What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Is it time to dispose of my car?
I have a 2011 Mazda 2 TS2 which has covered only 29,000 miles. I have owned it since 2014 and am the second owner.
I recently had it serviced by a Mazda specialist who I know and trust. He recommended Dinitrol treatment at a cost of £350 if I was going to keep the car otherwise I would have corrosion problems underneath e.g. to the rear chassis. The MoT is due in January and I think it will pass but I am reluctant to spend £350 in this way on a 10-year old car.
We can afford to change it for something newer and have mainly bought low-mileage cars or demonstrators in the past.
Online valuations vary between approx. £1,600 and £3,000. The car runs well, has a new Varta battery and good tyres. There are one or two dents - should I have these rectified before selling or trading?
What would you recommend as a replacement? Prior to owning the Mazda we ran a Skoda Fabia 1.2 HTP and a couple of Volkswagen Polos.
I have looked online so far at Skoda Fabias, SEAT Ibizas and the smaller Skoda Citigo, SEAT Mii and Volkswagen Up. I have also looked at Suzuki and Toyota (Yaris). I won't buy anything French.
Used prices have "gone through the roof" it appears. I would not want to spend more than £12,000 (less whatever I receive in part exchange or by selling privately).
We own two other cars - a 2011 Mazda MX-5 2.0 SE Roadster Coupe and a Skoda Yeti 1.2TSI SEL. We are both in our 70s and don't do much mileage in any of the cars.
If only we could buy a small car with the handling of the MX-5!
I recently had it serviced by a Mazda specialist who I know and trust. He recommended Dinitrol treatment at a cost of £350 if I was going to keep the car otherwise I would have corrosion problems underneath e.g. to the rear chassis. The MoT is due in January and I think it will pass but I am reluctant to spend £350 in this way on a 10-year old car.
We can afford to change it for something newer and have mainly bought low-mileage cars or demonstrators in the past.
Online valuations vary between approx. £1,600 and £3,000. The car runs well, has a new Varta battery and good tyres. There are one or two dents - should I have these rectified before selling or trading?
What would you recommend as a replacement? Prior to owning the Mazda we ran a Skoda Fabia 1.2 HTP and a couple of Volkswagen Polos.
I have looked online so far at Skoda Fabias, SEAT Ibizas and the smaller Skoda Citigo, SEAT Mii and Volkswagen Up. I have also looked at Suzuki and Toyota (Yaris). I won't buy anything French.
Used prices have "gone through the roof" it appears. I would not want to spend more than £12,000 (less whatever I receive in part exchange or by selling privately).
We own two other cars - a 2011 Mazda MX-5 2.0 SE Roadster Coupe and a Skoda Yeti 1.2TSI SEL. We are both in our 70s and don't do much mileage in any of the cars.
If only we could buy a small car with the handling of the MX-5!
Asked on 6 December 2021 by Roger Hulme
Answered by
Andrew Brady
A shortage in new cars means used car prices are inflated at the moment. As you've found, this means you might be surprised by your Mazda's value. It also means a replacement might be more expensive than it would be otherwise. If you really want to cash in on the current situation, perhaps you could sell the Mazda 2 now and use one of your other cars until prices of newer models drop? It's difficult to say when this will be, however.
It certainly sounds like a good time to sell your Mazda if a specialist is warning you of rust issues. Don't bother repairing dents – no one expects perfect bodywork on a car of this age.
As a replacement, take a look at a Ford Fiesta. It handles very well (if not quite as well as your MX-5) while there are lots available on the used market. We'd also recommend the latest Volkswagen Polo. If you like Mazdas, the current Mazda 2 is well worth a look, too.
It certainly sounds like a good time to sell your Mazda if a specialist is warning you of rust issues. Don't bother repairing dents – no one expects perfect bodywork on a car of this age.
As a replacement, take a look at a Ford Fiesta. It handles very well (if not quite as well as your MX-5) while there are lots available on the used market. We'd also recommend the latest Volkswagen Polo. If you like Mazdas, the current Mazda 2 is well worth a look, too.
Similar questions
My daughter has a Hyundai i10 but will shortly be looking for a new car. She wants something similar in size to the i10 or not much bigger, at least as high up as the i10, but the most important factors...
I'm considering a new/used Ford Fiesta Powershift but my local independent garage (very experienced and trustworthy) has warned me off the 1.0 Ecoboost engine as he has seen a number of failures. He says...
I have a Volkswagen Tiguan on order which is expected for delivery next month (which will be almost one year after ordering!). I no longer need the car but am loathed to lose my deposit so am wondering...
Related models
.jpg?width=115&height=75&rmode=crop)
Enjoyable and fun to drive with economical engines. Feels well built. Ride quality was improved for 2011.
Attractive small car that'll be cheap to run. Lots of standard equipment. Easy and fun to drive.
Most versions good to drive especially ST-Line but significantly more refined, comfortable and practical, comes with active safety technology as standard.
More Golf-like than ever, will carry four large adults in comfort, huge boot, excellent TSI petrol engines.
.jpg)
