Diesel or Petrol?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Diesel or Petrol?

Our three-year-old A160 petrol is coming to the end of its contract, and we've been offered a diesel version at a very good price on the same finance basis.

The current commute is about 85 miles per day (mainly all fast A road), but we're not sure about any cost benefits bearing in mind the extra price of diesel. Any advice regarding petrol/diesel mpg figures gratefully received.

Asked on 8 March 2012 by SD merc

Answered by Honest John

Diesels are usually cheaper to run for the first 3 years, but then can suffer catastrophic repair bills during years 3 - 6.

Tags: buying

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:

Similar questions

Which car for lowest maintenance

I need something my wife can drive (so not a long car) that is safe and also spacious enough to accommodate two children. So a large cabin, but don't need a big boot. It must be a car that won't break...

Shell diesel fuel pricing

I follow your advice in the Telegraph to avoid buying supermarket fuels and buy Shell as you recommend because of the ad alwaysditives therein. However, there are two grades of diesel sold in my local...

Buying a new car. What options match my A Class 1.8 Diesel CVT

We wish to replace our 2009 Mercedes A Class 1.8 diesel CVT with a similar, non-Mercedes CVT about the same size and power. What cars are available? We are having problems establishing which cars have...

Related models