What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Used car with a loud gearbox
I would appreciate your assistance with the following matter:
I purchased a Saab 9-5 Estate 2.3 Aero manual (2005 05 - 1 owner and 105k miles with full Saab service history) from a dealer on 22nd April 2012. In the first week of ownership I noticed a whine from the transmission - particularly in 1st and 2nd gear.
I took the vehicle to a local specialist Saab dealer (not the supplying dealer) - who inspected and identified an overfilled gearbox and damaged bearings causing the noise. Written report indicated gearbox replacement or repair as the solution.
I immediately contacted the supplying dealer, who agreed to take the car back and subject it to inspection himself (which he has apparently undertaken).
It took 2 weeks to get any form of response - with the dealer indicating; "...as far as I'm concerned the vehicle is fit for purpose and perfectly commensurate with being 7 yrs old and 100k miles. The gearbox has not failed..."
I have not collected the car and am not content as the issue remains with the car.
What is my position with this issue - as the car does drive, but may fail at any time? I feel I have been reasonable in providing the car back to the dealer, leaving it with them for inspection and even providing a copy of the report I paid for to diagnose the problem.
he Dealer Principal has not answered my calls and the only contact I have from him is a text message, which included the quote above.
The dealer concerned is Specialist Cars of Somerset - an organisation trading as a supplier of high-end and exotic cars. I paid £3,000 for the Saab (including a trade-in, which has since been sold). I like the car - as I have indicated to the dealer, but am not content that the issue remains.
Could you please recommend a way-forward with this issue - as at present I have no access to a vehicle! If I collect the vehicle and have it repaired - am I likely to be able to recover costs (and could I sue through my local small claims court)?
Should I formally reject and try to recover the full purchase price (though I appreciate this may take some time and be expensive/messy)?
I purchased a Saab 9-5 Estate 2.3 Aero manual (2005 05 - 1 owner and 105k miles with full Saab service history) from a dealer on 22nd April 2012. In the first week of ownership I noticed a whine from the transmission - particularly in 1st and 2nd gear.
I took the vehicle to a local specialist Saab dealer (not the supplying dealer) - who inspected and identified an overfilled gearbox and damaged bearings causing the noise. Written report indicated gearbox replacement or repair as the solution.
I immediately contacted the supplying dealer, who agreed to take the car back and subject it to inspection himself (which he has apparently undertaken).
It took 2 weeks to get any form of response - with the dealer indicating; "...as far as I'm concerned the vehicle is fit for purpose and perfectly commensurate with being 7 yrs old and 100k miles. The gearbox has not failed..."
I have not collected the car and am not content as the issue remains with the car.
What is my position with this issue - as the car does drive, but may fail at any time? I feel I have been reasonable in providing the car back to the dealer, leaving it with them for inspection and even providing a copy of the report I paid for to diagnose the problem.
he Dealer Principal has not answered my calls and the only contact I have from him is a text message, which included the quote above.
The dealer concerned is Specialist Cars of Somerset - an organisation trading as a supplier of high-end and exotic cars. I paid £3,000 for the Saab (including a trade-in, which has since been sold). I like the car - as I have indicated to the dealer, but am not content that the issue remains.
Could you please recommend a way-forward with this issue - as at present I have no access to a vehicle! If I collect the vehicle and have it repaired - am I likely to be able to recover costs (and could I sue through my local small claims court)?
Should I formally reject and try to recover the full purchase price (though I appreciate this may take some time and be expensive/messy)?
Asked on 19 May 2012 by Tim S
Answered by
Honest John
Over a £3,000 7 year old 100,000 mile car I think the dealer is being reasonable. I've bought and sold cars with noisy boxes before and never had one give up on me. With one car (a 1988 Jetta 16v), I put some STP transmission additive into the box via the speedo drive point and, though noisy, it held together for a couple of years and remained together in the hands of the guy I sold the car to. So, I suggest you try that.
Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.
The Good Garage Guide
Our honest used car pricing is a little bit different to all the others. You can get to our values through make or model - you don’t have to follow a prescribed route. Plus, it’s live, which means we can react to changes in the market quicker than any printed price guide.
Honest Used Car Prices
Dear Honest John,
Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
Similar questions
A friend bought a September 2008 BMW 530d M Sport automatic from BMW franchised dealer Bavarian Garages in Belfast in May this year.
It has the optional sport automatic gearbox (including the shift paddles...
Do you know how long the EGS6 gearbox will last in a C4 Grand Picasso 1.6 HDI?
I want to buy a second hand Mercedes-Benz CLK 230 Kompressor with tiptonic gear box (2002).
It's done 126,000 miles.
I understand that IF the gear box goes I'm looking at a large bill but do you know...
Related models
.jpg?width=115&height=75&rmode=crop)
Decent mix of performance and economy. Superb long-distance comfort aided by good ride and fantastic seats. An exceptionally safe car.
Elsewhere on 
.jpg)
