What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - movilogo

What prevents manufacturers making modern cars which look like old classics like 1960s Rolls Royce, Dusenberg, Jaguar E type etc.

Is there no market for such looking cars or there is technical difficulty with all the mandated safety requirement nowadays?

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Xileno

Safety regs will certainly have a part to play but more than anything I suspect the manufacturers consider the market would be small. Maybe we should be looking forwards. The Rover 75 was an attempt to produce a car with styling cues back to the past, to me it was all wrong, not what the market wanted in the run-up to the turn of the Century.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - RT

Safety regs will certainly have a part to play but more than anything I suspect the manufacturers consider the market would be small. Maybe we should be looking forwards. The Rover 75 was an attempt to produce a car with styling cues back to the past, to me it was all wrong, not what the market wanted in the run-up to the turn of the Century.

Despite the Rover 75 being the best car built by BMC, etc in a generation or two.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Trilogy.

Despite the Rover 75 being the best car built by BMC, etc in a generation or two.

The wrong car at the wrong time for the no man's land sector of the market. Unlike most cars from the group hamfisted by poor packaging.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - RT

You mean like MINI, New Beetle, Fiat 500 ?

Kit car manufacturers do make old-style cars that resemble MG TF and a few others.

I guess not many people want an old-fashioned car.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - SLO76
“ You mean like MINI, New Beetle, Fiat 500 ?”

Absolutely and yes, there is demand for retro modern. It has to be done right however and the Fiat 500 is a perfect example of this.
Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Alby Back
If Mercedes were to recreate the pagoda roof SL, I'd willingly sell body parts if necessary to afford one.

;-)
Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Mike Lyons
If Mercedes were to recreate the pagoda roof SL, I'd willingly sell body parts if necessary to afford one. ;-)




Gorgeous looking car ; I've always hankered one of those myself , but I suspect Mercedes would have a challenge making a modern replica pass current-day crash tests with those slim windscreen pillars.

and if you made the pillars thicker, it would ruin the looks for me.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Sofa Spud

Morgan have made cars with the same styling since 1953 - and that was an update of their 1930's design! The mechanicals might have changed but there's a continuity of production.

Not content with still making the real thing, Morgan also did 'retro' with the Aero 8!

Several companies have produced 'continuation' cars, which are new builds done to the original spec. These include the Lister Knobbly, Jaguar E-Type Lightweight and the Bentley Blower 4½ Litre (despite the fact that Bentley were opposed to fitting superchargers when the originals were built).

With notable exceptions, car styling is not in a happy place at the moment but going 'retro' is unlikely to improve things because it will be created in the context of modern unhappy styling.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - FoxyJukebox

I wish they made Minis that looked like the old 1950's/60's "look"-but more safe!. The "new" BMW Mini is sort of ok--but ruined for me by the inappropriate retro fascia that presumably somebody felt might be appealing. Foul.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Big John

What prevents manufacturers making modern cars which look like old classics like 1960s Rolls Royce, Dusenberg, Jaguar E type etc.

Is there no market for such looking cars or there is technical difficulty with all the mandated safety requirement nowadays?

I'd love a retro look - sorry not getting the SUV thing these days. I think history will put the SUV fad up there with 1970's flares - probably just me!

Edited by Big John on 23/07/2021 at 23:16

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - RT

Part of the problem with retro styling is that modern cars are so much bigger than those of yesteryear - if you ever pass a classic on a motorway, it'll seem minute compared to everything else.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - John F

What prevents manufacturers making modern cars which look like old classics like 1960s Rolls Royce, Dusenberg, Jaguar E type etc.

Such upmarket attempts never sold well - look what flops the re-incarnated Rover 75 and Jaguar S type were - even in this country, let alone elsewhere. Mass market attempts were successful in many countries - e.g. Beetle, Mini, Fiat 500.

Is there no market for such looking cars or there is technical difficulty with all the mandated safety requirement nowadays?

There is a market, but it is small, reflecting the tiny proportion of eccentric enthusiasts in the general population, e.g. Morgan buyers; the Eagle car company.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - primus 1

The Opal manta is making a comeback…..so is the Renault 5, electric only of course..

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - daveyjp

Old style cars were designed and built based on the technology available at the time. Presses, hand seam welding etc etc. The world has moved on.

However if you want a Mk1 or Mk2 Escort mst cars will build one for you or you could DIY.

https://mst-cars.com/mk1-fast-road-touring/

But would you spend £75k plus VAT for one?

Edited by daveyjp on 24/07/2021 at 11:04

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Terry W

Making a modern car which looks like a classic is truly superficial.

Some modern cars pick up on a few design cues - eg: Mini, Fiat 500 - but any more than a cursory inspection would show them to be completely modern in design and technology.

But a car with modern underpinnings which is substantially indistinguishable from a classic is like a fake Rolex with a £5 chip inside, Tesco clothing with fake designer labels, GTI and AMG badges on a cooking VWs and Mercs.

Some may see this as a joke or challenging convention. Me - a celebration of the tacky without substance intended to pump up the sagging ego of the owner.

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Engineer Andy

What prevents manufacturers making modern cars which look like old classics like 1960s Rolls Royce, Dusenberg, Jaguar E type etc.

Is there no market for such looking cars or there is technical difficulty with all the mandated safety requirement nowadays?

As others have said, exact copies of old cars with modern underpinnings are difficult in the extreme to get at a reasonable cost and that passes the latest safety tests with at least reasonable scores. There is a small-scale indie firm building replica E-Type Jags - at a cost of several £000ks each, so I'm sure if buyers have the money and there's sufficient demans, it can be done.

Original minis and tiny Fiats, no - not just on cost grounds, but because they are so small, safety would be terrible. Even modern micro cars have a difficult time score well on NCAP and I regularly read in the papers of fatal accidents where one of them is hit by other cars, just because the difference in size/weight.

I think there nearest anyone's going to get for a mass-market manufacturer are the latest (not so small) Minis, Fiat 500s and Nu VW Beetle (no longer in production).

Perhaps if and when new-fangled 'smart' 'nano-materials' are used to build vehicle, then we might start to get some old-style flair back in car external design, assuming such materials can save a big chunk of weight whilst maintaining or improving safety to offset perhaps some less aerodynic shapes (but which look nicer).

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - Warning

Would chrome bumpers be allowed?

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - badbusdriver

Would chrome bumpers be allowed?

No, wouldn't pass pedestrian impact requirements. Unless of course you could make something which looks like a chrome bumper but was appropriately 'squishy'

Same reason why you wouldn't be able to have a big, upright, sharp edged radiator grill like an old Roller.

Edited by badbusdriver on 27/07/2021 at 19:51

Why manufacturers don't make old style cars? - edlithgow

If they still made them, then they wouldn't be.