What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - sammy1

Picking up on HJ reply today, if it were my car with 28k miles and less than 4 years old I would be seriously unhappy faced with a bill of £2114 from Mini dealer. HJ answer whilst describing a possible cause was at best unhelpful. Is there a warning in the vehicle handbook that disparity of tyre tread can cause a costly problem? I would suggest that HJ could have advised the writer to have at least asked the dealer for a contrbution from Mini - part not fit for purpose? This is an expensive car. Failing this take it elsewhere for a more reasonable quote? The reason consumers write to HJ is for advice as they know little about the mechanics and their consumer rights which is reflected through this forum. I appreciate that sometimes the full letter to HJ is sometimes not published in full!

MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - oldroverboy.

The amount of problems with "transfer boxes" of all types is becoming a problem in itself, lack of oil changes in haldex types, wear and tear and of course tyre tread differential.

Coupled with BMW long life servicing and ....

You can bet that there is a sentence buried somewhere in the hand book, and no dealer is going to tell anyone about it, least of all on a used car, and certainly not on a lease or pcp..

Edited by oldroverboy. on 11/01/2018 at 15:57

MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - SLO76
This certainly was an issue we warned buyers of 4wd cars about when I was a salesman. All wheel drive Cavaliers were the worst for chewing their rear diff if tyres weren’t close to equal dept but 4wd Sierras and Mondeos too. It was also noted in the owners manuals. Sadly few owners read them. Although times have moved on the basics of this technology really haven’t so I guess it’s still relevant.

I don’t rate Minis either. They’re good to drive but past 6-7yrs old they’re total money pits.

Edited by SLO76 on 11/01/2018 at 18:01

MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - focussed

"I don’t rate Minis either. They’re good to drive but past 6-7yrs old they’re total money pits"

Good to see that the modern mini is staying true to it's roots - the BMC Mini.

MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - galileo

"I don’t rate Minis either. They’re good to drive but past 6-7yrs old they’re total money pits"

Good to see that the modern mini is staying true to it's roots - the BMC Mini.

We had a 1971 Mini 1000, ran it as second car till 1985, only ever needed routine servicing, Traded it when kids got bigger and needed more space.

MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - focussed

I'm talking about the original rubbish 1959 > models which were, it has to be admitted, total money pits. Everything wore out, corroded and fell to bits and they were a total PITA.

MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - Metropolis.
You could say that for a lot of cars of the era, only country making decent cars en-masse then were the americans!
MINI Countryman cooper D 4WD - Transfer box - Nomag

Agree with original poster. However common transfer box problems are, this is a VERY low mileage vehicle. And only just out of warranty. I would be taking MINI to task. Disparity in tread depths or not.

We have two 4wds with automatic engagement. The IX35 has had tyres rotated throughout its life as I swap to winters Nov to March. Despite this, at 4 years old it needed a new propshaft bearing (under warranty).

On our Sorrento I didn't rotate the first set of tyres, shear laziness, just replaced all four (second replacement set on front, first on back) will rotate these. Even rotating though, it's impossible to keep wear completely even all the time. The Sorrento recently had a whole new diff (different thread) under warranty due to a "minor oil leak".

The Hyundai was main dealer serviced until this year, and the Sorrento remains main dealer service. At no service has any dealer mentioned/suggested rotating tyres to ensure even wear and avoid diff problems. I appreciate its the owners responsibility to know about this, and many have 4wd they don't need, but at the very least if you are paying to maintain a main dealer service history, they really should give advice (after all they record the tyre tread depths on the service sheet!) if not offer to rotate tyres for you. This is the sort of thing that has gone out of the window in the modern glass and chrome palace dealership, which of course you have to use to maintain your warranty, whereas I bet there are lots of good rural independents used to seeing 4wds who recommend this.

Personally I would like a switch like I have seen in the Renault Kadjar for 2wd/auto/lock 4wd. Ours are both auto at all times, and can be locked in 4wd electronically, but cannot be locked in 2wd. If such a vehicle was driven locked in 2wd most of the time, it woudl avoid this sort of problem caused by uneven tyre wear, but still allow use of the 4wd in the situations in might be needeed, without unnecessary wear on the diff.