What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Why are modern cars, like my wife's Volkswagen Touran, so complicated?

Surely there is something fundamentally stupid about the way we are building cars today? I drive a ten-year-old Toyota Yaris, a wonderful little car. My wife has a larger car, a Volkswagen Touran, for her job as a nanny (employer's kids, pushchairs, dogs and so on). Three weeks ago the dashboard display told her to rush to a garage to have the oxygen exhaust level thingy checked. Some malevolent on-board computer gadget told them that we also needed a door mechanism and the air-conditioning fixed.

The very nice people at Volkswagen have done all this and my complaint is not against them. But we are now £1,600 lighter in the pocket for no real gain whatsoever. Our driving experience is exactly what it was before. If I wanted a spaceship I would go to Florida. When I was a small boy I could identify all of the bits under the bonnet. Now all I find when I lift the lid is an unintelligible collection of boxes. We need to take the ego out of car design.

I am one of those apparently rare people who are perfectly happy if their vehicle starts, stops and turns left and right when I tell it to. Remember when every street had a bloke who was always tinkering with cars, and dads could teach their teenage children how to do a basic service? There must be a place in the market for a car that is reliable, durable and doesn't induce wallet-panic whenever servicing is required.

Asked on 3 April 2011 by MM, Chessington

Answered by Honest John
You got the wrong end of the stick. All this stuff has been legislated into cars due to the intensive lobbying of the component manufacturers and the desire of car manufacturers to profit from replacing parts during the life of the car. "Safety laws" and "Emissions Laws" do not get passed unless they generate profit. Campaigning groups are financed by the manufacturers who benefit from their campaigns.
Similar questions
I am the owner of a 2006 Volkswagen Touran 1.9 litre MPV. I have had an ESP traction warning light on my dashboard for some time. To date I have had two mechanics have a look at the issue, but after trying...
You recently diagnosed an “antiskid service required" warning on a Volvo XC90 as being due to different sized tyres front to back, but there may be a different reason. When my 2006 Volvo S60 was about...
My Renault Scenic has started to intermittently display the warning message on the dash "Check Injection" with the service light. I've checked out the definition in my handbook and it says "serious engine...
Related models
Solid, small 7-seater with a comfortable ride. 2.0 TDI model is greatly improved by DSG autobox and gets 3 stars.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer