What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
New car query, economy related - jingo

Good evening fellow motorists.

I have come to seek advice as I am after a new car, as my current Mitsubishi Galant much as love it, is not the most fuel efficient!

I am looking at a 7/8 year old diesel or petrol hatchback, preferably in the 1.4l category which achieves high mpg figures I cover around 200 miles a week mostly on A roads and Motorways with little 'urban' driving.

I would welcome any suggestion from owners of cars which may fall in this category. Thanks in advance

Jingo

New car query, economy related - unthrottled

I cover around 200 miles a week mostly on A roads and Motorways with little 'urban' driving.

A bigger diesel engine than a 1.4 will be better to drive and will probably get equal or better economy with this sort of driving. Engine size and fuel economy isn't as closely linked as it is with petrols.

New car query, economy related - Avant

I agree with Unthrottled. If you want a diesel the best ones to go for would be the Ford Focus or Mondeo, or a VW or Skoda with the 1.9 TDI engine.

But for 10,000 miles a year a petrol would do you just as well. Japanese petrol engines are particularly reliable try a Toyota Corolla/Auris, a Mazda 3 or (my choice) an old-shape Honda Civic.

New car query, economy related - jamie745

For that kind of mileage you don't want a squitty little engine which will scream like a boiled hamster all day. Even a big petrol engine can do well on fuel for that kind of driving because it's barely breaking sweat at normal road speed.

New car query, economy related - Bobbin Threadbare

10k pa is probably petrol territory........... Buying a petrol will be cheaper than buying a diesel and if you're after something 7-8 years old, possibly less risk of getting a duff one.

New car query, economy related - skidpan

Do the sums, 10000 miles a year in petrol doing approx 33mpg is £1800 on fuel. 10000 miles in a similar sized diesel doing 45 mpg is £1300 on fuel. That is a £500 saving a year plus the RFL on the diesel would be less.

Know where my money would go but whatever you do don't let your heart rule you head.

New car query, economy related - oldtoffee

Agree with others about petrol being less of a gamble. Can't argue with the recommendations for Japanese but I'd look at a Mondeo or Vectra 1.8 or 2.0 as there are so many about and you can be fussy on condition and history which should be high on the priority list. I'd probably go Mondeo because I've had one and it was good to me, it returned 40mpg on a long run and handled well on the twisty bits. I understand that the Vectras can be more economical and refined on the motorway.

New car query, economy related - thunderbird

Agree with others about petrol being less of a gamble.

Any 7 or 8 year old car is a gamble but old Ford and VW's diesels pre DPF do appear to go on and on. We still have some 9 year old Vauxhall combo 1.7 diesels on our fleet that have done galactic mileages with no major issues but I hate to drive them.

New car query, economy related - madf

Whatever you do, do NOT buy any French diesel. The engines may be fine but the electrics will usually go wrong big style. And if you buy a Renault diesel, you are likely to suffer a life of pain and degradation as the layout is deisgned to ensure it cannot be serviced properly without grief..(so it is skimped with consequences)

New car query, economy related - jingo

Thanks for the replies so far folks. I am aware of electrics on french cars, reading a few car magazines taught me that! I was thinking maybe a 307 HDi but otherwise English?japanese would be the preference.

The reason a 1.4 would suit is the cheaper car tax, as well as dropping my insurance costs. The current Galant is insurance group 13! I guess my aim is to bring down the overall cost of running a car which is why the comments on petrol econmy and value of used models will broaden the search. I'm off to do more research : )

Cheers!

New car query, economy related - jamie745

Don't believe all of the generic scare stories about French cars. I've had two Peugeot 406's (one HDi and one petrol) and both Executive models with lots of electrics and neither of them have gone wrong.

New car query, economy related - Collos25

For once I agree with you.

New car query, economy related - jingo

My Dad has a 407 HDi SW and after 3 years of ownership he is very happy with it with few faults bar the dashboard display.

New car query, economy related - Ed V

I wonder if the French, who have always appeared very loyal to their own cars, spend larger sums on maintenance than us.

Outside central Paris, the average age of their cars seems higher than ours too, and I find it hard to believe that they're down at the garage every month sorting out their cars' electrics.