What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
I've replied to CP Plus parking in response to being ticketed in a motorway service area during bad weather.
Regarding my ‘fine’ for taking a nap in a Moto motorway rest area, following your advice, here is my response to CP Plus, which I hope will at least give you a chuckle:
"Dear Sirs, Your attached request refers. I would like to advise you that I have no intention of paying any money to you. I was going to use the word "fine" but it's not really a "fine" which could be described as a sum of money to be paid as a penalty; this would be an admission of guilt of actually doing something wrong. I do not believe stopping at a service area on a night of lashing rain and wind with extremely poor visibility to be anything other than prudence and preservation on my part. I believe on the night in question I saw three motorway signs that read "severe weather forecast" ; "tiredness can kill" ; and "take a rest". Assuming "Moto" at Donington Park is a government-licensed service area, I presume your remit is to provide travellers with an area to take a break with food and rest. That is patently what I was doing.
"This type of enforcement under the proviso of a "parking charge" is laughable; highway robbery would be a more apt description. This type of enforcement is illegal in Scotland. If you wish to pursue the matter I suggest you raise a court action against me; I would be willing to bet that a judge would take a dim view of your actions. Please be advised that if you do, of course I will take the matter up with my local (Westminster) MP. I will ask him to advise the appropriate government department to look at the suitability of your company to run service areas."
"Dear Sirs, Your attached request refers. I would like to advise you that I have no intention of paying any money to you. I was going to use the word "fine" but it's not really a "fine" which could be described as a sum of money to be paid as a penalty; this would be an admission of guilt of actually doing something wrong. I do not believe stopping at a service area on a night of lashing rain and wind with extremely poor visibility to be anything other than prudence and preservation on my part. I believe on the night in question I saw three motorway signs that read "severe weather forecast" ; "tiredness can kill" ; and "take a rest". Assuming "Moto" at Donington Park is a government-licensed service area, I presume your remit is to provide travellers with an area to take a break with food and rest. That is patently what I was doing.
"This type of enforcement under the proviso of a "parking charge" is laughable; highway robbery would be a more apt description. This type of enforcement is illegal in Scotland. If you wish to pursue the matter I suggest you raise a court action against me; I would be willing to bet that a judge would take a dim view of your actions. Please be advised that if you do, of course I will take the matter up with my local (Westminster) MP. I will ask him to advise the appropriate government department to look at the suitability of your company to run service areas."
Asked on 9 March 2013 by NA, via email
Answered by
Honest John
NA later wrote, “The letter worked a treat and parking charge was dropped like a hot potato! Thanks for the advice as always. I feel sorry for all the drivers who pay up.”
Similar questions
Apropos of one of your recent letters topics - see this from the BBC: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-21752893
“Motorists who were unable to leave Pease Pottage service station on the A23 on Monday...
Last Monday our car broke down in the car park of a Welcome Break motorway services on the M5. I called out the AA and they told me it wasn't safe to drive the car. After an hour and a half under the bonnet...
I have been issued with a charge of £80 by CP Plus for overstaying my welcome at Forton services on the M6 by three hours eight minutes. In fact, we had broken down (or at least the vehicle was undrivable)...