You may find that what they failed it on was not smoke but soot. If you poodle round for a long time you get a build up of soot in the exhaust system, the first time you put your foot down and rev it hard the sheer volume of exhast gas blows all the soot out, looks just like black smoke, try belting it up and down the road at full throttle for a few minutes and you may find your exhaust looks much cleaner, if so, ask him to test it again.
|
|
Thanks guys. Any idea how the fuelling is adjusted.
One thing I'm unclear in. How is the fuel delivered to the diesel injection pump ? I have hot starting problems also, and have to pump the primer a few times. (I just replaced the primer pump/filter housing by the way). It ALWAYS starts cold even in sub-zero temps. Where is the pump that delivers the fuel to the distrubution pump under normal running conditions. Is it "sucked" through by a pump housed in the injection pump ?
Thanks again.....ebt
|
Would there be any point in taking the injectors out and cleaning them ? Reason I ask is that if there was a problem, I would have thought it would have resulted in less fuel rather than too much !!...........ebt
|
It doesn't have a fuel lift pump, the fuel is drawn by the transfer pump actually in the injection pump, thats why you get air ingress from a faulty joint, the whole system from the tank to the pump is under vacuum.
I still think you problem could be soot, try giving it a good thrash. There is nothing you can do to improve the injectors, they are unlikely to cause a problem anyway, the pressure setting of the injectors will drop as they age which will result in slightly more fuel being injected but I wouldn't have thought enough to make it smoke severely. Pumps are also normally very reliable so I wouldn't think that was the problem.
|
Thanks Peter, i was always under the impression that these older, more simple diesels went on and on. A few people here have said I should give it a good thrashing prior to the test.
I'm not sure I do have an "over fuel" situation as this is probably one of the most fuel efficient cars I've ever owned averaging about 47-48 mpg.
Any ideas on the hot start issue ?
As mentioned earlier, it NEVER fails to cold start, and as you might remember from last year, I live in winter temps down to -30c but averaging -15c. However, when I go to town and park up, I quite often have to depress the priming pump a few times. It gets hard and offers back pressure after about 2-3 depressions. I have installed a new priming pump/fuel filter housing. Not sure it was Ford genuine, maybe a pattern replacement as I got it from eBay. Still have the same hoy start symptoms. I replaced the small piece of black tubing from the fuel pre-heater to the pump housing with some clear, and when I have the problem, and depress the pump, bubbles of air can be seen being drawn thru/from the heater into the pump, then it goes hard and all starts immediately. The fuel heater is first in line from the tank, then comes the pump/filter then onto the injection pump, so the air seems to be coming from the tank side UNLESS, when I siwtch the engine off, the air is coming from the injector pump side and siphoning back to the tank side before I draw it back again as stated above.
I thought I might have had a leaky diaphragm in the pump, which is why I replaced it, but still got the problem.
Any ideas ? Thanks again.............ebt
|
Give it a really hard thrashing. A good ten minutes of sustained high-rev action. That should clear out the soot.
Then when you take it back for the test, make sure the engine is hot and it's just had a good run.
|
|
|
Thanks Peter, i was always under the impression that these older, more simple diesels went on and on. A few people here have said I should give it a good thrashing prior to the test.
I'm not sure I do have an "over fuel" situation as this is probably one of the most fuel efficient cars I've ever owned averaging about 47-48 mpg.
Any ideas on the hot start issue ?
As mentioned earlier, it NEVER fails to cold start, and as you might remember from last year, I live in winter temps down to -30c but averaging -15c. However, when I go to town and park up, I quite often have to depress the priming pump a few times. It gets hard and offers back pressure after about 2-3 depressions. I have installed a new priming pump/fuel filter housing. Not sure it was Ford genuine, maybe a pattern replacement as I got it from eBay. Still have the same hot start symptoms. I replaced the small piece of black tubing from the fuel pre-heater to the pump housing with some clear, and when I have the problem, and depress the pump, bubbles of air can be seen being drawn thru/from the heater into the pump, then it goes hard and all starts immediately. The fuel heater is first in line from the tank, then comes the pump/filter then onto the injection pump, so the air seems to be coming from the tank side UNLESS, when I switch the engine off, the air is coming from the injector pump side and siphoning back to the tank side before I draw it back again as stated above.
I thought I might have had a leaky diaphragm in the pump, which is why I replaced it, but still got the problem.
Any ideas ? Thanks again.............ebt
|
Reverse light switch should be on front of g/box(between box & rad).
|
I would certainly say that your hot start problem is due to air ingress, I didn't know they used a fuel heater on Fords but that could well be where the problem is, the old Peugeot/ Citroen ones used to fail for a pastime, the metal would go pourous.
|
Hmm.....interesting comment on the fuel heater Peter.
(Yes, air ingress is almost definately the issue, just a matter of finding it). I've made up a transparent link from the output of the pump/filter to the injector pump that I intend to use as a diagnostic aid. I had a couple of spare bosch connectors.
The problem is, is that it's not very easy to bypass.
Unfortunately the feed to it, from the tank, uses quite hard black plastic tubing that is heat shrunk onto it.
(As mentioned previously, I replaced the output from it to the primer/filter housing with some clear tube and used copper wire around the output of the heater to tightly bind it. (The other end uses a propietary (Bosch) fitting that is a push fit onto he pump/filter).
Any ideas how I could bypass it as a diagnostic aid ? The only way I can think it to cut the black tube and somehow rig a connection from the cut to the pump/filter housing.
I assume the hard black plastic tube is installed with a special tool/heater as it's also bent where it needs to be and maintains shape.
(I had toyed with the idea of having a small test tank of fuel, under the bonnet, fed straight into the injector pump !!!
|
|
|
Thanks for the info on the reversing switch., Think I've found it, according to the wire colour coding in my Haynes manual. (The location they give is hopeless, they think it's underneath).
It's almost directly under the fuel priming pump, sitting on top of the transmission. To get to it easily, I need to take the top of the air filter box off and the large air pipe that runs from the filter box to the turbo. Defo the switch though. Both bulbs are good and the circuit shares fuse 24 with the indicators, which are working. I've got no +ve feed to the light clusters when in reverse (ignition on). Tomorrow (weather dependant), I'll ensure I've got a good feed from the fuse to the switch. If so, it's a case of taking the switch out. Have to say, it looks bigger and more complicated than it should.
Will advise............ebt
|
I think the only option is to cut the pipe, can you get some flexible pipe to slide over it? or a length of clear plastic pipe would be even better, you have the diagnostics in place for the next time! If you can't get some the right size, can you find a bit that will fit inside it, or a metal section with plastic at each end - I'm sure you can find something.
|
The 1997 TD has a fuel heater,on end of head next to filter-power to it is module controlled.
|
The 1997 TD has a fuel heater,on end of head next to filter-power to it is module controlled.
Update on reversing light switch. Definately WAS at the top of the transmission, underneath the primer/filter housing.
Took off the plug and shorted it out and hey presto, reversing lights lit. Took the switch itself out (2 x torx bolts) and tested switch and hey presto, worked fine.
Anyway, cleaned the plug and switch connectors really well and lubricated the slider inside the switch. Also had someone out the lever into reverse a few times to ensure the actuator inside the tranmission was moving freely.
Reassembled and now everything is absolutely fine. Phew.....
Edited by Englishbullterrier on 27/01/2011 at 14:34
|
|
I think the only option is to cut the pipe, can you get some flexible pipe to slide over it? or a length of clear plastic pipe would be even better, you have the diagnostics in place for the next time! If you can't get some the right size, can you find a bit that will fit inside it, or a metal section with plastic at each end - I'm sure you can find something.
Peter, update -
Luckily the fuel line coming from the tank is terminated (factory heat shrunk) over a length of 8mm steel pipe. I used 2 spare bosch connectors and a short (15cm) piece of transparent tubing to bypass the fuel heater altogether.
Now I have to wait until I visit town again, and have a hot engine to see whether there's any change. The problem manifests itself VERY frequently and virtually evertime I stop for a minute or two, I have to use the primer.
It will be interesting to see, if it still fails, (and having used transparent tube) whether I can see any signs of air being drawn from the tank side. If so, I'll be at a loss :-)
Will keep you informed.......ebt
|
OK hope it goes well.
Hi Pete, don't know if you're still monitoring this thread, but just wanted to pass something by you.
Living where I do, for 4-5 months a year we have snow and sub-zero temps, sometimes lower than -25c, but averaging I guess -5c to -15c. It is quite common here to start your car and leave it running for about 20 minutes before driving off, to de-ice it and warm it up.
(2 weeks ago, although unusual, an ice storm left 1/4" of solid ice encapsulating the car !)
Trying to keep my costs down, I tend to upshift where possible, hence revs are never very high.
I assume this could really exacerbate the issue of high emissions and black exhaust smoke (even some particulates left on the snow after revving whilst stationary) ?
Cheers............ebt
|
Yes, I'm still here. That type of driving will cause the exhaust to soot up as there is never enough velocity in the exhaust gas to shift it - until you rev it. I drive like that all the time, but then I'm old! Best way for economy though, and engine life.
Peter
|
Yes, I'm still here. That type of driving will cause the exhaust to soot up as there is never enough velocity in the exhaust gas to shift it - until you rev it. I drive like that all the time, but then I'm old! Best way for economy though, and engine life.
Peter
Me too ! (maybe)
|
Update for you Pete.
Passed emissions test today. On failure last week, the measurement was 8.37 m-1.
Today, after some high rev driving for about 8km, (around 4k rpm and about 100km/h) it sailed through at 2.56 m-1.
So, it was really all down to driving like an old f*** (and trying to conserve diesel !)
Last thing to fix is the hot start issue. As mentioned, I've isolated the fuel heater completely from the fuel route and it's STILL b***** failing when hot. Cold starts, after standing all night (even in sub-zero temps down to -10c for a few days) are 100% good.
Occasionally too, when the engine's hot, it will stall at idle, like a traffic light or stopped traffic. Only way to restart is depress the primer. It goes hard with back pressure after 2-3 depressions.
I assume that somehow the fuel is draining away from the injector pump as there's not a single pot firing when attempting to hot start. What do you think ? (No sign of leaking fuel anywhere !)
Maybe I'll try and isolate the primer/filter housing from the route and see then. Can't think of anthing else to try.
Do you think it possible that there's an air leak at the back (fuel tank) side of the injector pump allowing in air. I'm quickly becoming stumped !
|
Good, glad you got rid of the soot, I always give mine a good thrash on the way to the MOT, the garage is about five miles away but mostly on a fast road.
Can't remember where we got with the fuel problem, have you changed the filter? Next time it does it undo the fuel filler cap and see if there is a vacuum in there, you will hear the 'whoosh' if there is, if so the breather has probably got blocked.
Peter
|
Ah, there's a thought Peter. So far I've replaced the primer/fuel filter housing and filter (with new) and bypassed the fuel heater - still fails.
Don't know where the tank breather is, but it's definately a possibility. Especially as it always starts overnight, which would give it enough time to bleed a little air in and equalise the system.
With all the snow/grit/crap here on the roads, wherever the breather is, it could possibly be blocked. Any ideas where in this silly car ?
I only have a quarter of a tank of fuel at present, so maybe, when in town and engines hot, I'll run with he filler cap off.
Thanks again Peter, I'll keep you updated..............ebt
|
The vent always used to be in the filler cap but I'm not sure now, I once had a Vauxhall Cresta that the tank had collapsed on due to the breather being blocked.
|
Interesting Peter, "Haynes" says there's a vent pipe at the rear of the tank. ("The handbrake cable is secured to the vent pipe outlet with a cable tie") .
So, gotta try and get under it and trace to pipe to see where it terminates. Problem is road is 100% ice and snow.............haha
Will advise...........ebt
|
|
|
|
.
Edited by Englishbullterrier on 27/01/2011 at 14:34
|
Vent pipes? IIRC the diesel has a red filler cap(vented)and petrol a non-vented black cap(for evaporative emissions).The pipe from the top of the tank has nothing to do with tank venting whilst running-it is there to get air out of the top of the tank whilst filling and for this reason the filler nozzle should be put as far into the filler as possible to avoid the venting air.
|
Thanks for that JC2 and Peter. I assumed it was for venting when drawing fuel.
Anyway, I am GOING b***** crazy ! Today I ran without the fuel filler cap and with the fuel heater bypassed.
Again, started immediately even after standing out overnight in -5c. Drove 10 miles and parked up for a doc's appointment.
Came out and lo and behold, FAILED TO START again. A few depression of the primer pump and it started IMMEDIATELY.
I really am at a loss. All I can now think is the (new) possibly non-genuine primer/fuel filter assembly (obtained from eBay) is allowing fuel to drain back. However, why would it cold start ?
Any help at this stage would be much apprecaited.........ebt
|
Oh dear, back to the drawing board. It seems certain from your last comments that the problem is due to air ingress, why it doesn't do it from cold is puzzling, the only thought I have is that the leak is occuring in something that expands when it gets hot.
The only way you can be sure to find the leak is to replace sections of the fuel line with clear plastic, starting as far back as you can get to make sure the fault isn't at the tank end. You could try either side of the primer pump and then the filter, at least that will tell you where abouts in the system the problem is.
If you can park the car for a while on a steep hill, facing downwards, so that the tank is higher than the engine - you might be able to see a leak.
Peter
|
The thing that I don't understand is that (surely) air ingress would also mean fkuid egress, ie, a leak, Although maybe it's so infinitesimal that it might not be seen.
Also, when I depress the pump, no air bubbles can be seen. (I have a small section of clear tube between the fuel heater (now back in circuit) and the pump.
I think it's one of two things -
The new primer/filter assembly I put in has a dodgy valve allowing fuel to back filter
or
There is an air leak in the transfer pump, BUT, in this scenario, I would expect to see some air bubbles.
I forgot to also mention that I replaced the preformed pipe from the pump/filter to the injection pump with a genuine Ford component.
Next step is I will try and work out a temporary way to bypass the primer/filter assembly. Not easy for 2 reasons. Feed and flow are terminated with 2 x Bosch 8mm slip on connectors. I will need to try and source some 8mm pipe. And of course, I will need to get the car started without a primer pump ! (Wish I had one of those old bulb primers !! haha
I will let you know what happens Peter................ebt
|
Just a thought Peter.
When I get to town, maybe I'll pull the inlet of the primer pump/filter off. I assume that oher than a little residual fuel, nothing else should come out as the (inlet) one way valve should stop this.
I wish I had one of those bulb primers that I oculd put in circuit.......ebt
|
You won't get a fuel leak unless you put the system under pressure i.e. park on a hill, as the transfer pump in the injector pump is drawing fuel in so the whole system is under a vacuum. Forgot about your clear pipe,
If there are no bubbles when it won't start from hot, I would think there are only two options, either the transfer pump has lost efficiency, although I have never heard of that happening, or there is a restriction in the fuel supply which it can't overcome, the only way you can check that for sure is to run the engine from a container of fuel under the bonnet.
Peter
|
You won't get a fuel leak unless you put the system under pressure i.e. park on a hill, as the transfer pump in the injector pump is drawing fuel in so the whole system is under a vacuum. Forgot about your clear pipe,
If there are no bubbles when it won't start from hot, I would think there are only two options, either the transfer pump has lost efficiency, although I have never heard of that happening, or there is a restriction in the fuel supply which it can't overcome, the only way you can check that for sure is to run the engine from a container of fuel under the bonnet.
Peter
Yes Pete, I had (and will) consider that). I think I have worked out a way to route the incoming diesel from the tank direct to the injection pump. I need to ensure however that the tube I use is full of fuel, as there will be no primer in circuit. As always, I'll keep you posted.....
|
Tried but can't bypass primer/filter as fuel simply runs back away from injector pump.
Now sourcing a bulb primer, an additional low pressure one way valve and a hosetail should I need to make up a temporary tank under the bonnet for more testing.
Might be a few days but will, of course, keep you informed.........ebt
|
If you have a good battery you should be able to start it without priming, it will take a while to draw the fuel up but it should do it. If you can jack the rear up it will help.
|
Thanks...............ebt
That's the strange thing. When I do get this hot start failure, no matter how much I crank it, it just wont start until I press the primer a few times, and then it jumps into life :-(
Edited by Englishbullterrier on 04/02/2011 at 14:55
|
I wonder if you have an obstrution in the supply line? Tank filter perhaps, Can you disconnect the pipe and blow it through to the tank with compressed air.
|
Hi Peter, I have a low pressure 8mm one way valve on the way. I'm gonna place it close to the input to the injector pump. (I've also a bulp primer coming).
If it still fails, it would indicate some form or injector pump leak, do you think ?.....ebt
|
Well ,that's a good start, a pump leak is possible but the fuel is under presure once its inside so it should be leaking fuel if that were the case. I think it uses a Lucas pump doesn't it? Bosch pumps suffer if the injector leak off pipes are leaking. The only possible pump fault I would think could cause the problem would be a worn transfer pump, but as I said, I have never heard of that problem although it is of course possible, I would remedy that by fitting an external electric pump.
Peter
|
That would be a novel solution (if the transfer pump is defective).
I assume they're available with flow sensors etc so that it will only deliver fuel when required and not pump all the time ?
I could easily wire it into the switched ignition side.
Will keep you posted...............ebt
|
In the unlikely event of that being the problem, you don't have to worry about pressure regulation as surplus fuel goes back to the tank via the return pipe.
Many years ago I used an SU electric pump on a Morris Oxford that I had fitted a diesel engine to.
Peter
|
Hi Pete, I thought that was just the excess flowing back from the injectors to the pump ?
Do you mean that any excess fuel at all is returned and that it wouldn't be a problem to use a constant flow pump ? Sorry, I'm pretty thick with regard to diesel pumps......ebt
Edited by Englishbullterrier on 05/02/2011 at 19:20
|
No problem. Later type pumps are of the 'through flow' type, well I say later, probably since the '70s, the idea is that there is a continual flow of fuel through the pump, this makes it much easier to start again if you run out of fuel and also allows air to flow back to the tank without going into the pump, but of course if there is enough air ir will still stop it.
If you look on the top of your pump you will see an inlet pipe at the back, and at the front near the throttle lever there is the return pipe, the leak off from the injectors is also connected to it.
As I said before, I would be very surprised if that is the fault - but stranger things have happened. I have been running diesels since 1959 and have never had that problem, although the early ones didn't have that arrangement and if you ran out of fuel you had to bleed the whole system through which you were lucky to do without flattening the battery, but they did have a lift pump on the engine so you got a fuel leak rather than an air leak.
Peter
|
Still waiting on bulb primer and one-way valve....
|
Peter, whilst waiting, a couple of things sprang to mind.
In a "flow thru" transfer/injection pump, what causes the back pressure felt at the priming pump when depressed a few times. (Would it be the engine stop solonoid ?)
If the ignition was on, should I normally be able to pump, using the primer, feeling no back pressure, as the fuel would simply flow through the injector pump back to the tank ?
Just a thought.........ebt
|
Just advising that bulb primer and one way valve arrived this morning.
I will try installing the one way valve between the injector pump and the priming pump/filter housing first. If this solves the fault, I will assume I have a leaky valve in the priming pump.
Unfortunately it's -15c outside at present and might be for a few days. As soon as it warms up, I'll install it.............ebt
|
Sorry, missed your previous post, yes, the stop solonoid, should pump through when its open. Been quite warm here today, about 10C outside, 32C + in our conservatory! Supposed to be miserable all day tomorrow though.
Hope you get on allright
Peter
|
OK, braved the -19c weather this lunchtime and installed the one-way-valve between priming pump and injection pump.
Now waiting for run to town this week to see is it still fails on a hot engine. I REALLY will be non-plussed if it still does and maybe then the only resolution will be to fit a 12v fuel pump in the same place (after removing the one-way-valve).
However, I will still elimate the priming pump/filter as I now have a bulb primer in my greasy hands !!
Will advise..............ebt
(Is it possible to post photos/jpg's here at all ?)
|
Minus 26c / Minus 14.8f here this morning. Car cranks for 50 seconds minimum and starts (with 2 batteries in parallel).......result.........ebt
|
That doesn't sound to bad for that temperature, my son has one of those engines in his P100 pick up and that's a pig to start at anything near freezing . I have recently bought a Peugeot 406 Hdi diesel and that starts instantly at below freezing without glow plugs! It also has a diesel fired auxilliary heater - fantastic.
Peter
|
Stop bragging Peter ! lol
I've just put my battery on charge for the night......ebt
(Feedback on the main issue soon).
|
That doesn't sound to bad for that temperature, my son has one of those engines in his P100 pick up and that's a pig to start at anything near freezing . I have recently bought a Peugeot 406 Hdi diesel and that starts instantly at below freezing without glow plugs! It also has a diesel fired auxilliary heater - fantastic.
Peter
So, how does that work then Peter ? Do all modern diesels have no glow plugs ?
|
They do have glow plugs but don't generally need them, my glow plug light shows for about a second but if you just get in and turn the key it starts almost instantly.
The reason is that modern common rail and a few previous to that are direct injection, the fuel is injected direct into the cylinder so there is no heat loss as with your engine where the fuel is ignited in a seperate 'swirl' chamber in the head, by the time it has been pushed through a small opening into the chamber and has 'swirled' around in it, to give a good mix, it has cooled significantly and needs the added heat from the plugs.
For years I have fought shy of entertaining such an engine as faults are not easy to diagnose and repair, I have been running Citroen XM td's for the last 15 years, fantastic comfort and space plus 50 mpg on a journey, they have IDI engines but very good ones, about the best made I reckon, good for at least 300,000 miles and super low down torque with the 12 valve head - you do have to use the glow plugs though!
This Peugeot Hdi engine is based on the previous XUD engine as the the XM one, When I was looking at the Peugeot's I noticed that there were quite a few advertised with in excess of 300,000 miles recorded, that did a lot to inspire my confidence. As you can't effectly repair them without the aid of a diagnostic code reader - I have relucantly purchased one.
I have always repaired my own cars but at 71 I don't bend as easily as I did but am hoping to keep it up as long as possible.
Peter
|
Hi Pete, not sure understand the difference (in operation) between a DI and non-DI combustion chamber.
Surely, if the non-DI fuel/air mix is ignited in this "swirl chamber" it would be the same as igniting it in the actual cylinder head itself, as there is no mechanical delineation between this chamber and the head cavity itself ? Hence, the power produced by the burn is "effectively" in the same place ? Confused.com !
By the way, I have an '(ex-Metropolitan Police) '05 1.7 CDTI Astra Mk V as my UK car, what sort of diesel lump would that be ? (And yes, the glow plug lights for a very short amount of time and it starts veet easily).......ebt
(Off to town today for the first time since installing the one-way valve, will let you know the outcome.....)
Edited by Englishbullterrier on 16/02/2011 at 10:23
|
On an IDI engine the swirl chamber is machined into the head and then almost blanked off by an insert, leaving a very small aperture for the air to enter, that's what causes the swirl, the pumping friction loss is partly what gives lower efficiency from the IDI, it also causes heat from the compressed air to be absorbed by the metal and water surrounding the chamber. The fuel is injected into the air in the chamber then the burning gas has to go back through the orifice back into the main part of the cylinder - more friction loss.
If you look at an IDI injector it is quite short as it only has to reach the swirl chamber which is above the cylinder, on a DI engine the injector is much longer as it injects the fuel directly on the the top of the piston, which also has a swirl chamber built into it.
very old diesels were all direct injection but the fuel couldn't be made to mix effectively above about 2000 rpm, the IDI engine was introduced in the late '50s to make an engine suitable for car use, one of the first being the Perkins 4/99 which gave 43 bhp at 4000 rpm. I fitted one to a Vauxhall Velox in 1959. The development of very high pressure injection now allows direct injection at reasonably high speeds.
Yes, your Astra would be a common rail DI engine, 10% or more efficient then and IDI and as a result generating a lot less heat.
Peter
|
Many thanks for the education Peter.
My Escort, so far so good. Drove to town, 15km, engine up to temp. I parked and moved it within town 3 times. Prior to the latest "fix", each time I would have had to depress the primer 3-4 times prior to it starting.
Today, it started each time with no problems. !!!!!!! However, I'll obviously prefer some more instances of this before I can celebrate !
IF it is the fix, it must mean that the non-Ford (pattern) primer pump/filter housing has a leak in one of he one-way valves......grr.
Will not close off for another week or so...............ebt
Edited by Englishbullterrier on 16/02/2011 at 15:16
|
Well done, hope it lasts.
|
Closing - all seems well after one-way valve ws installed. Can only assume one of the one-way valves in the primer pump/filter housing was allowing fuel to run back to the tank. Thanks all, especially Peter........ebt
|
|
|
|
|
|
|