A-Class, 1 Series or A3?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

A-Class, 1 Series or A3?

Hello I was wondering which one of the following 3 cars would you say is the best: BMW 1-series, 2012 Audi A3, 2012 Mercedes-Benz A-class.

Early reviews have shown that the A-class has been a bit of a disappointment (which is a massive shame). And the Audi doesn't seem to drive as well as the BMW.

So is it the BMW which is best? Especially considering you can buy a nearly new model for about £17-18k.

Many thanks!

Asked on 7 July 2012 by timmyd

Answered by Honest John

Probably the new A3 with the 1.4TSI engine.

Tags: buying small family cars new cars

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:

Select a few terms below

Similar questions

Quiet family car

My current Honda Civic is due for change & I'm wondering which of the current similar models (Focus, etc) are the quietest, especially in respect of road noise. The Civic is great on good surfaces but...

Petrol or diesel?

I am looking to upgrade from my 2003 VW Polo to something a little bit bigger. I commute 50 miles a day (round trip) but undertake short journeys during the day. Would I be better buying a Petrol or a...

What new hatchback?

I have a 12-year old 5-door Rover 420Gsi and my wife has a 10-year old 3-door RAV4. We want to sell both cars and get one new petrol 5-door medium-size hatchback, eg Golf or similar size. We are both...

Related models

Mercedes-Benz A-Class (2012 - 2018)

High-quality interior. Strong diesels. Good record for reliability. Option of four-wheel drive.

BMW 1 Series (2011 - 2019)

A very entertaining car to drive, efficient yet powerful engines, superb infotainment.

Audi A3 (2012 - 2020)

Comfortable and high quality premium hatchback, low emissions diesel engines including economical 1.6 TDI, very refined at speed yet handles well in corners.