What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Buckler’s hard

I have a 2005 BMW 535D M Sport Touring with standard 235/40R18 wheels and tyres. 6 months ago, when planning a routine 4-wheel tyre change at Micheldever Tyres, they informed me that both rear wheels had cracked. Remarkably the local BMW dealer had 2 wheels on the shelf which, at £450 each, was a huge surprise. Micheldever said that this type of wheel failure was very common with BMW and that the runflat tyres were a significant contributing factor. I had been considering coming off RFTs as they badly affect the ride and so made the decision to fit Dunlop SP Sport. The ride was dramatically different and I was very pleased with the result. I contacted BMW customer service to complain about the wheels and to say that they weren’t interested would be an understatement. They blamed UK roads and said that it was likely that I hit speed humps too fast. Last week I had a slow puncture and arranged for my local tyre fitter to try and repair the puncture. They were not able to do this and worse still informed me that the rim had cracked. On further inspection another rim had cracked as well. Once again these were on the back axle and were the rims that had been purchased from the BMW dealer in Winchester only a few months prior. The tyre fitter then mentioned that they are getting these all the time with BMW and that one driver had even had 6 rims. I decided to take a bit of time thinking about what to do this time and have taken the decision to fit aftermarket rims. I don’t know if this is going to turn out to be a good decision but I just can’t afford t o replace wheels at the rate BMW would appear to think is normal. I drive approximately 30k miles per year with a large amount of these on motorways. I have driven this kind of mileage for 25 years and have never had to replace a wheel before.

Asked on 14 November 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Yes. It’s very common with BMW 18" and 19" rims. They are not suitable for driving on Britain's roads in the state the roads are now in. I've done all I can with BMW already. I think the problem is that BMW UK cannot get the case across to BMW Germany who simply blame the poor state of Britain's roads. Best advice I can give is to go down a wheel size and fit deeper profile tyres. You'll not only get improved ride comfort, you'll be surprised at the improvement to steering feel and wet road grip. New softer sidewall Bridgestone Runflat 3s are arriving about now and will also help considerably to absorb road shocks.
Similar questions
The internet is awash with complaints across the world that appear to relate to the combination of 19" wheels and low profile runflat tyres. I have never in the last 27 years of my driving experience ever...
I’m considering a new set of ‘KEI force 10’ Alloy wheels for my 2002 Mini Cooper S. To keep costs down I was considering, swapping the runflats from the old wheels to the new. I am getting mixed opinions...
The alloy wheels on my wife's 4.5 years old Mercedes C180 Kompressor SE are peeling and bubbling. The car was bought new and has been serviced at the local Mercedes garage where it was bought. They have...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer