What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks
Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

The IAM is apparently advising drivers to start off in second gear to minimise wheel slip in slippery conditions.

In my mind, This just looks like a band aid to poor throttle/clutch control. It also seems to be unnecessarily hard on the clutch/DMF assrmbly-particularly in diesels. I would have thought that advanced motorists would have little difficulty in modulating tractive effort with the throttle...

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

My late dad never took a driving test. In snow he'd tend to start off in 2nd gear. That was in a petrol car e.g. Moggie, 1100/1300, Maxi, Volvo or Jamie's favourite...............Swedish but not a Volvo. Best not mention the name or he will have a hissy fit!!!

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

I can see the logic when you had to rev engines as you let the clutch out.

But a modern engine has automatic idle control, so if you let the clutch out gently, the engine will maintain idle speed-thus giving you an easy form of starting torque control. Honda Jazz drivers haven't discovered this feature yet!

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - ChannelZ

IAM. Should be renamed ICM. Institute of Clueless Motorists. 10-to-2, cadence braking, starting off in wrong gear. Don't make me laugh. :)

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

or Jamie's favourite...............Swedish but not a Volvo. Best not mention the name or he will have a hissy fit!!!

I'd only have a hissy fit if you sat here proclaiming Saab invented second gear.

As for the IAM, everybody knows they're a pathetic useless organisation. We've been through this before. You can add this one to other gems of advice from them such as 'IAM advises motorists to read road signs!' and to 'Not travel in snow unless absolutely neccessary' which all sounds quite basic, rather than advanced.

On my driving test (the one i passed) it was in dry conditions and i'd dropped down to 2nd gear for a roundabout but ended up stopping completely and pulling away in second on a slight incline. I didnt really realise until a few seconds later.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

IAM. Should be renamed ICM. Institute of Clueless Motorists. 10-to-2, cadence braking, starting off in wrong gear. Don't make me laugh. :)

What do you do instead of 10 to 2? A mate does 5-1 and I've been out in car when someone drove at 25 to 5. What about you?

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

Wait hold the phone! You're supposed to use both hands?

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

Usually quarter past three with the right elbow wedged against the window frame. The low beltline in my car is reason enough not to scrap it. Left hand just plays with gears.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Chris M

Driving test wise I imagine starting off in second gear would get you a minor, not sure what 25 to 5 or a quarter past three would incur.

Having taught one son to drive and a second lined up for 6 months time, I have re-evaluated my driving over the last 18 months. I was various times in my yoof, but age has lead me to 10 to 2. I find it comfortable and I believe, it's probably the best position (along with a quarter to 3) for control. In an emergency, your hands are close to indicators and wipers, so if you need to reach either of them quickly, the other hand is ready to steer around danger.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

Driving test wise I imagine starting off in second gear would get you a minor

I didnt get anything for it. Examiners dont mark you based on what gear you're in. If i'd stalled it halfway cross the roundabout and rolled backwards on the other hand....

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

If you're expecting to manoeuvre then 10 to 2 is ideal-but a bit of a bore for cruising where a slovenly slouch is more appropriate. Why do people take their hands off the wheel to engage the indicator?

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

If you're expecting to manoeuvre then 10 to 2 is ideal-but a bit of a bore for cruising where a slovenly slouch is more appropriate.

Agreed. I can drive the S-Type up and down Britain using one finger and one toe.

Why do people take their hands off the wheel to engage the indicator?

Perhaps they drive a Saab where the indicator is hidden in the glove compartment to avoid strain on the drivers little finger. Innovative safety feature that.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

Perhaps they drive a Saab where the indicator is hidden in the glove compartment to avoid strain on the drivers little finger. Innovative safety feature that.

That's made my day!

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Chris M

" Why do people take their hands off the wheel to engage the indicator?"

I imagine only E.T. could reach the stalk from the 25 to 5 position.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - ChannelZ

What do you do instead of 10 to 2? A mate does 5-1 and I've been out in car when someone drove at 25 to 5. What about you?

Whatever I feel is appropriate. :) When I said 10-2, I was thinking more the pass and shuffle, the way Police drivers used to be taught. My grandpa was taught to drive by the Police when he joined after WWII, and still shuffled until he stopped driving about 10 years ago. Impossible steering method to do any sudden swerves, or correcting any tail out action. He wrote off a few cars over the years, and I'm pretty sure if he wasn't shuffling the wheel he'd have caught them all.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

Pass and shuffle?

My dad used to practice that technique. But that was on the wheel of a tractor unit without power steering...

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - RT

In slippy conditions, only small amounts of torque can be transmitted before the wheels spin - so there's no great strain on the clutch or DMF - but starting off in higher gears when there is grip WILL cause component stress.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

I was thinking more the pass and shuffle

Sounds like a dance to me.

jamie, I was about to say Saab invented the second gear, but you beat me to it. You've been doing your homework...........................at last!.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - SlidingPillar

In my opinion the IAM and a lot of officialdom is bonkers here.

Moving off in slippery conditions is all about not breaking traction. Using second to move off requires a longer period of clutch slippage, so more wear and tear. And frankly, a greater chance, not a lesser one, of wheel-spin for a lot of drivers.

As has been pointed out above, a lot of cars now have an antistall circuit, so will pull away at idle. So the gentlest of take offs are easily performed - and that is what it is all about.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

I like my Skoda because it will just trickle along at walking pace (when I want to go slowly) without my foot on the accelerator. :)

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

Here's some more indispensable advice:

"Ensure you have de-icer and a scraper. Before setting off, make sure you clean any ice or condensation from all the windows so that your visibility is clear."

Talk about taking the watch off your wrist and telling you the time!

I'm going to start an organisation for the benefit of drivers who have been stabbed by their cars.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

Here's some more indispensable advice:

"Ensure you have de-icer and a scraper. Before setting off, make sure you clean any ice or condensation from all the windows so that your visibility is clear."

Talk about taking the watch off your wrist and telling you the time!

I'm going to start an organisation for the benefit of drivers who have been stabbed by their cars.

unthrottled, sadly there are lot of people who lack common sense and need to be told to clean their windows. I see enough morons who just clear a tiny patch on the windscreen and then venture down the road. Unfortunately there are still inconsiderate, brainless, lazy moronic motorists.

The best moron story I've heard is when a motorist was involved in a car accident when it was icy. When the motorist mentioned to the attending policeman he didn't realise it was icy the policeman asked of the car was kept outside? Yes. Did you use de-icer on the winds this morning? Yes

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

Trilogy-it is pointless. The people who listen to the IAM, know to scrape the windows and don't need to be told. The people who do need to be told aren't listening to the IAM.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

The type of motorist who needs to be told simple (not advanced) things is not going to be logging onto the IAM, or even this site for that matter so they'll never read it. The argument of 'thick people need to be told' is not a justification for the IAM acting in such a patronising way. Basic things like 'clean your windows' should be learned by your second driving lesson, its not the place of an organisation pretending to be 'advanced' to be spouting nonsense babble.

Thats the key point, the IAM are not advanced at anything. They just teach the same basic stuff as any ordinary driving instructor but using more complicated words to make themselves sound special.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - bintang
I can't do 10 t
Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Avant

Sorry Bintang - b***** Microsoft again. Try using Google Chrome or Firefox - we don't want to lose you!

In the old days of lower gearing it was quite normal to start in second. But even when I learned to drive in the 60s (in a Morris 1100) you could feel that it was more of a strain on rhe clutch than it had been in a 50s' Austin. Thus I never started in 2nd and never have.

If you want to save on gearchanges, better to do so further up the line - say, 1,2,3,5 or 1,2,4,6.

Edited by Avant on 28/01/2012 at 16:12

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

Skip shifting is definitely the best way. But cars aren't trucks. 1st is not a crawler gear-that is avoided if not heavily laden.

Modern cars are just too heavy-especially with NEDC friendly gearing...

I find 1,2,5 to be quite useful from a standing start up to about 40. If downhill, 1,3,5 seems to do the trick. Does sdepend on the gearing though...

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

jamie 747 'Thats the key point, the IAM are not advanced at anything. They just teach the same basic stuff as any ordinary driving instructor but using more complicated words to make themselves sound special.'

LOL!

Edited by Trilogy on 28/01/2012 at 16:48

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Avant

Jamie 747?

Inflation gets to us all.

Or has he become a Jumbo?

Or has he improved to 74.7 pence in the pound?

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Bobbin Threadbare

Jamie 747?

Inflation gets to us all.

Or has he become a Jumbo?

Or has he improved to 74.7 pence in the pound?

He's been eating a lot of biscuits lately.

I'm sure the IAM will advise that it's best to keep some biscuits in the car in case all of the instructions become too much and you collapse in a sobbing heap, unable to drive through stress at all that scraping and creeping in snow.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

Jamie 747?

Inflation gets to us all.

Or has he become a Jumbo?

Or has he improved to 74.7 pence in the pound?

He's been eating a lot of biscuits lately.

I'm sure the IAM will advise that it's best to keep some biscuits in the car in case all of the instructions become too much and you collapse in a sobbing heap, unable to drive through stress at all that scraping and creeping in snow.

As do Saabs for those cold snowy winters. I'm sure Jamie 767 knows that Saab were the first to include biscuiit tins in their cars as a gift for buyers at time of purchase. N.B. JamieConcorde is the forum's resident Saab expert. All Saab queries, and while on the subject of his expertise, he is the font of all knowledge for the IAM Test, so all Saab and IAM queries should be addressed to JamieSpitfire!!!

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

I'm sure the IAM will advise that it's best to keep some biscuits in the car

Bobbin-that would be most unwise. Biscuits contain mono-unsaturated fats which can lead to high cholestral, elevated blood pressure and raise the risk of a heart attack. If you were to suffer a heart attack whilst driving, it could be a cause for distraction.

If you think you have suffered a heart attak, you should phone 999 immediately.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - focussed

"IAM. Should be renamed ICM. Institute of Clueless Motorists. 10-to-2, cadence braking, starting off in wrong gear. Don't make me laugh. :)"

You really do not have a clue what you are talking about-try taking your advanced test and then come back and comment, if you pass of course,remember the examiner is always a police class 1 licence holder, the highest driving qualification there is.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

You really do not have a clue what you are talking about-try taking your advanced test and then come back and comment

Im assuming you've done the test, so can you tell us what is 'advanced' about it please?

Just because the examiner has a Police driving qualification (which means very little, judging by the Police forces' accident statistics published last week) doesnt mean the IAM's test means anything.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

If the advanced driving test is so useful, why are insurers so indifferent to it?

I would put a Class 1 LGV up there among the high classes of driving-but I don't see the Road Haulage Association dispensing advice about demisting windscreens.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

If the advanced driving test is so useful, why are insurers so indifferent to it?

Possibly because its not a properly recognised qualification. It means nothing. Some insurers do pay attention to it but in reality theres such a small amount of people with IAM qualifications that the data field is quite irrelevent. Didnt we work out in the past only 0.3% of Britain's motorists have this qualification? The rest of us seem to manage alright without it.

I would put a Class 1 LGV up there among the high classes of driving-but I don't see the Road Haulage Association dispensing advice about demisting windscreens.

Because their members actually are advanced, so they dont need to be told simple things. People who drive Buses, LGV's, HGV's etc are the most skilled in the road in my view. I've seen a lorry driver manouvere a 44 tonne truck into the back of a Tesco in town in one move. To put it in perspective, most people would struggle to do this turn in question in a car.

And how Bus Drivers manage to thread those things through towns is beyond me.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

747, 'Thats the key point, the IAM are not advanced at anything. They just teach the same basic stuff as any ordinary driving instructor but using more complicated words to make themselves sound special.'

you made the statement, its up to you to support it with evidence. Bet you can't!

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - unthrottled

you made the statement, its up to you to support it with evidence. Bet you can't!

Um, I think the onus is normally on the claimant to provide positive proof, rather than on a skeptic to disprove an unsubstantiated claim.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - jamie745

Um, I think the onus is normally on the claimant to provide positive proof, rather than on a skeptic to disprove an unsubstantiated claim.

Quite. If the IAM and its supporters think their test and qualifications are really advanced and special then its up to them to make their case and prove it.

The fact is i've asked 'what makes them advanced?' on here many times and nobody has given me an answer yet.

Probably because they dont have one.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - RT

If the advanced driving test is so useful, why are insurers so indifferent to it?

I would put a Class 1 LGV up there among the high classes of driving-but I don't see the Road Haulage Association dispensing advice about demisting windscreens.

Not all insurers are indifferent - I get a better insurance deal through the IAM than I can get elsewhere - good cover, lower excess, low premium.

I do agree though, that basic driving education shouldn't be a function of the IAM - mainly because it's a waste of membership fees as basic advice falls on deaf ears.

Compared to the low standard of driving necessary to pass/keep a basic driving licence, the IAM test is advanced - I'd be surprised if BackRoomers consider their own skills as merely adequate so it's quite likely that the test isn't advanced compared to skills here.

Edited by RT on 29/01/2012 at 07:57

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - Trilogy

Um, I think the onus is normally on the claimant to provide positive proof, rather than on a skeptic to disprove an unsubstantiated claim.

Indeed, jamie is the claimant.

Any - IAM advice-starting off in second gear - nudger
Guys, there's a lot of hissing about the IAM on this forum and it's a little disappointing considering the type of motorist that we expect here. Is anyone here actually a member?

I am and I love driving fast and enjoying my car. I don't hold my hands at 10 to 2 and I was never told to. I start driving using the clutch alone in the snow that's currently outside and I have no problems. I don't use 2nd gear because I haven't got stuck doing what I'm doing. The advice I was given by the IAM was simply that 2nd gear is a useful rescue tip if you do slip.

The IAM taught me how to read the road and the traffic with the intention of driving in a way that was sympathetic to my car and that would get me from A to B safely and, it now appears, faster than the general stream of traffic.

I'm nothing special and I don't consider my driving to be either but the IAM is a good thing. I get massively reduced insurance premiums - don't forget that only 12 months ago, the majority of the insurance industry was penalising drivers who were risk averse enough to fit cold weather tyres,like much of Europe and North America, when it was cold! So just because Sheila's Wheels and Admiral don't give someone a reduction, you can't extrapolate.

Almoat without exception, the IAM advice pages that are posted on HJ are excruciatingly simple and slightly embarrassing for all of us who read these pages, but it does reflect the standard of driving out there. It's white and icy outside but I still see others driving without lights on, before sunrise, peering through little peep-holes in their windscreen.

So please let's have less of the denegrating talk about the IAM. They do a good job but the majority of motorists know nothing about what they actually stand for and I agree that the advice post recently on this site doesn't really help that.