What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Getout claws
I have seen you recommend Warranty Direct in the past and so covered my SAAB 9-3 with one of their Extra Care warranties. This was renewed in October last year and I have just upgraded it to a no limit policy. The car has always been maintained to manufacturers specification with the exception of receiving additional oil changes at mid points between services. Last Wednesday the heater fan stopped working, I notified Warranty Direct by e-mail on Thursday that I had booked the car into Lookers Chester SAAB to investigate on Monday 2nd February and that there could be a possible claim. The car went into Lookers (who have always maintained the car since new) to determine the fault, which was that the heater fan and control relay had failed. Lookers submitted the claim via Warranty Direct's online system (once they were given the correct information). Warranty Direct then requested a complete breakdown of all the required parts prices, labour costs, etc. which was supplied Monday pm Warranty Direct requested on Tuesday a faxed copy of the MOT Certificate which was supplied. On Wednesday they requested a copy of the last service invoice, which I supplied to the garage Thursday morning as they have changed their systems and no longer have access to previous servicing records. Warranty Direct then asked the garage when the pollen Filter was last changed - answer at the last service (its changed every service) Warranty Direct then asked why the components had failed. The garage have responded that they think that at some time the components may have got wet, because of a blocked drain hole, but that currently the area was dry and non of the drain holes was blocked. The claim has been rejected because of exclusion clause 12 which states: “Breakdown or damage to parts (whether insured or not) caused by frost, water, freezing liquids, carbon build-up, corrosion, oxidisation, blockages, contaminants building up, sludge or silt, or other waste matter that has prevented the parts from working properly.” That clause is so wide as to render the policy useless. Cars by the nature of their use are likely to get wet, in use they are likely to be exposed to air-born contaminants. Am I being unreasonable to feel that Warranty Direct are selling policies under false pretences.
Asked on 21 March 2009 by
Answered by
Honest John
You write, "That clause is so wide as to render the policy useless." Not really, because this is a maintenance issue and if there has been
water ingress to the car because of blocked vent well drains then any
problem it causes is induced rather than a straightforward breakdown. And it is becoming increasingly common for franchised garages to ‘load’ the amount of work required for an independent warranty claim in order to make as much money as they can from it. But you have been very patient in submitting everything WD wanted so I will resubmit this to the MD who may or may not decide the circumstances warrant changing the decision. (WD agreed to pay that same day.)
water ingress to the car because of blocked vent well drains then any
problem it causes is induced rather than a straightforward breakdown. And it is becoming increasingly common for franchised garages to ‘load’ the amount of work required for an independent warranty claim in order to make as much money as they can from it. But you have been very patient in submitting everything WD wanted so I will resubmit this to the MD who may or may not decide the circumstances warrant changing the decision. (WD agreed to pay that same day.)
Similar questions
I have a Saab 9-3 convertible TTiD, which is 2008 registered and has covered 52,000 miles, trouble-free, mainly on motorways over long distances at steady speeds.
I am considering buying an extended...
The BMW warranty is due to expire at the end of this month on my E91 estate which has done 29,000 miles and will be four years old.
Is it worth renewing the warranty?
We have a 2007 Honda CRV ES 2.2iCDTI that is coming up to 3 years old and we usually think of changing at this point. However we both enjoy the car and due to changed circumstances it has not yet reached...
Related models
More of the same. Modernised with sharper looks. Quick 2.8 twin-turbo. Strong diesels. Spare parts still readily available.