My wife caused minor damage to another car, but the claim shows £1600 of damage - can we ask the owner to get a second estimate? | Ask Honest John

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

My wife caused minor damage to another car, but the claim shows £1600 of damage - can we ask the owner to get a second estimate?

My wife grazed a BMW while pulling out of a very tight parking spot at a BMW garage. She thought it was very minor and might even just polish out. The same day, a quote came through from BMW at £1600 - involving lots of dismantling, reassembling, new parts (+ car care kit and ‘sundries’). We want to put it right for the driver and had intended just to do it outside of an insurance claim (I know we may still have to declare it on a renewal), but the quote seemed out of proportion. Is it reasonable for us to ask the owner to obtain a second quote from a reputable independent who would use BMW parts where necessary?

Asked on 4 December 2017 by

Answered by Honest John

What you are experiencing is what it actually costs to repair a vehicle, rather than what you think it costs to repair a vehicle. Imagine if the situation was the other way round. You can ask if they could get you another estimate, but they do have the right and entitlement to have the car repaired where they wish. Unfortunately, if your wife damaged the other vehicle, you are liable for whatever it cost to repair that damage back to it's pre-accident condition at retail rates.

Tags: insurance damage consumer advice repair costs

Similar questions

A dealer crashed my car and is repairing it for free, but can I get anything else out of them?

I took My 66-plate Skoda Octavia to the Skoda dealer with a tyre monitor problem, which they fixed. But after they washed the car, the service receptionist crashed my car into one of the new cars on the...

I caused damage to a van and my excess is very high - should I cover the repair costs myself?

Today, as I pulled out of a side road onto a main road, I hit a van. The van was indicating left and I assumed he would turn left, but he he carried straight on and I hit him. My insurance excess is £1000....

I'm paying for accident repairs without insurance involvement - how do I check the garage isn't overcharging?

I hit a car when trying to reverse out of a confined space. I offered to pay for the damage without going through my insurance company as I envisaged the repair would only be £100 - £200 max. But the third...