What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Insurance claim
My Volkswagen Golf (2.0TDI, 140 bhp, 2004, 90k miles) was hit on 27th December whilst parked with no occupants in a residential area. The other party admitted liability and my vehicle is currently being repaired. I had to wait until 2nd January to hear whether it was economical to repair and will be without my car for 2-3 weeks in total.
The impact occurred at the front offside wing and wheel, and knocked my vehicle backwards 6 feet and also sideways so that the nearside wheels were lifted from the road up the kerb and onto the pavement, scraping half an inch of tarmac off the pavement in the process.
I do not recall whether the car was parked in gear. I have always taken a lot of care over my car, and had it serviced every 10,000 miles (shorter than the recommended interval). In the last 6 months I have had new rear brakes, discs, handbrake cable & caliper, glowplugs, throttle valve, coil spring and tyres. Additionally, my garage bills over the last 12 month period have been the highest to date (£2,009 for 2012).
I am concerned that the accident may have caused damage to the vehicle which is not immediately obvious, and will affect the longevity of parts old and new in the future. The assessor has agreed to replace part of the steering mechanism, the offside front tyre only and repair the bodywork to the wing, bumper and slight damage to the offside front door. He says there is no visible damage to the alloy wheels which have been scraped up the kerb.
I have declined the offer of a hire car whilst my vehicle is being repaired, and would much prefer to put any costs that otherwise would have been met towards a vehicle warranty for peace of mind in the future. Please can you advise what would be reasonable for me to expect and the best way to negotiate with the repairer and insurance company.
The impact occurred at the front offside wing and wheel, and knocked my vehicle backwards 6 feet and also sideways so that the nearside wheels were lifted from the road up the kerb and onto the pavement, scraping half an inch of tarmac off the pavement in the process.
I do not recall whether the car was parked in gear. I have always taken a lot of care over my car, and had it serviced every 10,000 miles (shorter than the recommended interval). In the last 6 months I have had new rear brakes, discs, handbrake cable & caliper, glowplugs, throttle valve, coil spring and tyres. Additionally, my garage bills over the last 12 month period have been the highest to date (£2,009 for 2012).
I am concerned that the accident may have caused damage to the vehicle which is not immediately obvious, and will affect the longevity of parts old and new in the future. The assessor has agreed to replace part of the steering mechanism, the offside front tyre only and repair the bodywork to the wing, bumper and slight damage to the offside front door. He says there is no visible damage to the alloy wheels which have been scraped up the kerb.
I have declined the offer of a hire car whilst my vehicle is being repaired, and would much prefer to put any costs that otherwise would have been met towards a vehicle warranty for peace of mind in the future. Please can you advise what would be reasonable for me to expect and the best way to negotiate with the repairer and insurance company.
Asked on 7 January 2013 by anagama
Answered by
Honest John
You can't negotiate with the repairer because you have no contract with him. The only contract you do have is worth your insurer. I'm surprised that your car was not written off. I think you are entitled to ask for a courtesy car while yours is repaired, but NOT a 'credit hire car'. As long as you 'mitigate' the expense of the hire car (best done by taking a cheaper, smaller, basic hire car) you should not create any liability for yourself over it.
Similar questions
I was interested to read your letter headed ‘Decline and Fall’ in the DT dated Saturday 13 August. I had an almost identical situation arise as MM of Hawick which involved the same insurance company. Last...
My son and his partner purchased a pre-reg Clio Music with zero miles last October for the advertised price of £8,500. In December, whilst stationary in a jam on the motorway, they were hit in the rear...
Must I go through an insurance claim after damaging another car, or can I pay for the damage myself?
I bumped a girl's Volkswagen Polo in an the work car park on the near-side wing. I have stated that I would pay for the damage I had caused rather than go through the insurance. She stated that it would...
Related models
Comfortable and quiet on the move, enjoyable to drive. Nicely trimmed with great attention to detail. 1.4 TSI sweeter to drive than a diesel.