What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Mechanical sympathy - Octane

Forty years ago I jacked up and placed enough bricks under my Mk1 Escort to be able to wriggle underneath to remove the propshaft and the gearbox then renew the clutch plate and the very noisy release bearing. This and many other practical tasks were typical amongst the young motoring crowd that I hung around with and no one thought anything particular of it. The following weeks brought enhanced enjoyment of driving with smooth pull aways and noiseless clutch dipping until you got used to it and then something else would come to your attention. The almost continuous tinkering with an old car to keep it as good as possible was part of the motoring experience and the word driver implied some mechanical knowledge. Most drivers brought up on these vehicles would have learned some mechanical sympathy and perhaps still have it. I wonder if we are expecting too much from todays motoring crowd who are brought up on vehicles with dynamic qualities plus comfort and ease of use we could only have dreamed of combined with perhaps just one annual visit to the garage. I write of these things because the contributors to this motoring section reflect so many of the thoughts that time in my retirement now allows. For many people the car is like the fridge / washing machine / microwave and numerous white goods that perform the required task and little understanding of them is required. Indeed the manufacturers push the wifi and other electronic features as the principal reason for purchasing rather than the basic function of the product. For me the driving I do still includes some of that satisfaction derived from some knowledge of a well maintained machine and I wonder if all the other motorists whizzing past me are missing out. Or is this all irrelevant other than to the few left of similar experience.

Mechanical sympathy - gordonbennet

There's quite a few of us like minded souls in this backroom, the white goods car users you mention would probably call us dinosaurs, well if humans last anywhere near as long as the dinos did they will have done well.

There is nothing quite like learning and getting the best out of a well designed well made well oiled machine, and doing your bit to keep it in that peak condition and making it last gives one a great deal of satisfaction, the new generation of car users will never have that added satisfaction of knowing whats going on and 'feeling' at one with the vehicle, that's why old schoolers wouldn't dream of thrashing an engine from cold, and they cringe when they hear some poor vehicle being subjected to abuse and double cringe when they just know the poor thing probably only gets a drop of fresh oil when the oil pressure light comes on.

Oil's going to be dropped from my old Landcruiser on Thursday, then its going to stand for 24 hours to drip clean and my endoscope is then going up the drain plug to inspect the oil pick up which is just above, then fresh Fuchs synthetic is going in (twice a year change) and a new filter, and safe in the knowledge all the transmission oils are good because i replaced them all only recently, the vehicle will drive lovely on its fresh engine oil when i go back to work on Saturday.

Mechanical sympathy - catsdad

One of the pleasures of retirement was giving up my company car. After 25 years of new cars every 2-3 years it was good to be able to buy a car to look after as a keeper. I can also replace tyres comfortably before the legal 1.6mm, keeping them as matching sets.

There is definitely satisfaction to be had from careful long term ownership.

Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T

Oil's going to be dropped from my old Landcruiser on Thursday, then its going to stand for 24 hours to drip clean.

Hmmm. Half an hour is enough for me with warmed-up oil. I'm not enough of a dinosaur to bother with the next 23½ hours :-) It's about the only job I do on the oily bits nowadays.

Mechanical sympathy - gordonbennet

Hmmm. Half an hour is enough for me with warmed-up oil. I'm not enough of a dinosaur to bother with the next 23½ hours :-) It's about the only job I do on the oily bits nowadays.

You misundertand me Andrew, the object of the exercise is to have a jolly good poke nose at the oil pick up checking for any signs of carbon build up, hence letting it drip for 24+ hrs and hence using a magnifying endoscope with leds around the lens.

Most importantly my mince pies, only one of which is much cop, out of the firing line in case an errant drip drips.

Those 3 litre Toyota Diesels are one of the engines that can suffer with injector blow by, hence every now and again a good look at the pick up mesh which is as good a guide as any.

Even i'm not fussy enough to let it drip overnight for a normal oil change.

However i'm looking forward to changing the Scooby oil next time, because there is a brand new Fumoto quick drain valve sitting in front of me waiting to go in place of the sump bung, the standard Scooby plug is rather large bore and hot oil gushes out at a hell of a rate, hence Fumoto it is :-)

Mechanical sympathy - gordonbennet
the object of the exercise is to have a jolly good poke nose at the oil pick up checking for any signs of carbon build up, hence letting it drip for 24+ hrs and hence using a magnifying endoscope with leds around the lens.

Got finsihed early on Wednesday so dropped the oil and filter when i got home, left to drain overnight, no drips at all thismorning.

Endoscope gave a clear picture, pick up is clean, new oil in and just covered 40 miles, oil still clear so that overnight drain really did the business (that will be the case from now on), sounds smooth and my mechanical sympathy conscience is satisfied, that's it now till about March, i've done the oil change a fraction early this year due to higher than usual mileage covered during the spring.

Mechanical sympathy - Leif
I’m definitely impressed with you care and attention to the engine. I doubt main dealer services would be up to your standard.
Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

I doubt main dealer services would be up to your standard.

Main dealer could not let a fitter take that much time over an oil change or anything else for that matter

I left a car hire firm 1987 due their attitude of not letting mechanics do their job properly, only to find when I started at a main dealer i serviced a fiesta, manager asked me why I had rear drums off, ( you could check shoe thickness through hole in backplate but I always took the drums off)

when I said to him you should know why, he said we don`t do that here- just look through the hole....this was the attitude then of a few garages I worked at and found the attitude spreading- so I worked for another car hire firm who were very good and let you do your job.....

Mechanical sympathy - craig-pd130

Some of my earliest memories were of 'helping' my dad work on his motorbikes, and then in my teens, various friends had cars and bikes which all needed regular attention, so I love to 'keep on top' of cars and bikes in the family.

It's also useful when diagnosing faults: my son's Corsa E 1.4 petrol recently developed a hesitation / misfire when transitioning to acceleration from a trailing throttle (e.g. when changing up a gear). It also threw an emissions warning light. I had a quick spin round the block in it, and figured the problem was either:

- a spark plug had worked loose (Corsas use 10mm plugs which often loosen off in service). I checked them, they were all snug.

- a plug had gone duff: having checked them, they were all the same colour and none was wet

- the coil pack was faulty

As the car is still under warranty, I was able to tell the service desk exactly what the symptoms were, and what I suspected the fault was. Sure enough, the coil pack was failing and replaced.

Mechanical sympathy - concrete

Pretty similar experience from early motorbike days as an apprentice (James Captain 197cc first bike) Mini (first car). Basic servicing was part of the fun and kept the car right. Also saved a boat load of money. From the early 70's I had company cars every 2/3 years and looked after them also. My last car was my private car, used for business and mileage claimed back. Cheaper and tax efficient too. That Superb did over 200k miles in 10 years or so. In all that time I have never had to replace a clutch or had any major repairs to engine or gearbox on any car in my possession. Driven sympathetically cars can last a long time. The Skoda had all original fittings when I sold it on. Same exhaust, clutch etc etc. Having some knowledge and using it is definitely useful in keeping your car as good as it can be.

Cheers Concrete

Mechanical sympathy - Leif
I don’t tinker with my car, mainly because I have only one and need it for work. However, I understand the basics of how the engine etc works, and I have mechanical sympathy. I’ve never had a clutch go, or an engine for that matter. Clutches last 130,000+ miles in my cars. Brakes last ages too, replaced front disks on last car at 80,000 miles.

I find my cars have far fewer faults since I took IAM lessons, whether that is coincidental I know not, but they do teach better use of gears etc.
Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T
Clutches last 130,000+ miles in my cars. Brakes last ages too, replaced front disks on last car at 80,000 miles.

Clutch life is mainly down to driving habits. My FiL used to wear them out by resting his foot on the pedal. Even in the 'old days' they could last a surprisingly long time - I had a second-hand Morris 1100 which I sold on to a mate at about 70K and it went on to at least 90K, still on the original clutch AFAIK.

Mechanical sympathy - SteveLee

"who are brought up on vehicles with dynamic qualities plus comfort and ease of use we could only have dreamed of "

Hmmm, dunno about the comfort bit - the Jags and Citroëns I used to drive in the 80s and 90s are vastly more comfortable than anything I'd driven in the last 10 years. Plenty of modern cars with dual mass flywheels suffer failure at the 30-50K mark. Other than that I agree, cars have become consumable white goods and drivers mere users rather than motorists in the old sense of the word.

Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

I had a second-hand Morris 1100 which I sold on to a mate at about 70K and it went on to at least 90K,

What, without subframe mountings going, thats unusual, they were reknown for rust and mountings collapsing, a lot used to crab as well where the new mounting plates were not welded in place properly

I lost track of the amount I did in the 70s I owned one myself of which I got caught out severe rust under rear subframe, took a week to weld new panel on it

My father always worked on them, they were a cheap motor for him who had 4 over some years, but the rust beat him on all but one, which some idiot smashed the rear up, but always under the bonnet which was fun for a few years untill you get used to their faults but did find the parts wore out quick on that car

Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T

What, without subframe mountings going, thats unusual, they were reknown for rust and mountings collapsing, a lot used to crab as well where the new mounting plates were not welded in place properly.

I can't say whether that 1100 suffered that way in my mate's possession, but I don't remember any subframe problems with the three that I owned. I certainly remember following Minis which could crab horribly - it was a common problem.

I remember two other problems though, which affected the 1100 I drove in Canada and the US. It had an electric fuel pump mounted in front of the rear bumper. Every so often the points would soot up and need cleaning, or very rarely it would get hit by a pebble on rough back roads. I travelled with a spare which I could change in about 15 minutes, cleaning up the points at leisure.

The second fault, maybe due to the previous owner's rallying habits, was wear in the solid rubber U-joints in the drive shafts, which began to knock against the transmission casing. Had those changed in San Francisco.

Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

What, without subframe mountings going, thats unusual, they were reknown for rust and mountings collapsing, a lot used to crab as well where the new mounting plates were not welded in place properly.

I can't say whether that 1100 suffered that way in my mate's possession, but I don't remember any subframe problems with the three that I owned. I certainly remember following Minis which could crab horribly - it was a common problem.

I remember two other problems though, which affected the 1100 I drove in Canada and the US. It had an electric fuel pump mounted in front of the rear bumper. Every so often the points would soot up and need cleaning, or very rarely it would get hit by a pebble on rough back roads. I travelled with a spare which I could change in about 15 minutes, cleaning up the points at leisure.

The second fault, maybe due to the previous owner's rallying habits, was wear in the solid rubber U-joints in the drive shafts, which began to knock against the transmission casing. Had those changed in San Francisco.

It was rare to see an 1100 that didn`t crab, parts you mention were for some standard carrying kit in the boot, as was dizzy cap rotor arm and especially points, they must have had very hard contacts as they were terrible for wear and sticking

must be rare now as I have only seen one at a show which did not look too clever but had been resprayed (could be why)

Mechanical sympathy - Leif
Clutches last 130,000+ miles in my cars. Brakes last ages too, replaced front disks on last car at 80,000 miles.

Clutch life is mainly down to driving habits.

That was my point.

My FiL used to wear them out by resting his foot on the pedal.

He must have been doing more than resting his foot on the pedal (something I do) but actually pressing down, so as to get the clutch near its bite point.

Mechanical sympathy - FoxyJukebox

Years ago-soon after i passed my driving test and got my first car, my father insisted that I learn't how to check the oil, radiator water(coolant), top up windscreen water, check tyre pressures(including spare) and also clutch and brake fluid master cylinders. He also taught me how to change a wheel, take it to be repaired and change it back again afterwards -then wash the spare tyre down and fit it back in the boot. Yes-very useful and to this day i still follow these basic guidelines, which have served me well. I seriously believe that the reason I hardly see anyone checking oil, checking tyres, checking anything under the bonnet is either because they ain't got a clue how to do it or possibly-just possibly-they could not care less?

Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T

I seriously believe that the reason I hardly see anyone checking oil, checking tyres, checking anything under the bonnet is either because they ain't got a clue how to do it or possibly-just possibly-they could not care less?

At least part of that is because car makers are gradually making it harder to do. More things under the bonnet are covered by black plastic, and less info is given in the owner's manual. All (presumably) to make more work for dealers, nominally in the interests of H&S. My car is 10 years old, but the manual says nothing about how to drain the oil, which I would happily do, except that it is extremely awkward without a hoist.

The other reason is that most cars will go on uncomplainingly for months or even years without treatment, so that easily becomes a habit. They even expect the tyres to tell you when they should be checked .....

Mechanical sympathy - drd63

Andrew T, your last comment is spot on. I've no plans to do my own servicing but have very good mechanical knowledge. I used to race motorbikes and carried out my own maintenance from oil change to full engine and gearbox rebuilds.

But modern cars are so much better mechanically than the cars I drove 30/35 years ago. Electrical and computer systems are a different matter and I wouldn't know where to start there. I do still check the fluids but it's been a long time since anything needed topping up!

So perhaps people do care but simply don't need to.

Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

Andrew T, your last comment is spot on. I've no plans to do my own servicing but have very good mechanical knowledge. I used to race motorbikes and carried out my own maintenance from oil change to full engine and gearbox rebuilds.

But modern cars are so much better mechanically than the cars I drove 30/35 years ago. Electrical and computer systems are a different matter and I wouldn't know where to start there. I do still check the fluids but it's been a long time since anything needed topping up!

So perhaps people do care but simply don't need to.

I'm the same but health prevents me from doing anything except levels.though I need not check them Honda has sensors for over level oil and low level and they work but never needed to check water as it's always been spot on.

Even electrics are or should be really reliable though that seems to depend on who makes the electrics

Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T

<< Honda has sensors for over level oil and low level and they work but never needed to check water as it's always been spot on. Even electrics are or should be really reliable though that seems to depend on who makes the electrics. >>

Ah yes, the sensors. Again we can come to depend on them implicitly, tho on rare occasions they can misinform. Hopefully that may not be serious, but it should always be possible to make visual checks to confirm. My car still has a dipstick and transparent reservoirs for coolant and brake fluid, which I look at every few weeks despite the start-up 'Oil OK' message. I believe some swish cars don't always help there, and tyre pressure detectors can be irritating too.

Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

Again we can come to depend on them implicitly

surprising how many people are sarcastic about sensors, I`m not that keen on TPS but have it.

and looking back on it, the only sensor I have had cause a problem was CPS when you got stuck in traffic for a long time where the sensor got hot, if you shut the engine off it wouldn`t start again for an hour, but as it only happened after traffic jams 3 times I never had it replaced Civic 2.2 diesel

there is also the point some are not able to check levels and some do not even know they have sensors

I do check everything but where I said never needed to check water it meant have the cap off, as level is visible without, as most cars.....

Mechanical sympathy - Leif

Andrew T, your last comment is spot on. I've no plans to do my own servicing but have very good mechanical knowledge. I used to race motorbikes and carried out my own maintenance from oil change to full engine and gearbox rebuilds.

But modern cars are so much better mechanically than the cars I drove 30/35 years ago. Electrical and computer systems are a different matter and I wouldn't know where to start there. I do still check the fluids but it's been a long time since anything needed topping up!

So perhaps people do care but simply don't need to.

I'm the same but health prevents me from doing anything except levels.though I need not check them Honda has sensors for over level oil and low level and they work but never needed to check water as it's always been spot on.

Even electrics are or should be really reliable though that seems to depend on who makes the electrics

I have a 4 month old VW Polo. Within a month the switch controlling the wipers failed. Thus in torrential rain the wipers stopped, leaving me with zero visibility., and that’s no exaggeration. Five minutes earlier and I would have been on the M3 and I can’t see how I would have avoided a multi car crash. A few weeks later the car refused to let me in. I had to walk home and get the spare keys. The emergency braking has gone off twice for no obvious reason, very scary. The radio has refused to turn off several times. When using CarPlay, the infotainment system has repeatedly crashed, though resetting my iPhone appears to have solved that one so VW 1, Apple 0. I suspect that the least reliable cars are those with the most toys, which is why many aspirational brands do badly.

Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T

<< I suspect that the least reliable cars are those with the most toys. >>

A fairly predictable situation, I think? Of course the first maker to present a new toy runs the risk of not having tested it sufficiently, so perhaps the Mk.2 version will work better.

Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

Andrew T, your last comment is spot on. I've no plans to do my own servicing but have very good mechanical knowledge. I used to race motorbikes and carried out my own maintenance from oil change to full engine and gearbox rebuilds.

But modern cars are so much better mechanically than the cars I drove 30/35 years ago. Electrical and computer systems are a different matter and I wouldn't know where to start there. I do still check the fluids but it's been a long time since anything needed topping up!

So perhaps people do care but simply don't need to.

I'm the same but health prevents me from doing anything except levels.though I need not check them Honda has sensors for over level oil and low level and they work but never needed to check water as it's always been spot on.

Even electrics are or should be really reliable though that seems to depend on who makes the electrics

I have a 4 month old VW Polo. Within a month the switch controlling the wipers failed. Thus in torrential rain the wipers stopped, leaving me with zero visibility., and that’s no exaggeration. Five minutes earlier and I would have been on the M3 and I can’t see how I would have avoided a multi car crash. A few weeks later the car refused to let me in. I had to walk home and get the spare keys. The emergency braking has gone off twice for no obvious reason, very scary. The radio has refused to turn off several times. When using CarPlay, the infotainment system has repeatedly crashed, though resetting my iPhone appears to have solved that one so VW 1, Apple 0. I suspect that the least reliable cars are those with the most toys, which is why many aspirational brands do badly.

TBH I have never had or wanted a VW of any model due to so many reports of problems, imo even Ford were as bad, after Rover went down I stuck with Honda and have to say they have had faults but nowhere near as many as a lot of other cars, but again thats personal opinion and think I will stick with them!

I don`t agree the more toys they have the more chance of a problem as usually its a component failure rather than complete unit that goes down.

Mechanical sympathy - Leif
I am rather sceptical of surveys especially JD Power as they are not well done IMO and sometimes have bizarre results such as the Skoda Citigo being far more reliable than the VW Up: virtually the same car, made in the same factory, same engines, same mechanics, almost the same body same electrics, small cosmetic changes. That said, VW always do okay in surveys, about mid way ish, so not awful, not brilliant. The DSG gearbox seems to have a poor reputation. Nissan were said to be very good, I had an old style Micra, it had faults, and finally the ECU failed, an expensive repair.
Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

I am rather sceptical of surveys especially JD Power as they are not well done IMO

Most people I know seem to want to keep up with the Jones`s and some wonder why they end up not affording the fuel and tyres for some motors, they are so concerned with I must have this motor, the running costs are not given a second thought, to some its bragging rights which imo is stupid if you are unable to run it without financial difficulty

Does anyone take notice of these surveys as no one I know does, the impression is given that only certain motors are given brilliant reviews...I may be wrong?

Mechanical sympathy - Leif

I am rather sceptical of surveys especially JD Power as they are not well done IMO

Most people I know seem to want to keep up with the Jones`s and some wonder why they end up not affording the fuel and tyres for some motors, they are so concerned with I must have this motor, the running costs are not given a second thought, to some its bragging rights which imo is stupid if you are unable to run it without financial difficulty

Somewhat off topic, but doubtless true. I notice people change car because they for example see a cam belt change coming up. The cost of changing a cam belt will be fare less than the cost to change.

Does anyone take notice of these surveys as no one I know does,

Interesting question, I don't know the answer. In my case I take notice of reviews, but not these surveys.

the impression is given that only certain motors are given brilliant reviews...I may be wrong?

That suggests some form of bias. Evidently there is a lot of money involved, and many marques do fly journalists out to all expenses paid jamborees. Hard to believe that has no influence, even if the journo is straight as an arrow.

Mechanical sympathy - Andrew-T

<< I don`t agree the more toys they have the more chance of a problem as usually its a component failure rather than complete unit that goes down. >>

I don't see why that is any better - whether a whole thing fails, or just a part of it. It's still a failure, and may indicate incomplete 'road testing'. It may take years for weak points in a new device to reveal themselves. Don't we all know it?

Mechanical sympathy - Bolt

<< I don`t agree the more toys they have the more chance of a problem as usually its a component failure rather than complete unit that goes down. >>

I don't see why that is any better - whether a whole thing fails, or just a part of it. It's still a failure, and may indicate incomplete 'road testing'. It may take years for weak points in a new device to reveal themselves. Don't we all know it?

My point was these parts should be repaired by either sending back to manufacturer or the garage repair the unit instead of, after OEM approval binning them, thats what they used to do, get a bin full of broken warranty parts wait six months to be told by OEMs to scrap them

it may be different now I don`t know, but for recycling reasons I see no reason why they cannot repair parts, apart from the profit side of it....reminds me of Apple lol