What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

A third party damaged our car and has offered to pay for the repair or go through insurance - what is the better method?

My daughter's car was scraped in a supermarket car park. The driver of the guilty car has given her his insurance details and has said that she can put the repair through insurance or he will pay for it. What are the pros and cons of either method?

Asked on 5 August 2019 by gray2015

Answered by Honest John
Have your daughter get a quote for repairs at a reputable bodyshop and provide it to the other party. If he is happy to pay for the repairs, then all parties are happy as no insurers are involved (this is a Civil claim outside of the road traffic act). If he advises it is more than he can afford, it is a conflict of interest for your daughter to deal directly with the at-fault insurer, Having the "paymaster" of the repair dictate what they want to pay you is a never a good idea, you also have no entitlement to complain to the FOS should things go wrong. Use a "reputable" claims management company or her own insurer, or as a last resort, the at-fault insurer directly.
Similar questions
My car was hit on the left front wing which also broke the headlight. The car was still driveable but my insurer is saying it will cost nearly £3000 to repair which I don't believe. What can I do?
A friend asked if someone with whom he had done a house and car swap, could drop off his car at my house. When the car arrived he had his wife and two teenage children with him. They needed to go to the...
My nephew's car suffered body and wheel damage while it was left for a routine service at a garage. He noticed the damage when he was collecting the car, and although they didn't deny the damage happened...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer