What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - zlyman
Which is the better option - both 2.0, both petrol, both fsh. Mazda 98 R 63,000 Peugeot 98 R 53,000???????????
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Jonathan {p}
626 every time

I own one and am very happy with it. Less likely to give you trouble than the Peugeot.

I would also bet its got better spec than the 406, elec windows, mirrors, sunroof, climate or ac.

Jonathan
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - zlyman
Thanks Jonathan - I was leaning towards the Mazda i must admit. What's it like for running costs and petrol etc.?
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Jonathan {p}
Running costs are about average, parts are expensive compared to other manufacturers, but you don't need them as much.

Tyres are about £40 each, so not too bad.

Petrol, I get about 440 miles from a tank, I could get more if its all motorway so I would imagine thats about 35mpg. Don't bother with mazda servicing, find a good local independent garage for servicing. Mine's the 113bhp LXi, expect poorer economy from the 135bhp GSI.

Hope that helps.

Jonathan
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - zlyman
That's great - thanks for your help
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Vin {P}
We ran a 626 for three or four years (mamory beginning to fade with old age). It was a 96N 2.0i and was used mainly for short runs by my wife. By all reasonable accounts, such use should have wrecked the thing, but in the time we owned it, we replaced an exhaust backbox (£50 or so) and a rear light bulb. MOT's passed with the payment of the test fee only and it failed to start only once, when my daughter turned on the interior light and my wife didn't notice. The AA chappie who turned up in the morning told my wife he was glad it was a flat battery, as he'd never worked on a Mazda before! Part of the credit for its reliability might have been the 6 monthly oil changes (about every 2,500 miles with wifey's driving pattern)

Performance is excellent to surprising; the only downer about the car as a whole was that the power steering is a little light. OK once you're used to it, but if you're constantly changing cars and used to heavier steering you can wander a bit on the motorway.

We sold it when I found a Mazda Xedos9 to replace it; the choice of make was entirely due to my satisfaction with the 626.

V
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Vin {P}
mamory and toping, of course.
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - footy_72
agree with the opinions on mazda reliability - absolutely flawless.

honda accord is definately worth a look though
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Aprilia
Don't neglect Nissan Primera 2.0i. Superb engine and outstanding roadholding. Parts more readily available and rather cheaper than the Mazda. If you can live with unimaginative styling then they are a great car.
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Jonathan {p}
honda accord is definately worth a look though


The only problem with the accord's in this age and price bracket is that they are 4 door saloons. The hatch only came along in 1999, so will be much more expensive. I also think they are not as spacious as either the 626 or the 406.

Jonathan
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Chad.R
>> honda accord is definately worth a look though
>>
The only problem with the accord's in this age and price
bracket is that they are 4 door saloons. The hatch
only came along in 1999, so will be much more expensive.
I also think they are not as spacious as either
the 626 or the 406.
Jonathan


The 406 is also a 4 door saloon and was never offered as a hatchback. In fairness the rear seats do fold to allow a load through but still may not be as flexible as proper hatchback. The estate version should provide ample space for most though.

The majority of 626s I've seen are hatchbacks and seem to be very spacious. I think someone (Aprilia?) mentioned that the the auto boxes can be a bit of a weak point.

Chad.
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Sooty Tailpipes
Weaknesses on 626s in my experience are...
HLA noise
Auto failure (change fluid every 24k to help avoid)
Notchy manuals due to brass synchro failure
Rear brake capliers on earlier models (some reports on later ones too with redesigned seal) - £200+ to replace each
Hatchback body is too flexible
tailgate creaks/rattles due to body twisting
Flimsy interior trim
Anti-roll bar link problems.
Peeling clearcoat
Check all doorlocks and tailgate lock work with key.


They hardly ever break down, true, but do everything but.
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Vin {P}
Weaknesses on 626s in my experience are...
HLA noise
Auto failure (change fluid every 24k to help avoid)
Notchy manuals due to brass synchro failure
Rear brake capliers on earlier models (some reports on later ones
too with redesigned seal) - £200+ to replace each
Hatchback body is too flexible
tailgate creaks/rattles due to body twisting
Flimsy interior trim
Anti-roll bar link problems.
Peeling clearcoat
Check all doorlocks and tailgate lock work with key.
They hardly ever break down, true, but do everything but.


Not doubting Sooty tailpipes has seen all of the above, but my sample of 2 [bought one for father-in-law] suffered none of the above - his had a handbrake problem that could have been the caliper problem above, though. Don't know what "HLA noise" is.

Keys, good point - Mazda do a key for when you get your car valet parked (all the time, of course!) that doesn't open the boot. Make sure it's not the only key with the car.

V
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - DL
I guess the 406 has lost then!
--
groups.msn.com/honestjohn - Pictures say a thousand words..... Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Sooty Tailpipes
Not saying don't buy the 626, I'm just giving things to look for seeing as thet's what seems to have won here....
A couple more, are to pull out the spark plug leads, and check there is no oil on the tips, as this signals a leaking timing cover, not a big job, but it can ruin the leads and make them swell and hard to pull out as they create a vacuum as you pull them out.

Also both V6 and I4 engines have timing belt tensioner issues.
These should be replaced with the belts (but are often not)

Listen for a noise under the bonnet which is relative to engine rpm, this could be a loose belt whipping and making a ort of Citroen 2CV noise.
Mazda 626 or Peugeot 406 - Aprilia
You should avoid a 626 auto at all costs. It uses the Ford CD4E transmission and seems to be even less reliable in the 626 than in the Mondeo. I believe that in the US there is a 'class action' against Mazda due to so many owners experiencing premature failure (60k miles is a typical failure point). I was asked to look at one that kept 'dropping out of drive' - it only had 12k miles on it and was owned by a vicar - unforunately the box was burnt out!

Otherwise the 626 is not a bad car.

Do consider a 2.0i Primera though:

1. Bodyshell is much more rigid
2. Higher safety rating
3. Cheaper spares, and more pattern parts available.
4. Far better handing and roadholding.
5. Lovely smooth chain-cam engine which is more powerful.
6. Saloon, hatch and estate body.

Look at some P11 models (mid-96 - 99, or P11-144, 99-2002).