What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Alex Rankin

My car has failed the MOT on account of the suspension needing replacing. I have only had it a year and already had to replace the clutch. Reluctant to spend more money as I would like to get rid of it. What are my best options? Part exchange? Scrap it? Or do the repairs and go for a private sale? Any advice much appreciated.

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Galaxy

Please inform us as to which part of the suspension needs replacing.

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Alex Rankin

Both suspension arms

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Ian D
The MoT fail would list the exact suspension parts that have excessive play/need replacing (Ignore any advisories), so get an estimate for replacing those items and then make an informed decision
Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - oldroverboy.

How old is the car? mileage? engine?

all relevant as to if a car is repaired or replaced?

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Alex Rankin

It's 2006, 1.4, with 69000 on the clock. It's otherwise a decent motor.

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - SLO76
It could be a minor repair or something major. We need details of the car to asses it’s value and the actual failures on the Mot test to work out if it’s worth saving. Without an Mot it’s scrap. A dealer may give you £200 but you’d get that off with no trade in anyways so you’re getting nowt.
Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Big John

My car has failed the MOT on account of the suspension needing replacing. I have only had it a year and already had to replace the clutch. Reluctant to spend more money as I would like to get rid of it. What are my best options? Part exchange? Scrap it? Or do the repairs and go for a private sale? Any advice much appreciated.

When you buy/own an older car this is to be expected. If it's a low number of £100 then just get it repaired. Then if you want to get rid of it it is then saleable - without an MOT it is not!

Depends on what you want next, be careful of buying someones previous problem. Better the devil you know?

The joys of motoring.............

Edited by Big John on 15/11/2018 at 23:37

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - daveyjp

If the car is otherwise sound a few hundred quid for new suspension parts (depending on the part it is preferable to change both sides) and you get another 12 months of motoring.

Your alternative is to get rid of this without an MOT, so you pay for it anyway as the price will be reduced, go and buy another used car with the potential for that to need expensive repairs over the next 12 months.

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Alex Rankin

To be fair I should have paid closer attention to the MOT history as the problems were all there as advisories. I've learnt my lesson

Nissan Note - MOT fail - what's the best option - Happy Blue!

In our family we have a 2004 Fiat Punto that has only 21,000 miles. We bought it for £500 in 2015 at 10,000 miles.

Our two sons have learnt to drive in it and it currently lives with son #1 at university. As you might imaging it has been bashed about a bit. But... underneath it is still a solid car with a great engine and gearbox and no rot. Every so often I have to spend a few pounds on repairs, such a brake pads and discs, exhaust section etc. But these are consumables and do not cost the price of a car.

If I had to spend £1,000, clealry it is not worth it to fix, but £200 - £300 per annum is worth it to keep a car on the road, especially a car we know and know it shouldn't actually let us down on the motorway.

So the same with the Note. They are good cars and generally reliable as far as the engine etc is concerned. So the suspension is a bit rotten. Get it fixed. The car should last you another few years if you drive sensibly and are prepared to invest modest amounts of money each year. Better the car you know at £300pa in repairs than one you don't that might cost you £1,000 to buy and you scrap it within 12 months.