Winter tyres or a Jimny?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Winter tyres or a Jimny?

My wife is about to start a new job that involves a 36 mile round commute mostly on very narrow country lanes. She is very concerned over the winter driving due to icy conditions - very few of the roads are gritted around us. Are we better off getting a set of winter tyres for her '07 Golf 1.9 tdi sport or replacing the car with a narrow 4x4 such as a Suzuki Jimny.

Reviews suggest the Jimny is exceptional in the winter but no where near the Golfs quality. Our preference would be to keep the Golf with the winter tyres but will they be up to the job?

Asked on 23 August 2011 by jimjam68

Answered by Honest John

Winter tyres better. Michelin Alpins or Pirelli SottoZeros.

Tags: 4x4s winter tyres winter

Similar questions

Even Range Rover Sports 4x4s are fallible in fresh snow.

Here is a salutary tale on winter driving. I recover cars for a Jaguar Land Rover repair contractor and was called to Gaydon to collect a JLR company Range Rover Sport diesel. A new car, it is allocated...

What car for winter driving?

I will be driving on country roads to work early mornings and evenings, and am worried about winter. I would like to buy a used car, which is female friendly and does not breakdown, handles well in small...

Solution to snowy weather

We have problems getting out of our (very hilly) road in snow. We would like to buy a small/medium sized car which is 2 wheel drive and can be switched to four wheel drive when needed, rather than a permanent...

Related models

Suzuki Jimny (1998 - 2018)

Outstanding ability off-road. Cute looks, especially as a soft-top. Cheap to buy.

Volkswagen Golf (2004 - 2008)

Decent handling and comfortable on the move, impressive TSI engines, massive improvement over the previous Golf, high-economy Bluemotion models, high quality feel of interior, five-star Euro NCAP safety rating.