Unless you need four wheel drive because you drive off road a lot, the S-Max. As well as a 7-seater, which no Qashqai really is, it's an extremely good drivers car. Look for big discounts. There may be a few old stock 2009 S Max about at really big discounts of £7k or more. But with Sterling improving against the Euro you should still get a substantial discount on a 2010.5 model with the more efficient engines. Avoid the old 1.8TDCI like the black death.