What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Economic crash

Is it my imagination but is it a new thing that police close motorways for many, many hours after an accident? If we have to get to an airport for a flight now, we have to take the motorway journey time, then time for traffic, and finally now, having to take detours along roads we don't know because the motorway is closed because of the accident. The police say it is because they are investigating a crime scene, but I'm sure they didn't do this in the past. I'm sure the police in other countries don't do this. I'm sure that the delays caused by the closures, the drivers rushing to find their way along congested unfamiliar roads trying to make up lost time, will cause more accidents than getting the motorway open quickly. So why do the police do this now? Are they being coerced to do this by government? Is there some evidence that prosecuting motorists for unintended accidents actually reduces accidents? (By the way motorists are the only section of society prosecuted when there is no intention to commit a crime. In every other court case, the prosecution must prove intent to commit a crime or they can't be prosecuted.)

Asked on 1 August 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Only if there have been a fatality because then the motorway becomes a 'crime scene' and forensic teams need to examine it thoroughly in order to apportion blame for criminal and insurance purposes. This only happens in the UK and was brought in by Richard Brunstrom when he was ACOP Head of Road Policing. There are arguments both ways. But bringing the entire country to a halt in order to establish exactly who or what caused a fatal crash does not make a lot of sense to me. I agree that the stress caused by this probably kills more people then the crash being investigated.
Similar questions
I am sure you are aware of the horrific crash about two weeks ago on the M25, when two BMW cars driven by young men were involved in a death crash when one of the cars clipped the central reservation and...
Listening to the radio it now seems that motorway closures are becoming an everyday occurrence. Motorways are the arteries of our economy so I can only assume that we are having a spate of major pile-ups...
After yet another inordinately long wait in a police induced traffic jam recently, I eventually slowly passed the scene of a bad accident. Rubber necking as I do, not to observe any gore, but to check...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer