What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

A flash in the prang

I'm sure you are aware that, with the increasing automation of many car functions, many modern cars have an Automatic option for their lights such that the sidelights and headlights come on and turn off according to how the car's own sensors judge the ambient lighting conditions. My girlfriend has a VW Golf, which has such an option. She always drives with her lights set to automatic, whereas I always prefer to select manually the lighting I want. I was recently in convoy with my girlfriend, she driving behind me in her Golf. I was keeping one eye on her in my rear-view mirror, as we were driving a route unfamiliar to her. There was a chap parked by the side of the road, indicating to pull out and waiting for a gap in the traffic. I passed him, but noticed in my mirror that just as my girlfriend's car reached him her headlights suddenly came on. My first thought was that she had flashed him to let him pull out, but she carried on with no change in her speed. I rang her immediately (yes - we're both on hands-free, before you ask!) and she had no idea her lights had come on; indeed, they soon went out again. As it happened, the parked car either didn't see her lights come on, or judged her too close to risk pulling out anyway, so nothing untoward happened. However, he could just as easily have seen those lights come on, assumed he was being flashed, and then pulled out straight in front of her, with the obvious consequences. Regardless of the rights and wrongs of the unwritten protocols that have built up around the flashing of headlights to mean different things, clearly when a car takes it upon itself to turn its own lights on there is a huge potential for misinterpretation. I would be interested in your views, not least as to the legal standing of either party should a collision have arisen under such circumstances.

Asked on 10 April 2010 by P.A., Leeds

Answered by Honest John
The potential for misinterpretation is in the stupidity of drivers over
the use of flashed headlights. A flashed headlight is a warning. Nothing more. Nothing less. Taken in conjunction with the way the flashing vehicle behaves and the circumstances, it could be a permission, but only on conjunction with those other circumstances.
The Brits get a lot of things very mixed up. They try to be polite by
flashing other drivers out. At the same time, instead of using their horns as a warning they use them as a rebuke and, instead of being grateful for the warning, hooted drivers immediately take offence.
Similar questions
I brought a Vauxhall Corsa on friday for my wife. Its a 2010 vauxhall Corsa 1.0 EcoFlex 3 cylinder. When she changes gear (or me) it judders and sometimes lack power. Went back to the dealer on wednesday....
Please could you comment on this statement on the IAM website as I always assumed you should put an auto into neutral at a standstill to minimise wear. 'When stationary in traffic, even for many minutes,...
I've just taken delivery of a 1.6 Golf Bluemotion automatic as a company car. As I've driven countless automatics over the last 30 years I didn't anticipate the problems I'd encounter with the stop start...