What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Boxer rebellion

In April 2008 my son bought a 2005 Ford Focus 1.6, 5-door automatic from Car Giant. The car had a recorded mileage of 30,000 and was ex-Motability with a service history. Since then the car has been driven a further 6,000 miles. Around 14 days ago, problems were encountered with the gearbox and the car was taken to an independent workshop. The workshop (at no charge) diagnosed a shattered 4th gear and quoted £1,500 + VAT to replace the gearbox with a, presumably reconditioned, unit covered by a 2 year warranty. Meanwhile, my son had been advised to speak to Ford directly to see if the company might be willing to contribute to the costs of the new gearbox – given the car’s age and mileage. My son spoke to the Ford Customer Relations Centre. He was told that under no circumstances would Ford consider any contribution unless the car was first inspected by a Ford dealer. My son’s wife then drove it to a Ford garage in Alperton, where she was quoted £150 to diagnose the problem. She was advised that if a replacement gearbox was required, the likely cost for the work would be £2,500. Whilst the car was at the Alperton garage a further telephone call was made to Ford when they were told that the company would not help because the car was by then 50 months old and the company’s “goodwill contribution” period expires after 44 months. There was no alternative other than to return the car to the first garage for the work to be carried out last week. If my daughter-in-law had been told it would not be covered she would never have taken it to the Ford garage. Of greater significance to your readers than Ford’s customer care is the quality of their cars. A gearbox should surely be of sufficient fitness for purpose and of satisfactory quality to enable it to safely endure an average of less than 10,000 miles each year over a four-year period.

Asked on 18 July 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
The car was four years and 2 months old. You don't know what sort of abuse it was subjected to by the previous, probably disabled, driver. Had all this happened within 6 months of purchase then Car Giant would have accepted liability. I'm as unhappy as you are about the treatment by the Ford dealer. But in all fairness, the dealer could not properly ascertain why the box had failed without dismantling it, and if it had been a lesser fault then the cost of rebuilding the box might have been a lot less.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I want to buy a second hand Mercedes-Benz CLK 230 Kompressor with tiptonic gear box (2002). It's done 126,000 miles. I understand that IF the gear box goes I'm looking at a large bill but do you know...
I would appreciate your assistance with the following matter: I purchased a Saab 9-5 Estate 2.3 Aero manual (2005 05 - 1 owner and 105k miles with full Saab service history) from a dealer on 22nd April...
I am looking at buying a 2005 Peugeot 307 HDI with 108k on the clock. Apparently it sometimes crunches going into third gear, but no other gear. It doesnt pop out of gear, just crunches getting it. How...