What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Volkswagen Polo - Car suggestions Polo sized run around £1600-£2400 - guygamps

4 years ago I bought a 2001 Polo 1.4v 5 door, my daughter learned to drive in it, and has driven it "as hers" since she passed her test about 2 years ago, Her studies and her work take her all over South East of England, sometimes she drives, sometimes she uses the train, the trains where she is based are terrible, it took her 6 hours to get from Brighton to Canterbury, which had nothig to do with snow just a while ago,

The Polo is now needing new gearbox and clutch the cost of which is much higher then the value of the car.

thinking of replacing it, but at this price level there is so much luck involved determining if you get a lemon or something half decent.

Suggestions?

GUY

Volkswagen Polo - Car suggestions Polo sized run around £1600-£2400 - 72 dudes

I think at this price level, the most important factor is condition and provable service history. The interior of a car often gives a better clue as to how well a car has been looked after. Buy from a known garage to protect yourself under the Sale of Goods act. Do your research, try and find old bills/invoices, speak to the previous owner(s), and take it on a proper test drive, at least 10 miles, not just round the block.

The previous model Fiesta falls into this price bracket, you could do a lot worse in terms of parts prices and cheap to fix.

You could look for a Yaris or Micra, older shape Fabia, or indeed another Polo.

But Condition is more important than model.

Volkswagen Polo - Car suggestions Polo sized run around £1600-£2400 - Auristocrat

First generation Mazda 2 (2003-07). Third member of Fiesta/Fusion family.

Volkswagen Polo - Car suggestions Polo sized run around £1600-£2400 - Happy Blue!
Condition is all. You might find a low mileage example of something 'boring' but it could be good value; e.g. a Kia Rio Mk2.
Volkswagen Polo - Car suggestions Polo sized run around £1600-£2400 - Mr Fox

Stick the Old Polo on EBAY, even with the faults you have stated mentioned, somebody will buy it and maybe fix it.

It is amazing what people will buy on Ebay.

I had to dispose of an old Fiat Punto with a blown engine, and got an Easy £300.00 for it, there were literally dozens of people after it.

To a hobby mechanic with time and expertise, your Polo could be fixed up and there should still be plenty of life in it.

Regarding a replacement, you could easily find a decent Renault Clio 1.5 DCI or a Modus 1.5 DCI which cost peanuts to run.

Edited by Mr Fox on 30/01/2013 at 21:26