What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
VW Golf - HJ VWGolf VII review - SteveLee

review: "We drove the 1.4 TSI 140PS engine with the clever cylinder deactivation system. This disengages two of the cylinders when the car is under light loads, so for instance when you're off the accelerator and the car is coasting."

Surely when your foot is off the throttle and you are coasting, no modern car is injecting fuel on the over-run?

VW Golf - HJ VWGolf VII review - unthrottled

Pioneered by the reviled GM on the 1981 Cadillac 5.7 V8. Reintroduced by GM in 2001 and used ever since. Chrysler put it on their V8 around 2003.

Mitsubishi played around with it on 4 pots around 2000-and took it off because the fuel savings weren't worth the increased NVH problem.

Doesn't stop the PR mem from claiming to have reinvented the wheel.

The idea is that under light loads (not overrun) you shut off two cylinders so that there is no pumping losses across those cylinders. This increases manifold pressre for the other two cylinders which increases overall efficiency. It does work although the gains are modest. Instantaneous fuel injection rate is of course irrelevant to fuel economy.

VW Golf - HJ VWGolf VII review - gordonbennet

When you say shuts off cylinders, presumably the pistons are still moving, but the valves have been locked open?...or is this some fantastic design that disconnects the pistons somehow? if neither exactly what is going on please cos i suspect more complicated and expensive electronics to go wrong to save little.

VW Golf - HJ VWGolf VII review - unthrottled

Oh yes, you still get all the friction from the inactive pistons-just the pumping loss that goes.

It works really well with pushrod designs because you simply use a collapsible hydraulic lifter-the rest of the valvetrain is entirely conventional. Not quite as easy with direct acting designs.

VW Golf - HJ VWGolf VII review - gordonbennet

Ah thankyou, can't see huge savings whilst still dragging those pistons up and down, but then in the strange world that is vehicle taxation etc a small saving might mean a lower VED or BIK class, which does translate into sales.

Hmm must bear this in mind as i'm sometimes tempted by US gas guzzlers that have this technology and in a mad moment might just go out and buy one, seeing as i'd be LPGing anyway it's another complication probably best avoided unless system easily disabled.

That collapsable valve lifter you describe is working opposite to the valve shutting when a Jacob (superb) brake is operating i would expect.

Edited by gordonbennet on 15/10/2012 at 21:24

VW Golf - HJ VWGolf VII review - SteveLee

Yes I was aware of the GM work in this area. I was just questioning the suggestion that it helps on the overrun as the fuel would be cut anyway when the throttle is closed. Keeping the exhaust valve(s) open when the cylinder is being cut would of course offer the best efficiency gains due to reducing pumping loses, but you'd have to be very careful not to disturb the gas flow for the active cylinders destroying scavenging. Just cutting the spark will reduce plant food production I can't see it saving fuel with a cruising car due to the pumping loses from the deactivated cylinder. Looks like more technology and needless complexity to keep the green fraud going without actually benefiting the driver or the environment.