What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Having had the car now for a few days, this is my first impressions. As my last car was a Scenic, this is the car I am comparing it to which may be the same for any potential buyers.

Got the car, brand new, with a saving of roughly £2500 off list price. The car is standard apart from the addition of the ?integrated? TomTom 510 Sat Nav unit.

Engine
Engine is very good with strong pull right through the gears. As with most diesels it doesn?t do too much in first from standstill but then quickly makes up for lost time. Engine is definitely noisier than the Scenic dci I previously had, especially noticeable whilst idling. Seat have stopped putting ?Noise Suppression Covers? on these models although they can be bought for about £60-£70. I have taken opinion on this and some people say it makes a difference, others say it doesn?t so I will see if the noise becomes intolerable over the next month or so. Too early to give opinions on mpg. Gearbox is very quick change, I always found the Scenic to be very notchy and ?long? but the Seat is the complete opposite.

Cabin
The car is very well laid out with everything needed to hand. The audio is very good with a socket for Aux input. My model has the 3.5mm socket but I believe if ordering from the factory, you can select ipod or USB socket instead. Controls are on the steering wheel which is taking a bit of getting used to as with the Scenic the controls were fixed which meant that you always knew where they were! Speedometer increases in 20mph markings but these are even rather than odd, so the critical limits of 30, 50 and 70 aren?t as obvious to see. Speedometer seems to be a good 10% out in comparison with GPS speed.
Plenty of toys, all round electric windows, cruise control, split zone climate control etc. As I said, mine also has the Tom Tom which also works as Bluetooth handsfree for phone, both phone and navigation instructions come through the car speakers.
The Seat is taking some time to get used to and to get comfortable. It has strong side supports but I find my left hand side resting on the support rather than in it, but I am nowhere near the right hand support. Don?t know if this is due to position of pedals or whatever. The seat is definitely far more supportive and firm than the Scenics was. If you like driving with one arm resting, well the middle glovebox is too low for your arm to rest on and the drivers door doesn?t have a good ?edge? to rest on, the door card slopes from the window.

Versatility
This car is nowhere near as versatile as the Scenic so if you need versatility and storage areas, then this isn?t the car for you. However, if like me, you have had 3 Scenics due to their great versatility and flexibility and then, on looking back, you realise that you very very rarely actually made use of them, then you should consider the Seat. The boot is huge and the Seat backs fold down to give you more space. However they don?t tumble forward or be removed like some MPVs (Scenic). The seats are split 70/30 but does have a middle pull down ?armrest? with integrated cupholders. A point worth noting is that the seats are lower than in the Scenic and for me, this means that where my 9 year old son sat in the Scenic no problem, in the Seat due to the seat being lower then the seatbelt comes down very close to his neck. He could really do with a booster seat even though he is taller than the new regulations. Also, unlike the Scenic, there is the middle hump that runs through the floor making things less comfy for a middle passenger. Storage is limited to 2 pull down flaps under the front seats (not drawers) and the centre armrest which has a split level in it, pens etc on top and then a couple of CDs in the bottom bit. There are no underfloor or underseat cubbies in the back like the Scenic does.
There are 3 auxiliary sockets, as well as the normal ?cigarette lighter? in the front, there is one at rear of centre console for rear passengers to use and one in the boot as well.
The boot is big and has a space saver spare wheel. However it also had a squareish space next to the spare wheel that lies empty. Therefore if you apply any significant weight to the boot carpet then it bevels due to the gap underneath it! I am sure I will find something useful to put in there to prevent this (compressor, jump leads etc). Boot does not have a conventional parcel shelf which rises with the bootlid, instead it has a telescopic cover that pulls out and retracts. I actually prefer this especially if you are carrying something taller than the height of the shelf then it is easier to recline it rather than remove it altogether.

Car itself sits slightly lower than the Scenic.

My first impressions are that I like this very much and prefer it to the Scenic. I think my kids will prefer the Scenic due to its seating positions but their opinion is being ignored! The car has a few strange things that I don?t understand ? it has a locking fuel cap which is attached by a cord to the ?door?. This means than when you unlock it and take it off, it hangs down the side of your bodywork! Why not a release inside the car or in the case of the Scenic, the flap worked through the central locking?
Under the rearview mirror there are 2 red LEDs which shine down onto the centre console, presumably their only function is to create some ambience! At night the inside of the car is very very red. The audio buttons on the steering wheel light up as well but you also have the option to switch them off, why?
Oh, and one gripe I do have, the car only comes with one remote control key, the other is just a normal key. For a car that should be £17.5k, surely you would expect 2 remote control keys? That?s what my Skoda has.

Shortly will be taking it to France and back so will report back in a few weeks how living with the car is.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
BobbyG

Re the filler cap, if its standard VW it has slots in it, that means it slots on top of the filler cap door, and not dangling on your bodywork!
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Ah, that must be on page 599 of the manual - I am still in the 400s......
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
The two red lights are actually called ambience lights. Its a standard part of the electronic dimming mirror from the VW parts bin.

The boot was orginally intended to have a false boot floor, level with the rear folded seats and the rear door lip (you can see the areas for the mounting points in the boot sides) - hence the flimsy boot floor.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
TVM, I believe when car first was released it didn't even have a space saver, just the liquid stuff so that is probably where the split floor came from. However I am told that the Seat dealers managed to persuade Seat to fit a space saver as standard instead.

(The money they had to spend on the wheel was probably saved by not fitting the engine cover!) :)
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - barchettaman
Cracking review, thanks BobbyG.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Avant
Enormously helpful Bobby - thank you very much. This one is on my shortlist, but the noisy engine and inability of the rear seats to fold flat are putting me off.

I have yet to try the Altea 2.0 TDI (which is what I think you have) but I had a good run in a Leon with this engine and DSG which wasn't excessively noisy. DSG also partly alleviates the sudden surge of power that VAG 2.0 TDIs specialise in.

I think I'll wait to see what the Golf estate is like (due out in August). If it's £2,000 more than an Octavia or Altea just for ndamped grab handles it won't be worth it.

That was an impressive discount you got - I presume you didn't PX the Scenic?
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Avant, yeah sorry missed that bit out - I have the 2.0TDI (140) Stylance but without the DSG.
I traded the Scenic in and got what I believe to be a decent price for it so all in all, happy with the deal although I am uncertain what the residuals on this car are going to be like in 3 years time but that is a (potential) problem for the future.
I reckon over the next 2-3 weeks I am going to be putting over 2000 miles on it so will then have a good idea how obtrusive (if at all) I feel the noise is.
Seat backs fold down so if it is planks of wood etc, then would still be able to get them in. Pretty sure I could get my bike in lying it on its side without having to remove any wheels. However if its something big and box like, eg a washing machine type shape then yeah, the lack of "tumbling / removable" seats would be an issue.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - J Bonington Jagworth
Is it just me, or does the back view of the Altea remind anyone else of a 1950's Vanguard? Excellent review, though, with a lot more useful info that one normally gets from glossy mags. "Attached by a cord" sounds much better than 'tied on with string'... :-)
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
Altea? or Altea XL? the two look very different from the rear.

Not its prettiest feature on either it has to be said.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - J Bonington Jagworth
"Altea? or Altea XL? "

Altea. Not sure I've seen an XL yet. Reminded me of this (but only from the rear - I'm not really trying to be rude!)

uk.geocities.com/vanguard49au/
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Mmm struggling to see the similarity with the Vantage!
The Altea only has lights on the rear quarter whereas the Altea XL has lights on the boot as well.
My kids think the rear of my Altea XL look like a big sad frown!!
--
2007 Seat Altea XL 2.0 TDI (140) Stylance
2005 Skoda Fabia vrS
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - tyro
>>Excellent review ... with a lot more useful info that one normally gets from glossy mags. "

I agree. Great review.

>>If you like driving with one arm resting, ... the drivers door doesn?t have a good ?edge? to rest on,

An important point for some of us, and one that is, indeed, usually missing from most reviews. (Mind you, I've just about gotten used to the fact that my Ka's door doesn't have a good edge.)
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - T Lucas
I had one in Spain last summer for 3 weeks and thought it was all pretty good other than the climate really struggled to keep the car cool.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Jonwm {P}
I would agree with the review, I had the "normal" Altea for a few months when my golf was recalled, didn't want the golf back to be honest, I had the sport (140) and found it a joy to drive, would have one again if i could, i dont remember the engine being noisy, but last week i had a leon diesel for the day from dealer and it was so noisy compared to all other diesels i've drove, makes you wonder if they did used to put the sound deadening on the Altea?

Jon
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Well just completed first leg of journey from Glasgow area down to my brothers in Bishops Stortford. Observations on yesterday's drive

Wipers
I love the automatic wipers, they are so much better than the Scenic. The fact that they hide in the pillar and there is a plastic lip at the bonnet side means that you don't have the "creep" of water up the windscreen that you get when wipers are parked at the bottom.
Lights
Again better than the Scenic in that the auto lights come on when heavy rain. This is due to the lights being linked up to the wipers "speed".
TomTom
Had a hold up on M6, think between 16 and 17, dialled up the TomTom traffic and it took me a detour to avoid the accident. Very impressed!
Cruise Control
This is the first time I have had a car with cruise control and really liked it. However I now know why sometimes I see cars blipping their brake lights for no apparent reason - just deactivating the cruise. I also found that this could make me lazy in that I was prepared to overtake another car at 1mph difference slowly, rather than I would normally accelerate past it and complete the manoeuvre quicker.

Fuel consumption on a tank of BP Ultimate was 40.7mpg, with the cruise set at a GPS speed of 76mph.

Kids don't like back seats, so low down compared to Scenic. In fact even though they are taller than the legal guidelines, we might go and buy them booster seats today.

Road noise probably noisier than the Scenic but when you have the music turned up then you don't really notice.

All in, enjoyed my lengthy drive yesterday and although I was expecting my back to be sore it was actually fine so quite pleased with that.
--
2007 Seat Altea XL 2.0 TDI (140) Stylance
2005 Skoda Fabia vrS
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
Cruise on a VW is quite good (when it works - mine isnt at the moment and I cant be bothered to get if fixed AGAIN - FOR THE THIRD TIME)

Brake cuts it out, but unlike some, gas pedal doesent. So what you do is leave the cruise on, gas past for an overtake, foot off and when speed drops to cruise setting she carries on. You can also adjust the speed you are doing in 1mph steps using the cruise buttons, very accurate.

at 70 I approach a 50 or 60 mph limit, push the down cruise button till speedo drops to speed i want and then let it go, and cruise through your speed limit at your chosen speed. I have learned to kick the cruise off with my left foot on the brake without throwing everyone through the windscreen.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Yeah I discovered that as well, quite interesting accelerating using the stalk controls! Don't know if its a good thing or not but as wel as a foot rest at the clutch, there is a foot rest at the accelerator! Makes for very relaxed driving but not strange not having your foot hovering over the pedals!

As an aside, I normally would be doing up to 90-95 driving down to here, being very vigilant for police, scameras etc. Some stretches of the M74 especially you can see for miles.

However yesterday I just set the cruise for 76 and went for it. Much more relaxed I think, plan overtakes much more advanced so that can maintain speed without having to hit any pedals or stalk controls!

Saw quite a few cameras, police on bridges but just kept going whilst everyone else braked. GPS was 76, speedo about 81/82.

Incidentally came off onto the A14, SPECS cameras all along route but also saw a scamera van parked in a layby and further ahead traffic police had pulled someone over as well. Take it they don't like speeding on that road!!!

(And annoyingly TomTom alerts you to every single SPEC camera)
--
2007 Seat Altea XL 2.0 TDI (140) Stylance
2005 Skoda Fabia vrS
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - cheddar
TVM,

IIRC the VAG cars with cruise have a cancel/resume button that avoids unecessary showing of the brake lights altea-ernatively (geddit!) the clutch pedal also cancels the cruise.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
> the clutch pedal also cancels the cruise

na it dont, depress the clutch and the revs rise to the point where the cruise gets all flustered and goes into error reset mode and you loose your last set speed.

I prefer the brake, the cancel button is awkwardly placed on top of the cruise stalk, where by a quck brake dab (so light the brakes dont actually do anything) kicks it off and you still have your last resume speed.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
>placed on top

doh - UNDER the the lever. The on off switch is on top, another poorly designed (ergonomically) switch.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - daveyjp
The problems you encounter with ergonomics of the switch are exactly what I encountered. I only drove the Touran for three days out of 7 on holiday and thought if I owned one I'd get used to it. Your long term experience shows this may not be the case.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - cheddar
> the clutch pedal also cancels the cruise
na it dont depress the clutch and the revs rise to the point ...>>



Strange, does on a Ford.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
Strange does on a Ford.


Indeed, and most other cars, I was suprised it didnt on the Ran.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - cheddar
Indeed and most other cars I was suprised it didnt on the Ran.


I had a Bora V5 for a short while in around late 2000, IIRC that worked in the same way, i.e. the clutch cancelled the cruise.

Nothing worse than the cruise on a 607 2.2 I drove about 4 years ago, so jerky, awful!
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
TVM, just finished reading the manual, according to it, the cruise control is cancelled by dipping the clutch! Will give it a try tomorrow on the way to Dover!

Incidentally looked under the bonnet and it looks like it will be very easy and straight forward to change the headlight bulbs. Thats a big bonus in my book compared to the Scenic's knuckle scraping efforts!
--
2007 Seat Altea XL 2.0 TDI (140) Stylance
2005 Skoda Fabia vrS
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - cheddar
TVM just finished reading the manual according to it the cruise control is cancelled by
dipping the clutch! >>



As per Ford et al and as I thought.

If TVM's does not do this it may be a contributory factor in the recurring cruise fault.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
Hold on Hold on, back in your Rind cheesy.

1stly he has an Altea, I have a touran.
2ndly "in the manual" does not mean "in practise"


However, I have to admit that the likleyhood of the fault on the touran is pretty high.

------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - charlesb
Little Tip reqgarding the VW Cruise Control. Instead of blipping the Brake pedal, I found that pushing the on/off switch lightly disengages the cruise control, then the resume remembers your last speed.

Handy. You can drive without using either pedal once set!
-------------------
VW Bora (51) 2.0 SE
VW Touran (54) 1.9 TDI
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - daveyjp
Having recently driven a Touran with cruise controls incorporated into the indicator stalk I prefer the Audi system of a seperate stalk below the indicator. Pull towards you activate, push away to cancel.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Brian Tryzers
I prefer the Volvo system of buttons on the steering wheel to anything on a stalk. A master on-off switch, up and down buttons to set or alter the speed, Suspend and Resume buttons to, erm, suspend or resume. All within view, easily worked with the left thumb, and certainly no reason to touch the brake pedal.

I read somewhere that the Vectra has a stalk-operated CC that, once activated, can be suspended but not switched off. So you're only ever a nudge of Resume away from unintended acceleration under control of the car, not the driver.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - yeoman
I prefer resting my foot on the accelerator peddle and I find subtle movements up or down change my cruising speed very accurately.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Nomag
Our octy mk II and leon mk II cruise controls are as in the altea, and although used to them now, I much preferred the old style control on the indicator in my mk I toledo. I always use the 'temporary' cancel to deactivate, and on the old stalk the switch for this was on the face of the stalk, whereas it is now on the upper edge, which seems much less ergonomic, and it is much easier to accidentally switch it all the way to off, necessitating a reset of the set speed. I detest using the brake to cancel the cruise, as however careful I am I always feel a slight jerk, I suppose that's because the car is on the throttle as you apply the brake, something you would never normally do. And of course the irritation of the brake lights flashing on to other drivers.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Avant
"Is it just me, or does the back view of the Altea remind anyone else of a 1950's Vanguard?"

I know what you mean - it's the 'beetle back'. It reminds me more of a Chrysler PT Cruiser. The Altea XL, like Bobby's, is better as the rear lights are extended into the hatchback to alleviate the blank space.

Even now, given the choice, I'd rather have a 1950 Standard Vanguard than a PT Cruiser! The Vanguard was a good car whose engine could last for ages. Our school doctor had one, and his arrival in it one day led to the headmaster giving us a fascinating Latin lesson about Roman battle formation (the fact that that could be fascinating shows what a fine teacher he was).
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
Just to put my "reporting" to bed, my final thoughts on the car having now taken it to France and back from Glasgow, and with the mileometer now reading 2300 miles.

Very impressed by wipers and the auto headlight link to them

Not impressed with the headlights in that there is no warning light for sidelights, headlights or front fog lights on the dash which I find totally unbelieveable! The only warning light there seems to be is the rear fogs. I checked this time and time again and definitely no lights. Must check the manual in case there should be!

With lights set to Auto, you only know that headlights have came on if

A, it is dark enough to notice the red glow in the instrument cluster

B, apparently the ?auto? light on the light switch changes from red to white or vice versa! But definitely not noticeable!

Kids definitely prefer the high up Scenic seats and flat floor to the low down Altea with hump in middle of floor., I picked up a booster seat for my 9 year old for a fiver in Argos which he appreciated.

I am not totally convinced by the boot, OK I had the rear seats pushed back as much as possible but I don?t think I got any more bags in the boot than I did with the Scenic although I may be wrong as it is 2 years since we last went a driving holiday.

I miss the option of folding flat the front passenger seat, used to do this regularly on Scenic so that kids could see better and even put feet up on seat (them not me!)

Fuel consumption over the whole trip was 39.5, quite disappointing since I never went above 80 for the whole time and did a lot at much less. However I fully appreciate that the engine isn?t run in yet etc etc.

Anyway, car has now had a full 6 hour valet, inside and out and is now looking gleaming again. An upside of the poor weather and torrential rain was that there was very few beasties on the front of car!

Re previous comment on cruise control, a quick flick of the on/off switch is enough to release the cruise without having to touch any of the pedals.

If filling the car, make sure you check the tyre pressures and reset the sensor switch, the difference between normal and fully laden pressures are 35/32 to 36/41 on mine!

TomTom worked well, was quite eerie seeing it track my progress through the Dartford Tunnel with no signal! I had taken advantage of the free month?s subscription to TT Traffic so twice it told me about delays and re routed me (coincidentally both times on M6 at Holmes Chapel!

In the Scenic if you pressed the ?lock? button at the electric window switches, not only did it prevent the rear windows from being operated but also locked the rear doors. However with the Altea, unless you actually activate the child lock inside the appropriate door, the kids can open the door whilst driving. Unless this is something that can be programmed with the key, there is something in the manual about that.

Regarding the manual, I suppose it is the same with all cars, it covers lots of features ?dependent on model?. But doesn?t tell you whether yours has got this! I have the Stylance which is the top spec, but there are loads of features covered which I don?t have.

Finally a small point about the Scenic I miss is the handsfree keycard! Didn't realise I had got so used to it. I am constantly getting out the car and having to go back in and retrieve the key from the ignition!

--
2007 Seat Altea XL 2.0 TDI (140) Stylance
2005 Skoda Fabia vrS
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - daveyjp
Not impressed with the headlights in that there is no warning light for sidelights headlights
or front fog lights on the dash which I find totally unbelieveable! The only warning
light there seems to be is the rear fogs. I checked this time and time
again and definitely no lights. Must check the manual in case there should be!


Audis are the same - only warning light is by the switch - useless.
Regarding the manual I suppose it is the same with all cars it covers lots
of features ?dependent on model?. But doesn?t tell you whether yours has got this! I
have the Stylance which is the top spec but there are loads of features covered
which I don?t have.


Manuals are written for all markets and simply translated. Manufacturers offer loads of options so having a tailormade handbook wouldn't be practical.

My Audi handbook has loads of information about cabin preheaters, various warning lights for options which aren't available in the UK, spec for the 1.4TFSi engine which is not a UK option etc etc. You have to sit in the car with the manual and see which goodies you have.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
Not impressed with the headlights in that there is no warning light for sidelights


Just checked the Touan, it has no warning light. I missed it so much it wasnt till it was pointed out that I noticed it.

Why do you need one?
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - cheddar
Why do you need one?

>>

Well you can get nicked for having front fogs on inappropriately.
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - Altea Ego
It has a front fogs warning light. It also has a rear fogs warning light. But why do you need a "your side lights are on" or "your headlights are on" warning.
------------------------------
TourVanMan TM < Ex RF >
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - cheddar
BobbyG says "there is no warning light for sidelights, headlights or front fog lights on the dash"
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - BobbyG
TVM, that is correct - the only lights warning light is rear fogs. When I am driving in dark it is obvious if my lights are on. If I am driving in heavy rain it is less obvious whether my headlights are on or off.

I would hate to be driving along in the heavy rain, cursing everyone who was driving without lights on , not realising that mine had switched themselves off!

Coming back up the M6 recently I ended up just switching my lights on manually (I know, shocking!), just so that I knew they would stay on until I had decided otherwise!


--
2007 Seat Altea XL 2.0 TDI (140) Stylance
2005 Skoda Fabia vrS
Seat Altea XL - first impressions - daveyjp
Bobby G - same here re reason for a dash warning - those times when you aren't sure if auto lights have worked. Audi do fit a lights on indicator, but its small and located next to the switch (as is the 'fog lights on' light), so you can't see it without moving your head (the steering wheel gets in the way) and looking at the switch.

At times when the requirement for lighting is marginal it's often not dark enough in the cabin to see if the dial illumination is on or not. I tend to have this set on fairly low because when it's dark if it's on high it's too bright.