. If someone is making you a light and fluffy cake, a good tip is to open the oven door and slam it shut (just at the right time). Coffee and Walnut.....I'd almost forgotten those (floats away to the mid 1960's, everything in black and white). If you can't be bothered to cook and eat it, Aldi do a pretty good square fruit cake (the sort to have with Cheshire Cheese). Theres a Porter Cake and an Irish Whiskey Cake. Put nearly a Stone on.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Bobbin Threadbare

I knew I was in the right place! You like coffee and walnut cake. I make a nice one of those but there's only one other person besides me who will eat it.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Vitesse6

For a decent fig roll try Sainsburys own brand - by far the best I have found.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Bobbin Threadbare

For a decent fig roll try Sainsburys own brand - by far the best I have found.

I second that. Although the fig roll is not a dunker.

I have just made a pear crumble. Where does that lie in the spectrum? Or does it live in 'puddings'? Its topping is basically the ingredients for a biscuit but it's also fruity like a cake.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - unthrottled

Pears are for stewing! Nice bag of cheap conference pears tossed in a pan and lightly simmered with some cinnamon and sugar.

Do you use oats in your crumble? My mum's recipe does and I thought that all crumbles did-but there seems to be a lot of support for the oatless powdery stuff.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Bobbin Threadbare

Yes, about 2oz of oats in 8oz flour. Gives it a nice texture.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - unthrottled

Perfect! how did the pear crumble go?

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Bobbin Threadbare

They scoffed the lot!

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - davmal

If it's with tea, bourbon doesn't go (tea and chocolate, barf) it has got to be Anzac biscuits, crispy,crunchy, coconutness and sweet. Lemon puffs? Say no more.

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - unthrottled

Right Thready, Thready Threadbare; l'll raise your plum crumble with a bread and butter pudding. The preparation is a bit of a faff, but well worth it!

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - Bobbin Threadbare

Pears not plums!

Fine, I see your bread and butter pud and I raise it a whisky mac cheesecake, which I am taking to a party :-P

Bourbon or Lemon Puff - JOGON

.....School Dinners..... much maligned, but they left me with a love of such puds, and pink custard served in odd gold coloured metal jugs. And sprouts which looked like a sprout but had been boiled from 8.30am until high noon, and was 'a paste', with a warm, buttery, nutty sproutiness on the palate, and beyond. The weedy kids whinged, but we went for seconds.