What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

The sum of all gears

I have been recommended to write to you by a friend who reads the Telegraph. In short, we bought a brand new Grand Cherokee 3.0 CRD in July 2005. It went back to the dealer with gearbox problems at 1 month old, then throughout the warranty period it was returned numerous times with the same problem. Two months out of warranty the car was again returned same problem. This time we were told the gearbox needed completely replacing at a cost of £12,000 and we had to put £6,500 towards this. We contacted Trading Standards and wrote letters to Jeep Finance. They were to conduct an investigation within 8 weeks, but we heard nothing so wrote again and again heard nothing. We contacted SMMT and Financial Ombudsman. Yesterday, out of the blue, the Jeep dealer rang and said the price of the gearbox had decreased to £5,500 and we should pay £1,000 or would have to take our case to court. We feel we have been backed into corner Can you please help?

Asked on 25 April 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
If you are only being asked to pay £1,000 rather than £6,500 then you have to consider the potential cost of fighting this through a court. Because the transmission has always been faulty and because this is well documented you stand a good chance of winning on the grounds that the transmission was never "of satisfactory quality". But you might lose. This will certainly cause further delay. And it could cost you more money. See FAQ Consumer Rights: Rejecting a Duff Car at www.honestjohn.co.uk
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I bought a Land Rover Defender 90 advertised as really clean inside and out with everything working has it should, with an MoT and no advisories. The car broke down in my second journey, failed an MoT...
We brought a 2017 Ford Tourneo in October last year. The seller said it has full service history. We have been chasing the history since we brought it and finally received it last week. It is not a full...
On the 16th of March I went to see and test drive a Nissan at the West-Way Garage Stourbridge. My daughter test drove a Nissan Micra Visia. As it did not have air conditioning we were keen to buy a Micra...
Related models
Bold and chunky styling, excellent 3.0 CRD diesel engine, superbly capable off-road, well equipped as standard, good-sized boot, great for towing.