Should Honda have replaced these parts?

Our four year old Honda Jazz, bought 12 months ago as approved used, passed its MOT and on the same day Honda carried out a short service and safety check.

They gave a red alert on the corroded brake pipes and lower suspension arm yet it had only done 6K miles since we bought it.t Total mileage of 20K.

We complained and the garage agreed to replace the brake pipes FOC ang give us a 10% discount for the arms, leaving us a £600 bill.

I asked to see the failed items and the flexibles only had surface corrosion, no deep pits on the ferrules, and the rubber bushes looked OK as well.

Surely they should have been found on their multipoint inspection for an approved car if they are as bad as they claim now. Who can I get an opinion from on their condition as Honda will not get involved?

Asked on 7 November 2011 by BNG

Answered by Honest John
If the brake pipes have been replaced FOC then why worry? Or is your dispute over the suspension arms? It's the first I've heard of this particular failure.
Similar questions
Any ideas please on a soft/long brake pedal on a 2014 Ford Focus 1.6 diesel. I have bled the brakes and the pedal is better but then gets softer over the course of the next two/three weeks? I have checked...
I need to fit a new rear brake caliper to my Vauxhall Zafira because the handbrake actuator has stopped working. However, I wish to use the existing half worn pads, what is the correct procedure for extending...
Our 2010 Fiat 500 has developed an intermittent high pitched squeal which seems to come from the front wheels (difficult to tell but seems to be RHS). Sounds like disc and pad rubbing as the squeal disappears...
Related models
Clever interior redefined the small car. Most space efficient small car built. Very reliable first 3 - 4 years.