What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - Car

Just out of interest for my next car in a couple of years time, I will be considering an auto. I likely the DSG gearbox.

However the reliability issues put me off, especially when I will be looking to purchase a car 5 years or more old due to budget.

So wonder what the alternatives are for something Skoda Octavia size.

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - Sulphur Man

Honda Accord or Toyota Avensis - both reliable autos.

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - Car

Apart from Honda Accord and Toyota Avensis, is there any others?

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - gordonbennet

Apart from Honda Accord and Toyota Avensis, is there any others?

Hyundai Sonata/i40, Kia Magentis/Optima, Lexus, Toyota/Lexus hybrids (jury is still out on other makes), Mercedes, BMW (careful here, gearboxes lovely if maintained well, engines need research and more frequent servicing than stated), Suzuki Kizashi, even Chevrolet but remember they are disappearing.

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - Avant

The 6-speed DSG (fitted to larger-engined cars) has a much better reliability record than the 7-speed (fitted to smaller ones).

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - Car

The 6-speed DSG (fitted to larger-engined cars) has a much better reliability record than the 7-speed (fitted to smaller ones).

What engines were fitted with the 6 speed DSG?

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - mustangman

Far as I know the current model smaller VW/Seat/Audi/Skoda petrol engines such as 1.2 / 1.4 all use the 7sp "dry clutch" system. All the diesels & 2.0 petrols use the 6sp "wet clutch" system which will take more torque. An exception to this is the 7sp wet clutch system used on my Tiguan and Audi quattros etc. together with 4wd. ( anybody please correct if wrong )

I've had both and can say that the only problem I've had was a juddering clutch on a Golf Mk6 1.4 tsi. Replaced under warranty at the time.

The dsg takes a bit of getting used to. It can be very snatchy / jerky below about 15 mph, and when pulling away from rest. You have to be accurate with your throttle operation. Above about this speed its generally excellent. I would recommend trying before you buy.

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - skidpan

Far as I know the current model smaller VW/Seat/Audi/Skoda petrol engines such as 1.2 / 1.4 all use the 7sp "dry clutch" system. All the diesels & 2.0 petrols use the 6sp "wet clutch" system which will take more torque

The 7 speed DSG box is used for all cars with engines of less than 250Nm of torque, that includes the 1.6 TDi which by some amazing coincidence has 250 Nm of torque. It also includes the 1.8 TSI which has had its torque limited to 250Nm (the same as the 1.4 TSi) to protect the gearbox. People with re-maps can expect a huge bill shortly.

The 6 speed DSG is used in the bigger engined stuff but I believe there is also a new 7 speed now that is used in cars like the TT.

Alternatives to DSG Gearbox - KB.

I suppose I generally agree that the DSG has had it's issues. Mine has had a new clutch pack under warranty due to clutch judder. You'd hope that someone as big and influential as VAG could sort out potential problems after this length of time. Mine was repaired after about two years in to it's three year warranty...no problems getting it done after they, initially, tried out re-programming it (or whatever they call it) and finally decided it needed a new clutch. I think they've now acknowledged the problem and fix it without a load of negotiation.

Don't have any problem at low speed for 99 percent of the time and conclude that if there ever is a bit of a low speed hiccup then that is outweighed by the cracking performance of the trasmission for the rest of the time. I love it and the manual over-ride facilities if offers, should you want them. Now the warranty is expired I'll pay just under £150 a year for an extended warranty which, I'm assured, will cover the transmission therefore I can continue to enjoy the DSG without worrying about a big bill to fix it should it go wrong. At least that's the theory!