I would go with the Toyota. I also have the 1.8 but in manual. It's a lovely smooth engine and economical

Hi Guys,

I'm on the hunt for a new car and i've been trawling the internet ..

You don't say what's important to you, what type of journeys you'll be doing, whether it's just you in the car, or family, etc, etc.

So what's good for me may not suit you.

Toyota for reliability

Merc if you want to look like a junior exec

Audi if you want that image

BMW if you like centre vents which you can select between cold air on your face or hot air. I really liked that feature. THough I wouldn't buy a 4 cylinder BMW.

You don't state the price for the Toyota

I have a slightly newer version of the Toyota you mention, also with the CVT 'box. I generally rate it, and went into considerable detail on the pros and cons in my review on this site.

I'll grant you, it's no fireball, but that's because it's a naturally aspirated 1.8 (albeit a very good one) rowing along a 1.5 tonne estate car. The manual (which we also tested before deciding on the auto) is also, you've guessed it, not going to be amazing in the performance stakes.

However if you want an auto because you want smooth driving, it's a very amiable thing to drive. If you want to press on (a bit!), there are plenty of ways to do that without getting CVT "droning".

For us the number one thing a car needs to do is not go wrong, and we're not fussed about the badge, so the Toyota was a clear choice for us.

If you want performance the Audi is probably going to be the quickest, at least in terms of in gear performance which is what really matters in day to day driving. But you're paying for the badge - as you also are with the BMW and Merc.

Do you want reliability? "image"? Driving pleasure, such of it is available these days? Toys? Comfortable suspension?

The lower price makes the argument even stronger in favour of the Toyota: to some extent, with the other three you're paying for the brand.

If you feel that the others would be more fun to drive, widen the search to include a petrol Mazda 6 (avoid the diesel), which should be just as reliable and a bit better to drive. Not so many of them around though.

HI

Thanks for everyones input....

I guess it does come down style over substance....As much as I love the Audi, The Toyota is the sensible option and besides I have heard very mixed reviews about the multitronic gearbox and the fact that BMW's dont come with folding rear seats as standard is a little rubbish - well thats what i've found