What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Any - Not changing the car - oldroverboy.

Unless something catastrophic happens have now decided to run the MG ZS as long as is practical.

Not for financial reasons but because of the problems associated with the "new tech". inc internal combustion engines.

Secondly, will be 70 next year and now only really drive when necessary, Bus service till 7pm from town is good, last few every half hour, daytime every 20 minutes and about 100 metres from bus stop, also have bus pass.

The M25 going to west london at the weekend was the usual every man for himself, undertaking, sudden car parked without hard shoulder on the A1 below South Mimms, Hazard Warning lights very faint, (no problem as we both pay attention to the road ahead) but able to slow and then pass safely.

In short getting tired of the "circus" on the roads.

Edited by oldroverboy. on 20/01/2020 at 08:26

Any - Not changing the car - Cris_on_the_gas

My experience is every time I trade a car then lose money. If you trade less often then you lose less money.

Any - Not changing the car - Terry W

I have but a few years before I hit the magic three score and ten - but I don't think I will want to give up driving unless forced upon me by events. However driving is no longer an enjoyable experience - just a way of getting from where I am now to somewhere else as painlessly as possible. Age or traffic volumes - I'm not quite sure.

But like you I have no particular desire to change car unless necessary. I no longer feel the urge to treat every journey as a competitive event, don't really care what others think of my conveyance, and save a chunk of money in the process.

Although retired, finance is not an issue but a couple of thousand a year not spent on depreciation means I feel that more relaxed about spending money on other luxuries - holidays, meals out, hobbies etc.

Any - Not changing the car - barney100

When I retired I bought myself an SLK 250 which I've had for 5 years now. I'm of the same mind as Terry W in that you mostly lose when you change a car and mainly use the car to get to my pastimes at a leisurely rate.

Any - Not changing the car - madf

I decided to buy my Jazz in 2012 as the last ic car I would ever buy...

Even then it was clear that diesel was a dead end...

Any - Not changing the car - focussed

I decided to buy my Jazz in 2012 as the last ic car I would ever buy...

Even then it was clear that diesel was a dead end...

I disagree - diesels fuelled by biofuels is the power source of the future.

They grow rape seed for biofuels all around us here in the French countryside.

Any - Not changing the car - madf

I decided to buy my Jazz in 2012 as the last ic car I would ever buy...

Even then it was clear that diesel was a dead end...

I disagree - diesels fuelled by biofuels is the power source of the future.

They grow rape seed for biofuels all around us here in the French countryside.

Joke of the week.. you surely are not serious?

Any - Not changing the car - alan1302

I decided to buy my Jazz in 2012 as the last ic car I would ever buy...

Even then it was clear that diesel was a dead end...

I disagree - diesels fuelled by biofuels is the power source of the future.

They grow rape seed for biofuels all around us here in the French countryside.

And how many fields would you need to grown enough to replace all diesel cars? Don't see that happening.

Any - Not changing the car - Bromptonaut

And how many fields would you need to grown enough to replace all diesel cars? Don't see that happening.

Exactly. Biofuels might have a place, particularly if they can be produced as a by product.

Aside from space constraint mentioned above there must be a serious question over using fields for fuel when we cannot feed the population.

Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T

<< there must be a serious question over using fields for fuel when we cannot feed the population. >>

The Brazilians grow large quantities of sugar-cane to make ethanol for fuel. Just as daft, but I guess it saves their balance of payments. Won't do the rain forest any favours though.

Any - Not changing the car - madf

<< there must be a serious question over using fields for fuel when we cannot feed the population. >>

The Brazilians grow large quantities of sugar-cane to make ethanol for fuel. Just as daft, but I guess it saves their balance of payments. Won't do the rain forest any favours though.

And to grow rape we HAVE to use large quantities of pesticides or the rapeseed beetle eats the crop..

ANd then luvvies tell us we should be eating avocadoes and drink almond milk - the latter produced in areas made lifeless by pesticides..

I despair...The holier than thou preachiung by people whose prerred lifesttyle is worse than meat eaters when using pesticides and destroying the planet shows their diet either rots their brains or destroys their ability to think critically...

Rant over.

Any - Not changing the car - focussed

All sorts of crops and biomass can be used to produce fuels, both aromatic and diesel.

The diesel engine in various forms will be with us for a long time yet.

Any - Not changing the car - gordonbennet

Not retired yet, due next year but i actually enjoy my job and the company are most reluctant to lose reliable people, i will defer pension whilst still working (no point in paying tax on every penny earned), may for some reason not pass the HGV medical, annual once 65, which will make my decision for me, though there's enough work around the place to keep me going.

As for cars, the Landcruiser is now 15 years old, the Forester 12, both are in superb condition, if i stay on at work we'll keep both for the forseeable, both enjoy slow depreciation and have proved completely reliable, if and when i retire fully then one will have to go i suppose, that is going to be difficult decision.

As above have no intention of replacing either, there's almost nothing sold in Britain officially i would want even if free, if the govt of the day tax our old cars off the road i absolutely refuse to be forced by some appratchik into a scalextric car, and we'll do without, the LC in its condition will always sell easily for export to more sensible countries, the Forester probably won't be worth enough to worry about but the engine will always be in demand so an easy breaker.

Just changed the power steering fluid on the pair of them, got to keep that cost effective maintenance up.:-)

Any - Not changing the car - Theophilus

Came the same conclusion last week - my Toyota Verso will be 5 years old in a fortnight's time and the 5yr warranty expires. I've never had need to call on the warranty but most of my driving now is 1,500 - 2,000 mile journeys on holidays to France with family. Not keen on breaking down anytime soon in rural France with no nearby agents, so was semi-seriously thinking of looking for another nearly new MPV.

However, the Verso has been reliable, suits our needs for an occasional 7-seater, VED is only £30 per year & French emission rating 2 so no problems there ...

Decision made up when I got quote from Toyota to extend my manufacturers warranty for another 2 years - total price under £500 for 2 years extended warranty, including 2 years MOTs, and 2 years European travel insurance. I reckon the MOT & insurance would cost over £100 per year, so the cost of the warranty comes down to under £150 per year ... no brainer!

Edited by Theophilus on 20/01/2020 at 14:04

Any - Not changing the car - Theophilus

As an afterthought - I wonder whether the responses from those of us in their 60s-70s represent a fair proportion of those who dwell in the Back Room - and explain why the intrusive adverts are so ineffective in persuading us to part with our cash, and thus the present financial plight of the HJ.com site :-(

Any - Not changing the car - barney100

I've been a bit penny wise pound foolish most of my time. Cars have always been a temptation but now when I get the change the car urge I sit back 'til it goes away.

Any - Not changing the car - Alby Back

My car is one of a small fleet of company cars which come under my supervision and budget.

I, and the other users, do a fairly high annual mileage so the sweet spot seems to be keeping any given car for 200,000 miles or five years, whichever comes first.

Provided they are serviced on time this seems to work well. Only disappointments have been a couple of failed DSG gearboxes on VWs. One of those ( a Golf ) at a painfully low mileage of 16,000, and the other ( a Passat ) at a slightly more tolerable 120,000. Contrary to reputation, Powershift boxes on several Fords ( Mondeos ) have been no trouble at all.

The Mercs ( E Class ) we've had seem to be nigh on indestructible things. Expensive to buy and service but 100% reliable, and keep a very sensible residual value even with big miles.

My wife's car is now 12 years old ( petrol manual Qashqai ) we keep muttering about changing it, but we've never had a problem with it. Never had so much as an advisory at MOT time and with "only" 80,000 on it, it seems possible that it will keep going for a good while yet unless she just gets bored with it.

Any - Not changing the car - oldroverboy.

For me, at least there is no more "pleasure" in driving, only a means to get from A to B where public transport is either not an option or silly money.

At the weekend it was a last minute dental appointment where Swmbo could be fitted in for a crown to be fitted, otherwise wait a week.

Shortly off to SPA, belgium for some treatment for SWMBO and some nice warm water and cold beer for me.

Options..

Can't fly to Liege from Stanstill. (no dogs allowed, no flights anyway.

Can't train.(eurostar) ditto no dogs..

Boat Harwich to Hook of Holland, silly money, overnight on boat, kennel for dog.

drive, sadly!!!!

Any - Not changing the car - nellyjak

We (The Missus and I) have just faced the same dilemma..do we or don't we renew her car.

Having had her Yaris for 4 years (it's now 6 years old and her third Yaris) with only 40k miles and in super duper condition...should we hang on to it..or change up.?

SO..we visited out local Toyota dealer...ostensibly to view/consider a newer Yaris....BUT they had a great deal on a brand new (pre-reg) Y20 Yaris...so we decided we should take the deal and bought it.!!...this is going to be her car for many, many years.!!!!

In my case I shall be hanging on to my trusty 2003 V6 Toyota Estima which I've had a for 4 years now..utterly reliable and has cost nothing but the usual consumables...luxury on wheels and is used as a MPV/Dayvan/Campervan.

I don't do that many miles (4-5k p.a.) now so I still enjoy the miles I drive...but I can largely choose the where and when..but I agree that the enjoyment is getting harder to find these days.

Any - Not changing the car - Alby Back

It is a little bit of a strange thing though isn't it ? ( and hey I'm just as "guilty" as the next person in this! )

But, when you buy a washing machine, a fridge, a watch, a pair of shoes or even a hat, by and large you'll just keep it until it no longer functions, or is uneconomical to repair.

With cars though, I'll bet we've all changed them when they had years of life left in them just because we could, or simply wanted to. Convincing ourselves that it was the right thing to do despite the inevitable and considerable costs involved.

Odd critters aren't we?

;-)

Any - Not changing the car - oldroverboy.
Odd critters aren't we?

;-)

None more so than me!

The tiring bit is also related to having to "visit" dealers and all the hassle of dealing with liars and (sometimes) thieves..

We''ll see how it goes...

Says he with an MGZS that just decided it wanted to behave like skippy this morning... Maybe a gallon of petrol and a box of matches will cure it, but if it goes, it aint getting replaced.

Any - Not changing the car - Alby Back

Part of life's pattern I suppose. My earliest cars were purchased purely on the basis of being functional but affordable, but then in time, it was possible to get ones I wanted but really didn't need, then the complexities of life take over, and it was back to ones I needed but didn't particularly want.

Now, I'm at the stage where I can ( if only temporarily ) have the sort of cars I both want and need, and eventually I'll end up, no doubt, with something I don't really want, but can see the need.

If you see what I mean?

;-)

Any - Not changing the car - John F

It works best when you buy quality. 'Buy the best, make it last' is an axiom I try to follow; from the mundane (our Mk1 auto Focus, nearly 20yrs old) to the flagship (Audi A8 sport quattro, 14yrs old.). Not forgetting the durable TR7 - 40 in May, so no VED or MoT required. Yippee! (The engine management system consists of two wires - one for the accelerator, one for the choke).

I wonder how long a 'bargain' Chinese MG will last without major attention?

Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T

<< The tiring bit is ... having to "visit" dealers and all the hassle of dealing with liars and (sometimes) thieves. >>

The only visit I have made to a dealership in the last 10 years was a couple of years back when SWMBO had just had a shoulder replacement and was thinking of switching to an auto in case of difficulty. She quite liked an auto i10, but after things had settled down she felt so much better that no change was made.

Otherwise I have made private sales and purchases now and then, of elderly Peugeots which I improve and enjoy for a few years before repeating the process. I don't expect to do that many more times though .... :-(

I've never made a dealer's eye light up - never bought brand-new, and only once spent over £10K.

Any - Not changing the car - FP

This thread chimed in with many of my own thoughts. I'm in my seventies now and although I aim to keep driving for as long as it's safe to do so, who knows how long that will be?

I always keep cars for a long time and have only once changed sooner than I really had to. I have never bought a new car, on the basis that the huge depreciation at the beginning of a car's life was something I wasn't going to finance.

Since I started driving at the age of 17 I've had these cars:

1. Messerschmitt three-wheeler – unreliable/engine seized

2. Vauxhall Viva with Brabham conversion (oh yes!) - rusted out

3. Vauxhall Firenza - unreliable

4. Vauxhall Chevette - floor rotted through

5. Vauxhall Astra #1 - written off in a rear-end collision

6. Vauxhall Astra #2 - wife kept it when we split up

7. Peugeot 205 - paint got really tatty

8. Fiat Punto 75 - got bored with it

9. Peugeot 306 - last MOT record (Sep 2016) shows 155,619 miles

10. Ford Focus Mk2 - currently 120k-plus

11. Mazda CX-5 - best car I’ve had. Maybe my last car?

So in 58 or so years of driving, eleven cars, some kept for longer than others and most racking up over 100k miles. (The Ford, now owned by my stepson, has done over 120k, all on the original clutch and exhaust, with minimal repairs.)

Edited by FP on 21/01/2020 at 18:36

Any - Not changing the car - edlithgow

ir.

With cars though, I'll bet we've all changed them when they had years of life left in them just because we could, or simply wanted to. Convincing ourselves that it was the right thing to do despite the inevitable and considerable costs involved.

Odd critters aren't we?

;-)

Nope.

Only ever changed (read scrapped) a car when forced to by circumstance (usually an inconveniently timed MOT failure), and usually felt guilty about it, since I'm pretty sure they were all savable.

(Perhaps apart from an 1800 Marina with a rotted spring hanger, which oddly IIRC is the only car I've ever sold, with the fault declared)..

This is probably because I've only ever bought old (pre- 90's) tech bangers.

I'd think newer cars would have to be thought of as more disposable.

I probably am an "odd critter" though.

Edited by edlithgow on 22/01/2020 at 16:27

Any - Not changing the car - Avant

Yes, we're all odd (or different, to put it more politely) - me more than most, as at an advanced age (71) I (a) like new cars and (b) still enjoy driving.

Fortunately we now live in rural north Dorset, instead of Berkshire near Reading, where it was getting less and less enjoyable to drive. The amount of potentially productive hours lost in Reading sitting at red traffic lights must be immense. I used to have to go to Colchester regularly when I was working and I sympathise greatly with ORB. Lovely old town but the traffic system works as badly as it does in Reading.

I still do some work, writing and examining, in semi-retirement, one benefit of which is to enable us to change cars regularly when the warranty is about to run out. Yes, of course by most financial considerations we shouldn't....but hey, you've only got one life.

That said, I think we might keep SWMBO's A3 petrol convertible (new last year) long-term. There are fewer reasonably-priced convertibles around to choose from than there were, so this one, whch does a lowish mileage, should hold its value. And it's red, and we like it.

Any - Not changing the car - Alby Back

Convertibles should be red.

Any - Not changing the car - thunderbird

Both myself and the Mrs get a nice pay rise shortly in the form of the state pension, that £17000 a year tax free extra coming into the house. We have both been living on our private pensions for a few years now so its money that will in reality be extra to our our existing requirements.

So its our intention to buy a new motor every 3 years from now on whilst we are still allowed to drive probably passing the newest car down to become the second car when we make the change. Theoretically the oldest car will never be no more than 6 years old.

It will be quite a shock when you consider that the last Focus I had and the Focus the Mrs had were both kept about 12 years.

Where we lived previously the chap bought himself a new motor when he retired aged 65 and said it would be the last car he ever bought. My cousin bought herself a new motor when she was 60 saying it would see her out.

What is it with these people, don't they know you cannot take it with you.

Spend an enjoy. I would hate to think that my relatives will be getting enough to enjoy a huge party at my expense when I am gone. In reality that will not happen, what's left is going to various animal charities.

Any - Not changing the car - Bromptonaut

Both myself and the Mrs get a nice pay rise shortly in the form of the state pension, that £17000 a year tax free extra coming into the house.

I thought the state pension was taxable (though obviously only if total income exceeds allowances).

https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-pension

Any - Not changing the car - galileo

Both myself and the Mrs get a nice pay rise shortly in the form of the state pension, that £17000 a year tax free extra coming into the house.

I thought the state pension was taxable (though obviously only if total income exceeds allowances).

https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-pension

They take any tax due off my company pension, having added the two together to calculate what's due.

Any - Not changing the car - thunderbird

Both myself and the Mrs get a nice pay rise shortly in the form of the state pension, that £17000 a year tax free extra coming into the house.

I thought the state pension was taxable (though obviously only if total income exceeds allowances).

https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-pension

It is indeed. I made the mistake probably because the only benefit I have ever dealt with in the past was attendance allowance for my parents and that was not taxable.

So after tax we will still be left with over £13500 a yer which is over £40,000 every 3 years.

Should buy us quite a nice motor me thinks.

Any - Not changing the car - oldroverboy.

I too have nice pensions. Property income and some savings and youngrovergirl has her own money but we are aiming for a place in the sun...

Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T

What is it with these people, don't they know you cannot take it with you. Spend and enjoy.

That's one way to look at things. Personally, altho I could afford to buy new occasionally, I'm just not tempted by up-to-date cars. At least as long as my old ones keep going, and that is all one can ask of them.

Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T

Convertibles should be red.

His sins were scarlet, but his cars were red ? :-)

Any - Not changing the car - Alby Back
That's Bellocs Andrew!
;-)
Any - Not changing the car - Hugh Watt

Convertibles should be red.

His sins were scarlet, but his cars were red ? :-)

Nice try, A-T, but not quite Hilaire-ious? ;-)

Any - Not changing the car - johncyprus

We too. Currently have a nineteen year old CLK and a 11 year old Honda Jazz, both are lightly used and are reliable. We had an itch a month ago and I considered buying a Merc which had only 18,000 miles but decided against it as driving an old car ( assuming it’s reliable ) is comparatively stress free. Being able to shrug off the odd scratch or supermarket trolley dink is priceless.

Edited by johncyprus on 21/01/2020 at 07:03

Any - Not changing the car - catsdad
I was set to keep my 2012 Civic 1.8 until it was 10 years plus. I maintained it accordingly (fsh, inc valve setting, gearbox oil, new brakes all round etc) but it started using oil. I ignored it for a year but it was getting steadily worse and googling suggested it's one of the few common issues with this model, especially 2012 vintage.

The choices were to soldier on with top-ups, or get it repaired at considerable cost, or look around for something else. I chose the latter and hence I now have the Golf 1.4. I doubt whether it will give me the six trouble free years (oil aside) I got from the Civic but, once that itch set in, buying seemed the answer.

I do intend to keep the Golf long term too but will aim to unload it before I spend big on a repair. A crystal ball will be handy.

Of course a purely ICE 10 year old car might well be a collector's item come 2028.


Any - Not changing the car - Steveieb
Presently have an A4 and A2 PD diesels in the fleet.
Both throw away if anything major goes wrong and no upsets when my partner backs into them which she has done three times in the last year.
Total relaxation when parking down town. And 50 to 60 MPG out of both.
Both have handbrakes , no stop start CD players and FM radios that don't suffer from signal problems!

But could someone let me know how to go about choosing a replacement. I'm so confused after reading all the reviews on here. And when I do find something that I like I find that the feeling of elation goes away after I've owned it for a while.
It's not possible to hire a second hand car like a new one and the test drives are under duress and too short.
Would it be possible for posters could advertise the cars they are planning to sell on a section of the site Avant or Godon Bennet or SLO ?
Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T
And when I do find something that I like I find that the feeling of elation goes away after I've owned it for a while.

How long does that take? If you measure it in days, you will have bought the wrong car. If in months or even years it's just normal familiarity or boredom ... :-)

Any - Not changing the car - John F

And it's red, and we like it.

Convertibles should be red...

...but only if Ferraris. British racing green suits my TR7 (not that it won many races :-(

Any - Not changing the car - Avant

"Would it be possible for posters to advertise the cars they are planning to sell on a section of the site Avant or Gordon Bennet or SLO ?"

(It won't be GB, who maintains his cars to a high standard and keeps them long-term.)

We already have a 'cars for sale' section of the website. We don't want full adverts on the forum itself, but if someone mentions that they are thinking of selling their car, anyone interested can Email me (moderators@honestjohn.co.uk) and I can pass on an Email address.

Any - Not changing the car - Steveieb
Thanks Avant.
SLO s advice to buy a Captur 1.3 petrol for my partner has been such a sucess with her that she wants to part with her beloved BMW Z3 2.8 auto . One owner from new . I have looked on the Cars for sale section but it's hard to find any private sales.
I was proposing a section for members cars for sale similar to the A2 owners club which I belong to.
Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T
I have looked on the Cars for sale section but it's hard to find any private sales. I was proposing a section for members cars for sale similar to the A2 owners club which I belong to.

Have you tried an ad with the BMW owners' clubs? (I'm thinking of the similar section on Club Peugeot UK).

Any - Not changing the car - Steveieb
Good idea Andrew will try that !
Any - Not changing the car - Dingle232

I've been having this very debate this week. My car will be 3 years old in March 2021 and that was always the point at which I said I would change it.

Then I stop and ask myself why and do I need to? It's been utterly reliable and has been a pleasure to own. Being a Honda, FSH and with me changing the oil myself every 6k I have no reason to be nervous about its reliability I suppose. Previously I have changed my cars more often that I'd be prepared to admit to and probably lost a small fortune in the process. I stopped doing that a few years ago but am never sure what the right option is.

My other half changes hers religiously every 3 years as she does a PCP and takes great comfort in the fact that she's always in a new car. I can't quite reconcile paying for something I would never own but I have never financed a car in this way so it may just be my reticence based on that which deters me.

My brother in law is the opposite. He buys his cars when they are around a year old and runs them until they break or start to cause him problems. This usually takes him to around the 10 year mark, give or take. His take on it is that this is by far the most cost effective way to run a vehicle despite acknowledging the fact that repairs are a greater risk and that the technology in his car will be out of date.

Me? I am undecided.

Any - Not changing the car - Terry W

As you reach retirement it becomes increasingly difficult to break the habits and behaviours of a lifetime.

I could now fairly comfortably afford to change the car every (say) three years. Wife is provided for with widows pension etc and my two offspring are both professionals with decent careers ahead of them.

I took early retirement as the youngest finished uni and 6 years after I paid off the mortgage.. Until that point I had to be a little thoughtful about what I spent money on - choices to be made - new car, decent holiday, new kitchen, new bathroom, etc etc.

So my attitudes and behaviours were formed by the time I retired - the car would previously have been changed not because it was 3 years old, but because it had reached an age and mileage where it was going to start costing money. This is a real problem for car companies - the oldies have the spending power but little desire, the young may have the desire but little money!

Others may have a different expectation - particularly if they had company funded cars as I did for the first 20 years of my working life.

Any - Not changing the car - corax
the oldies have the spending power but little desire, the young may have the desire but little money!

Not sure - I still think the oldies have the desire based on their past car enthusiasm, the young have diminishing enthusiasm. Not surprising now that cars are mainly appliances.

Any - Not changing the car - Nomag

Most of you on here seem to be members of the "baby boomer" generation. I am a child of two baby boomers.

My parents were both (relatively) low paid professionals but have good final salary pensions, have inherited some money and are financially comfortable.

They both have very little interest in cars, but despite the reducing mileage they cover, my mum in particular still gets the "itch" that she should change her car every 5-6 years as she did when she was working.

She can comfortably afford to do so. Maybe I am hoping for more inheritance ;) but I am trying to convince her to hold onto her 2014 Jazz, which having covered just 17k miles is barely run in. As I said to her, what is it the Jazz doesn't have, that you hope to gain by replacing it? Her request for "extra" equipment when she bought it (replacing a Fiesta) was a external temperature gauge. She keeps asking me, since we got our Leaf (for my wife's 18k miles a year) whether she should get an electric car. I just told her to have an extra 2 holidays a year and pass the Jazz on to one of the grandchildren when they are ready to drive...

Any - Not changing the car - Avant

I can see your mum's point of view, Nomag.

It may just be that she just likes new cars - as do I - but there's also an element of logic on her side as she wants to buy peace of mind. Jazzes are very reliable but any car of 6 years old and upwards is going to need repairs and replacements: and it will probably have had a harder life doing 2000-3000 miles a year than if it had done 10,000.

If her mileage is mainly short journeys, and she would be happy with an automatic,electric might make sense - a Zoe perhaps? Or a Yaris hybrid? Both Renault and Toyota offer 5-year warranties which should appeal to her.

Any - Not changing the car - Nomag

Well, I persuaded her to keep her last car a lot longer than normal- a 2003 1.4 Fiesta she sold when she bought the Jazz. She kept it 12 years in the end- all it ever had was routine maintenance. At 10 years old she had the cambelt changed, so decided to keep it a couple of years longer. It was garaged its whole life and immaculate. Someone snapped it up for £1k, which considering it cost only £8.5k new from motorpoint, I thought wasn't bad for 12 years motoring!

Any - Not changing the car - Engineer Andy

Well, I persuaded her to keep her last car a lot longer than normal- a 2003 1.4 Fiesta she sold when she bought the Jazz. She kept it 12 years in the end- all it ever had was routine maintenance. At 10 years old she had the cambelt changed, so decided to keep it a couple of years longer. It was garaged its whole life and immaculate. Someone snapped it up for £1k, which considering it cost only £8.5k new from motorpoint, I thought wasn't bad for 12 years motoring!

Sounds a bit like the experience my OAP parents have had with their 11+yo 1.25L Fiesta - they bought a run-out near base model (essentially a new showroom model) for the princely sum of around £6300 in 2008, do very low mileage mainly on local roads and who have had few issues since. I too have recommended they keep it until it becomes too much of a hassle or expensive to keep on the road. New cars are nice, but they, especially at the moment, come at a high monetary cost.

The problem with going down the hybrid route if they are used for short urban trips most of the time is that the hybrid battery will inevitably fail early and is both dead weight and expensive to replace. What I was surpsied at with my parents' car is that when their car's battery failed last week, it was the original. Wow.

Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T

<< What I was surprised at with my parents' car is that when their car's battery failed last week, it was the original. Wow. >>

Not especially unusual, perhaps a bit on the lucky side. My 207SW diesel is still on its original battery, which I presume went in the car when it was built in January 2008. So nearly 12 years starting a diesel engine for 78K miles. It's starting to sound just a bit tired on a chilly morning, but I don't feel it owes us anything more.

Any - Not changing the car - Andrew-T

.... my mum in particular still gets the "itch" that she should change her car every 5-6 years as she did when she was working..

Maybe you should tell her about the lady who owned my recently-acquired Pug 306 for 20 years - or to be strictly accurate, she drove it while she worked for the first ten, before hubby took it over when he retired. She says she enjoys driving, and has since driven a Mini which her family bought for her 65th birthday. Both cars appear to have satisfied her craving without asking to be replaced ?

Any - Not changing the car - FoxyJukebox

I would love to have the confidence to be able to make that decision oldroverboy. Perhaps I would if my dealership/garage was in walking distance from my house-which it ain't!

Another point. Being 72 I am at the stage when I just can't be bothered ringing up and booking new or old temperamental cars in for unscheduled maintenance or checks.

The once a year service is all I want--so I expect I'll be changing my two year old CX3 in a year when the guarantee runs out. What I suspect I'll do is have the third service done at the end of that third year(plus MOT of course) -then keep the car for a further 6/8 months till late summer 2021.

If i can't drive, won't drive or am not allowed to drive-I'll wait for day time buses. Also have no hesitation in using Uber these days. That means I don't lose the parking slot outside my house, get dropped where i want and can safely consume that extra glass of alcoholic gumption with a clear conscience.

Any - Not changing the car - Pica

This is a really interesting thread to me as I am feeling pretty much the same. My iDtec CRV is now 10 years old and has 93K on the clock. I bought it new and paid cash for it with the intention of keeping it for 10 years or 100K miles and then give it away. I was initially worried because it had a DPF filter and it would therefore, punish me for the years of commuting short distances of 4 miles each way to the office but the car has been faultless (apart from the EGR pipe split that was fixed under warranty some years ago). It still looks good apart from some stone rash on the front.

I have looked at so many newer cars and despite depositing £400 per month into my car replacement savings account I cannot find anything that I want to replace it with that floats my boat. Every dealer I visit now wants me to take PCP to take advantage of discounts that they refuse to give me for a straight-forward cash sale. My thinking now is to keep saving my monthly payment and run the car for another year or perhaps even three before being forced into replacing it.

Edited by Pica on 24/01/2020 at 10:54

Any - Not changing the car - John F

My thinking now is to keep saving my monthly payment and run the car for another year or perhaps even three before being forced into replacing it.

Very wise. Months quickly roll by, and £400pcm will soon add up to much more than paying for routine maintenance done cheaply at your indy, or by yourself, let alone any repairs thrown up by the MoT. With care, it should last as long as our Ford Focus (nearly 20yrs old). If it does, you will have around £50,000 to spend on a nice car - or even more if fortunately invested!

Any - Not changing the car - madf

Buying a hybrid Toyota (other hybrids may be the same) and only doing low miles means the auxiliary battery - which starts the engine - goes flat and dies and has to be replaced.. c£100 a time

Any - Not changing the car - TQ

Keep it until it dies. I'm on my third car since 1987. The first two totally died, current one a Jap with TC auto is working just fine.