Are all-season tyres better than winter tyres?

Are all-season tyres an effective alternative to winter tyres on snow and ice? Would Vredestein Quatrac 5 be a significant advantage over Bridgestone Dueller on a Suzuki Grand Vitara? Or would you recommend another brand?

Asked on 28 January 2015 by John Greaves

Answered by Honest John
Yes. Wider range of sizes than Goodyear Vector 4 Seasons.
Similar questions
I’m about to take delivery of my Skoda Kodiaq PHEV. I do a significant mileage each year (about 35,000 miles) mainly on motorways, A and B roads, and really appreciate good quiet tyres. Could you recommend...
I have recently taken delivery of a Lexus NX 450+ Sport with runflat tyres. I cannot find their winter equivalent but have been told (not convincingly) that I can fit non-run flat winter tyres. Is this...
My Kia e-Niro has Michellin Primacy 3 tyres which perform poorly in the wet (they also have just over 2mm tread). My other petrol cars all have all-season tyres which are phenomenal, but the cars all weigh...
Related models
Good looking, on road handling much better than previous version, comparatively cheap, impressive off road.