What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Breakdown cover for punctures - smallcar
I own a 7 year old Honda CRZ and when I bought it I paid a rather ludicrous sum to get the manufacturer supplied space saver fittted in the boot well. I don’t have breakdown cover anymore (I had one year as a Honda approved used car) as I thought the car runs with perfect reliability so was ready to chance it.

A mate of mine has just posted on Facebook about getting a nail in his tyre on the M25 and as he has a modern Merc with rubber band wheels he had to be recovered off the M25 and then called what turned out to be a good mobile tyre fitter to fit a new tyre.

My question is if you have a puncture on a motorway(I never had had to deal with a puncture anywhere) are you required to get recovered off the motorway to then deal with the puncture in a service station or off a junction? If so does that mean you need breakdown cover in place to pay for it even if you hve a spare wheel or space saver? Do any of you have such cover in place mainly to deal with punctures even if you have faith in your vehicle’s reliability?

Edited by innerlondon on 13/02/2019 at 08:42

Breakdown cover for punctures - bathtub tom

The hard shoulder of a motorway is a very dangerous place, hence the advice to stand the other side of a crash barrier rather than inside a broken down car. A 'managed' motorway with no hard shoulder is even more dangerous. Would you want to change a wheel on a motorway?

I understand most breakdown insurance consider a puncture as a breakdown and will transport your car to a safe place to deal with a puncture.

You don't need breakdown insurance to deal with this, you could just call out a breakdown service and pay them.

Breakdown cover for punctures - John F
Do any of you have such cover in place mainly to deal with punctures even if you have faith in your vehicle’s reliability?

No. All our cars have a jack and a spare, and I make sure I can undo the wheel bolts by doing them up myself to the correct torque whenever the wheels are removed. Over forty years ago I bought a cheap torque wrench for a few pounds, (accuracy perfectly adequate for amateurs) and I see it is still available! It doubles as a 'breaker bar' for the too tight studs from overenthusiastic tyre jockeys.

www.amazon.co.uk/Draper-34487-2-Inch-Square-Torque...9

Breakdown cover for punctures - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}

Yes. I have AA breakdown and relay in place to cover any vehicle that I am in. Since 1973. They have dealt with a puncture on the A1(M) and a flat battery recently. A vital necessity for me.

But as said, you can just make your own arrangements when you have a problem. Rather you than me.

Breakdown cover for punctures - Andrew-T

Yes. I have AA breakdown and relay in place to cover any vehicle that I am in. Since 1973. They have dealt with a puncture on the A1(M) and a flat battery recently. A vital necessity for me.

But as said, you can just make your own arrangements when you have a problem. Rather you than me.

The point being missed here is that if your car gets a puncture and has a spare wheel, and you check every year or so that your wheel bolts are not too tight to remove at the roadside, you can fix your problem quicker than waiting (how long?) for the rescue services. Sometimes in my experience that can be an hour or more. (And of course you check the pressure in the spare .... )

Edited by Andrew-T on 13/02/2019 at 12:28

Breakdown cover for punctures - smallcar
I think I could change a wheel myself although not done it for real. I suppose my question is would anyone here try and change a wheel on the hard shoulder of a motorway especially if it was an offside tyre?

On the many smart motorways I wonder if the highways agency compels you to recover the vehicle to another place rather than try a replacement in what might be a carriageway where there is no hard shoulder? Or would you try and get to the refuge areas that are built as part of the smart motorway concept ?

Edited by innerlondon on 13/02/2019 at 12:57

Breakdown cover for punctures - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}

A scary and a dangerous place to be. We got out of the car , shredded tyre, and up the embankment to ring the AA. The motorway patrol parked up behind the car to protect it. The had to assist me to call the AA as I could not hear my phone over the high noise levels AA arrived in 10 minutes and swapped wheels.

No way would I attempt a wheel change on a hard shoulder..

Breakdown cover for punctures - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}

Tyre was shredded, I was just glad I could stop with a modicum of control. And a puncture does not have any connection with reliability and neither does leaving on your lights and flattening the battery.

Edited by Glaikit Wee Scunner {P} on 13/02/2019 at 13:41

Breakdown cover for punctures - Bromptonaut

I recently had to change o/s rear on my Skoda Roomster. Got the studs out OK but couldn't separate wheel from hub - corrosion. LV rescue dealt with it in minutes but their guy had proper tool and was better built than me. No way would I want to mess with that on hard shoulder.

Do carry an electric pump so possibly could have got enough air in to allow journey to continue.

Breakdown cover for punctures - Heidfirst

I do have AA cover so first thing would be a call to them. Depending upon their answer I might try to change a n/s tyre. I very much doubt that I would try an o/s unless it was a very quiet motorway (e.g. middle of the night) & AA said they would be hours.

Breakdown cover for punctures - Galaxy

I don't think I'd attempt to change a wheel on the side of a motorway without either a breakdown vehicle or police car behind to protect me from any oncoming traffic which might be coming my way.

Breakdown cover for punctures - sammy1

Buy a car with runflats and any puncture problems you carry on, a great invention and forget all the negativity about noise and ride etc, they are no different than any other tyres.

Breakdown cover for punctures - bazza

I once had a violent blowout on the M6 near Leek and changed it myself but this was years ago and I was in my 20s, with no breakdown cover .it was extremely scary, with trucks whizzing by a few feet from your head. I wouldn't bother again. But anywhere relatively safe, yes, a 10 minute job at most, maybe less.

Breakdown cover for punctures - smallcar
I’d definitely manage it subject to being able to get the wheel nuts off but only in a safe location.

Think I’ll get a basic breakdown recovery policy to cover motorways and dual carriageway situations or if in an odd location.

Thank you to everyone who has responded so far.
Breakdown cover for punctures - Steveieb

Managed to get a full sized spare from ebay for my partners 207SW for £65 but aftr weeks of nagging Ive failed to get my daughter to check whether her Mazda 3 has a spacesaver!

Too busy with everyday life I suppose!

Breakdown cover for punctures - Engineer Andy

Note that breakdown cover does not include the cost of any replacement tyre.

Breakdown cover for punctures - smallcar
Well I’ll assuemmid ask them to put the space saver on and drive home on that. Would abreakfown serivce have the exact make and size of tyre available when they come to fit?
Breakdown cover for punctures - Andrew-T
Would a breakdown service have the exact make and size of tyre available when they come to fit?

No, and they would probably be unable to fit one if they had it. Needs pretty heavy equipment.

Breakdown cover for punctures - dan86

Even a mobile tyre fitter would doubtfully have the tyres in their van they would have to get them from a warehouse.

I've fortunately never had a puncture on the motorway but plenty of other roads and a spare tyre is an essential I'd never want to not have. I'm very able at changing a spare wheel but if rather call the breakdown and be towed/ recovers to somewhere safe to change it if it was on the motor way.

You can get local breakdown cover for as little at £21 On some comparison websites. I'd say that a good price for peace of mind.

Breakdown cover for punctures - gordonbennet

As for tyre availability i sat with my lorry beside the motorway for probably 6 hours following a trailer blow out one night, whilst the attending tyre fitter drove all over the district checking the depot stores for the right not that rare size, and there's dozens more car tyre sizes and types now than lorry....if you have a car the HA people would insist on recovery given that sort of time frame.

You cannot beat having your own spare wheel of some sort, even if its one of those horrid wheelbarrow tyres, it gets you to somewhere else, either home or to a tyre shop where you can get things sorted.

Changing your own wheel on the hard shoulder depends on the circumstances, there are places i would do it myself, and places where i'd want the HA people there with multiple flashing lights watching intently as they do for the increasing number of idiots that seem incapable of driving in a straight line.

What does make sense and few people bother, is to make sure before the event that you have all the equipment you need to change a wheel, and that it's serviceable, you know how and where to use it (jacking points), and that your wheelbrace will undo the bolts when the time comes, and lastly that you have the wheelnut locking key, a decent torch in case its dark, a coat and preferably a hivis in the car, the latter you'll be needing after the 29th of next month anyway :-)

Breakdown cover for punctures - Heidfirst

afaik AA/RAC vans now carry "universal" spares www.theaa.com/newsroom/news-2013/aa-pioneers-unive...l

Not aware of any change in regulations (Brexit or otherwise) that would legally require a hi vis to be carried? Although I already do carry hi vis vest & trousers ...

I do carry all the necessary equipment to change a wheel in either day or night, summer or winter despite rarely having needed to do so. Also jump leads (mostly used to help other people start their cars), tow rope, oil/ water/ screenwash for top ups. & before first journey of the day I do a walk around of the car. Yes, I guess that I am a dinosaur/rarity ... :P

Breakdown cover for punctures - Manatee

Not aware of any change in regulations (Brexit or otherwise) that would legally require a hi vis to be carried?

I think GB might be referring to the likely protests of the yellow vests when Brexit goes belly up.