What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

One horse tow

My 20 year old daughter bought a 2nd hand horse trailer last week from a private seller who described the trailer in good solid condition and as having no faults that could not be seen in the photos. When we went to view trailer we noticed one light wasn't working and one tyre looked soft. These were fixed before we picked up and we were also told that her brother in law, who deals in tractors and agricultural machinery, had had a look at it and the trailer only had surface rust that we could see and no major faults. When we picked the trailer up her son and brother in law helped us hitch up and get lighting working with our car. We brought trailer home, parked it in our drive and 1 day later picked up a horse. One hour into our journey home with horse the trailer undercarriage broke and the trailer ran free from the towing vehicle. Luckily no one was badly hurt but the lady is now telling me that she has taken legal advice and doesn't have to give us our money back. I know that trailers are classed as vehicles and that they have to be roadworthy but does anyone have any experience or advice to share?

Asked on 3 July 2010 by NB, via email

Answered by Honest John
You could attempt to use the small claims track of the county court to sue for breach of contract in that the trailer you bought in good faith was dangerously unroadworthy and broke the first time you used it. I think there is quite a good chance that the judge would find in your favour. Tell the vendor that if she does not take the trailer back and give you your money back, then that is what you will do. But if the vendor is an itinerant and has no 'fixed assets' you might as well give up straight away because even if you get a judgement you will not be able to enforce it.
Similar questions
I bought a Mazda in December 2017. It had 10,000 miles on the clock and I paid £16,000. I was sold the car with the remainder of the 21-month manufacturer's warranty, so I had six months left on it. The...
I purchased a 2007 Citroen C4 Picasso on December 1 2017. I quickly found the car would judder, hesitate on pulling away and cut out on me. I informed the garage of this, and they said that was normal...
I bought a new Skoda Superb Estate seven months ago. When driving a few weeks ago, a warning light appeared on the dashboard saying 'Front Assist Not Available'. The light has been on ever since. My local...