What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Hyped drid
As a pensioner, I have to minimise the running costs of my car so I traded my 3-Series BMW for what I thought would be a much more economical car. I chose a Honda Civic Hybrid because the website and the brochure claimed an average fuel consumption of 61.4 MPG. Now, having done over 3,000 miles including two long motorway runs of over 800 miles each, I am barely making 40mpg. I wrote to Honda drawing their attention to this and received a reply that contained a lot of weasel words about Honda having to carry out tests according to the Ministry of Transport regulations etc. They also stated that every driving style was different and that road conditions had a bearing on the results obtained. They ended this part by saying "For these reasons the fuel consumption achieved on the road is unlikely to be the same as official test results”. The letter ended by advising me not to have my car checked over at my garage as I was not going to get any better fuel consumption. Now I can appreciate that everybody drives differently and could accept as much as a 10% reduction from the official figures but not the 50% that I am experiencing. I feel Honda has cheated me with their spurious claims and would like your advice on what can be done about this. Surely Honda should be required to state what normal drivers may expect as to fuel consumption and not publish unobtainable figure that are obviously used as a dishonest selling point.
Asked on 31 January 2009 by
Answered by
Honest John
Manufacturers are compelled by EC law to test their fuel economy in a certain way, overseen by VCA inspectors, and are then only allowed to use the figures thus obtained in any brochures or publicity material. The VCA's own website explains that these figures are not necessarily representative of what real drivers can obtain. That said. I wound up averaging 49mpg in a Prius over 6 months, and at 57mpg over 8 months I am fairly close to the published combined figure for my Focus ECOnetic. Yet I only got 45.3mpg from the old Civic IMA and 42.7mpg from the current model Honda Civic hybrid, which almost exactly matches the 42.94mpg I got from a Honda City 1.5 IVTEC 5-speed auto. Obviously, cold weather, during which cars overfuel for much longer, will slaughter fuel economy, especially on cars used mainly for short runs. All that said, someone in Germany has successfully sued Mercedes Benz in a regional court because they could not match the advertised fuel economy figures. More at www.spiegel.de/auto/aktuell/0,1518,594397,00.html Though you will need to be understand German.
Similar questions
I have owned an 07 BMW 320D Sport Tourer Auto from new. Until last Autumn, I was averaging 37mpg. This has fallen over the winter to 24mpg in town and 34mpg on open road. There are no significant indications...
I bought this car four weeks ago and I am getting 35 mpg average on a 400+ mile round trip. Driving on the motorway for over 80 miles at 76 mph with cruise control on I can not get the trip screen to show...
My 2002 1.9 TDI Passat estate 130 occasionally cuts out when started from cold (usually on pulling up at the traffic lights) and is slightly heavier on fuel than it used to be.
Now get around 37 per...
Related models
Congestion charge exempt if registered before January 2011, cheap car tax.