What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - Quoman123

Bought the above from a well known major car supermarket. To cut a long story short, when it was serviced the brake discs were 20mm front 9mm rear, pads 4mm front 3 mm rear. My question is, is this acceptable and should they have replaced them all before sale. They didn’t do the service as promised but they paid for Halfords to do it, so asked them if they had serviced it and found these measurements would they have replaced them awaiting reply? 38500 on clock. Thank you

Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - elekie&a/c doctor
It’s a second hand car with nearly 40k miles . Brakes wear out as you drive it. Minimum requirement for mot is 1.5 mm brake pad thickness. Discs need to be severely warped , cracked or corroded or reached their minimum thickness before replacement. If the car passed the brake roller test on the mot , then there’s not much wrong with them .
Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - kiss (keep it simple)

When I look at a second hand car I always have a quick eyeball at the discs. If they look scored and worn I factor that into my budget. If you are lucky, as I was with a Polo with 60k on the clock, they had all just been done all round.

Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - edlithgow
It’s a second hand car with nearly 40k miles . Brakes wear out as you drive it. Minimum requirement for mot is 1.5 mm brake pad thickness. Discs need to be severely warped , cracked or corroded or reached their minimum thickness before replacement. If the car passed the brake roller test on the mot , then there’s not much wrong with them .

Thats the theory.

In practice my cars in Scotland ALWAYS failed MOT for visible rust on the disks, though they passed the brake function test just fine.

Fortunately on most cars changing the brake disks is fairly easy (though not on the hub-over-disk AKA captive rotor designs used on, for example, 90's Honda Accords and on my last car, a Daihatsu Skywing) so I was able to keep a shiny set of disks just for my Renault 5 MOT's.

If you do it often they dont get rusted very firmly in place.

More recently, power abrading with flattened beer can seems to be pretty good at cleaning them up, though I'll probably never have an opportunity to test that against the UK MOT.

Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - John F

In practice my cars in Scotland ALWAYS failed MOT for visible rust on the disks, though they passed the brake function test just fine

A bit of visible rust shouldn't fail a disc. Brown rustiness can appear virtually overnight in damp moist conditions. More severe rust and ridging can be removed with a hammer, screwdriver (to drive through the ventilation holes) and carborundum wheel. In my experience of mundane cars driven carefully, pads should last around 50,000 miles and front discs 100,000 miles. Rear discs and (older cars) drums might well last the life of the car. For a quality car they should last even longer. All the discs on my nearly 19yr old Audi A8 (76,000 miles) are original with little observable wear after I bashed and ground the rust off them a couple of years ago. The original pads were changed less than 5,000 miles ago.

Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - Quoman123

New cars don't get mot til 4 years now, this would have been picked up if mot at 3 years

Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - catsdad

The MOT is still at three years.

Clio mk 5 2021 - Brake pads and discs - alan1302

New cars don't get mot til 4 years now, this would have been picked up if mot at 3 years

As above - the fist MOT is at 3 years for most people on here - are you thinking of Northern Ireland?