What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Snakey

Oh great, one of the last roundabouts on my commute is now plastered with utterly pointless traffic lights. Even at rush hour it was generally easy to cross with little or no queues.

Then the lights arrived - and a week after their switching on - a half mile queue back to the previous roundabout. Seriously - who plans these things, as I'd like to whack them around the head with a sock full of marbles!

Are our councils simple hell bent on making congestion happen, so they can then somehow charge more to 'reduce' it? It seems too wilful to be accidental

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Manatee

Are you sure it hasn't improved other routes through the roundabout?

I can however well believe it is just worse. I don't have to negotiate it now, but there's a big junction in Hemel Hempstead that is a real bottleneck at commuting time. When the lights fail, the queues are much shorter.

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Snakey

Thats the thing, having crossed it for years I can categorically say its worse! There is still a long queue on the opposite carriageway (mainly caused by the lights on the following roundabout ;-)) but the route I pass though has bottled up since the lights were switched on.

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - galileo

Oh great, one of the last roundabouts on my commute is now plastered with utterly pointless traffic lights. Even at rush hour it was generally easy to cross with little or no queues.

Then the lights arrived - and a week after their switching on - a half mile queue back to the previous roundabout. Seriously - who plans these things, as I'd like to whack them around the head with a sock full of marbles!

Are our councils simple hell bent on making congestion happen, so they can then somehow charge more to 'reduce' it? It seems too wilful to be accidental

Your last sentence sums it up: ours has spent years widening pavements, installing traffic islands to prevent overtaking, installing humps, cycle lanes, bus lanes etc. Traffic lights? they have put in at least 120 round the town centre and inner ring road in the last 20 years.

The council hates car owners, thinks we are all wicked top-hatted capitalists who grind down the honest working classes who ride bikes, walk or use buses. Can't think of any other reason why.

Edited by galileo on 01/02/2018 at 13:23

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - barney100

Agree, a couple of roundabouts near me have been "improved". Ordinary roundabouts are ok by me but when lights are added as well you get the build of traffic and the inevitable grand prix, vehicles realising they are in the wrong lane cut across one another resulting in gestures, hooting and fist waving. Cycle lanes round here take up a lot of room and most cyclists prefer the pavement.

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Snakey

Its such a pain, as roundabouts are, in general, a simple but very effective way to join roads together.

Put lights on them and you simply create an issue where there wasn't one - in this case I also hit this roundabout late one night (well past rush hour) and sat at red lights looking at a completely empty roundabout for a good few minutes.

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Mr Carrot Cake

Why are light on roundabouts rarely part time?

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Cris_on_the_gas

Quite believiable.

Traffic engineers are paid to reduce crashes on the roads not to improve traffic flow.

Have you looked up the junction on http://www.collisionmap.uk/. would be interesting to see how many collisions there have been at this junction recently

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Snakey

3 accidents in the last 3 years - all classed as 'slight'

Hardly a blackspot I guess. Interesting website though

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Smileyman

In Margate some years ago the roundabout for the clock tower in the town centre got changed to traffic lights ... endless congestion resulted ..which evaporated as soon as the lights were removed. Waste of public funds to install lights then remove them better not to have spent the money in the first place, use it to pay off the PSBR or National Debt instead.

Such thoughts could be applied to many areas of public spending, including the so called experts who think up these scemes... now that would be for benefit of all of society!

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Miniman777

It would be interesting to know how modelling for a roundabout to lights transition is carried out.

In Hinckley, Leicestershire, a perfectly servicable roundabout (Rugby Rd/Hawley Rd) was replaced by traffic lights. Locals - myself included - told council it was a poor idea, we were ignored, no surprise there. Next breath, developers add additional retail units between the existing Tesco and Lidl plus houses and pub built on land that was the Sketchley cleaners.

Result: Gridlock, even more so when A5 is closed after a bridge strike.

So now council propose putting back the roundabout so that traffic flows. You simply could not make this up, made worse that no one carries the can for the money wasted.

The real irony, is that on one corner of the junction is....the council's offices.

Any - Another roundabout ruined... - Big John

Is it as bad as the one near where I live? Drivers have taken to the 20mph back streets to try and avoid it. Can't see how that is safer.

metro.co.uk/2016/06/16/new-junction-with-42-traffi.../