What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Nearly new petrol automatics - why so few available?

Your advice columns are full of warnings about the longer-term running costs of modern diesel cars.

In the light of that I decided to stick with a petrol engined automatic to replace my faithful 13-year old Volvo V70 2.5 20v automatic (110,000 mile) that I bought 'nearly new' and does about 15000 miles per annum since my retirement. She is beginning to show her age and feels much less sure-footed than she did so I feel the time has come for a change.

I am reasonably open-minded about my choice of car but need an estate or hatchback around Mondeo sized and good to drive both locally and on long motorway journeys.

I have always bought one-year old cars in the past; however, I am amazed at how few 'nearly new' petrol automatics are on the market, particularly if you also try to avoid VAG's troublesome DSG gearbox.

Some manufacturers also seem to have limited, or removed, the range of petrol automatics in their new car ranges, which can only make the choice even more limited.

If I broaden my options, is a petrol DSG automatic from VAG likely to be less reliable/expensive to run than a diesel automatic from other manufacturers??

Life shouldn't be this difficult!

Please can you advise me on how to rationalise my search?

Many thanks


Asked on 4 April 2013 by IanSD

Answered by Honest John
380,000 DSGs have been recalled in China. VAG has been forced to put a 5 year warranty on them in China. Here they're still on a 3 year warranty. Mazda has managed to make its 6 speed torque converter automatic reasonably efficient. BMW and Mercedes still fits torque converter automatics to all but the MB A and B Class. That's where I would be looking.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I'm looking at a Ford Focus 2009 estate automatic, do you rate them? Would you recommend petrol or diesel?
For the past 2 years I've been running a Volvo XC70. This car has given me all the comfort that I could wish for with its fantastic seats and long travel suspension. In addition, over the last winter the...
We've got £2000-£5000 to spend on a used estate with a reasonable sized boot. We're not bothered about brand as long as it is reliable and has decent amounts of equipment. Ideally, we want an automatic...