What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Playing scrapple

3 weeks ago my 10-year-old Proton Persona was in a quite severe accident. My insurers (co-op) uplifted it and have assessed it as being beyond economical repair and offered the market value of £450. I appreciate that if I looked hard I could purchase a 10 yr old runner for that sort of money, though as an aside, my car was known to me and had a full service history, so I think their valuation a little on the stingy side anyway. What I am concerned about is that they are asking me to prove that I had already entered into a purchase agreement before they will consider the scrappage scheme value. I have seen mention in Honest John’s site that they have a duty to return me to the position I was in prior to the accident and as they have no means of sending me back in time; how can I purchase a car and have owned it for the one year required to qualify for the scrappage scheme? The accident was a much witnessed one with 3 statements given to the police by independent witnesses confirming that the fault was with the other driver, I as I believe is usually the case am struggling to deal with the aftermath. Further, I assume that as my car was driven by the impact to collide head on with a Mercedes SLK, the driver of which also confirming that I had been at no fault, his insurer will no doubt be claiming against my insurer and I will no longer have my full no claims discount. How do I recover what will be a serious financial loss over the next 5 years as I pay the much increased premiums I will no doubt have to pay?

Asked on 20 February 2010 by P.A., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John
You insurer is entirely correct. If you had not already entered into a scrappage deal, to be completed by a specific date, your vehicle did not have £2,000 'scrappage value'. It is only worth its replacement cost on the used market (which you might be able to argue up). £2,000 'scrappage' was only a £2,000 discount on a new car, £1,000 of which came from the Taxpayer and £1,000 of which came from the car manufacturer or importer. It has no value in itself unless a scrappage deal has already been done. If such a deal has already been done, then the wrecked car automatically has the scrappage value because it was going to be scrapped anyway.
Similar questions
My 17-yr old son (recently passed) was driving my Seat Ibiza 1.2 and was hit from behind at approx 35mph. Damage is to the rear bumper and the other driver has admitted liability. My son has no whiplash...
My car was recently driven into by a thrd party who admitted responsibility. The damage was minor; rear window and bumper. The car was sent to a garage to be assessed, and an estimate of £1300 made for...
We drove our classic Riley 300 miles to Cornwall to be the bridal car for a friend's wedding, only for some idiot, who was clearly driving without due care and attention, to reverse into us, stoving in...