What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Roundabouts - Roger Jones
Car 1 approaches roundabout and begins to enter. Car 2 enters roundabout rapidly from opposite direction at a speed and in a position that imply going straight on, but without signalling turns right across the path of car 1. Minor collision avoided. Give way to traffic on roundabouts, yes, but would the absence of a signal spread the blame had there been an independently witnessed collision?
Roundabouts - robZilla
I believe the wording of the Highway Code is along the lines of "give way to traffic already on the roundabout" AOT "give way to traffic on your right". As car 1 was "already on the roundabout", car 2 should give way, right?
Roundabouts - Cliff Pope
I think in the apparent circumstances described, Robzilla is right. If car 1 was on the roundabout already, car 2 doesn't have the right to zoom straight round and drive into it, even though approaching "from the right".
But a trickier situation is when car 1 is only considering whether to enter the roundabout, but is aware of car 2 approaching at speed but is not yet at the roundabout. Some people approach roundabouts so fast that they seem to assume that everything will clear out of their way, "giving way to the right". On a busy roundabout the choice is often to enter, taking a chance of being rammed, or wait for ever.
Roundabouts - Mad Maxy
It's up to drivers to judge other vehicles' speed and to position or manoeuvre accordingly.

However, no-one has the right to go opposite-locking round a roundabout at speed just because they can. It's unreasonable to expect other road users to judge correctly the intentions of vehicles going at an unsafe speed.

That said, if I see a car acting potentially dangerously I make sure I'm well out of its way, even if that means waiting till it has passed.
Roundabouts - Dwight Van Driver
On the face of it from brief facts appears 50/50 blame.
As stated an independant witness who could give detailed positions in relation to each other could shift the blame one way or the other.

DVD
Roundabouts - Cardew
Roger has not said the Car 2 was going at an excessive or unsafe speed, just rapidly and at a speed and in a position that imply going straight on.

It seems to me that Car 1 has wrongly assumed that Car 2 was going straight on. Based on that wrong assumption Car 1 started to pull out onto the roundabout and into the path of Car 2.
Roundabouts - Garethj
Give way to traffic on the roundabout is true, but it's not the whole truth is it? If you're joining a good size roundabout and you think you can get on and pull away without making the other car change speed or direction you do it. If you didn't no-one would ever get anywhere. Picture yourself sitting there, cars are approaching but you can easily get out so you do.

Seems like the faster car thought he could get on the roundabout before the slow car got to his exit so did it.

Also, indicators are just that - an indicator. Otherwise they'd be called "Definates".

Blame is probably 50-50, as stated above you're better to be safe and away from the idiots than have an accident and hope for it to be the other guys fault.

Gareth
Roundabouts - patently
Also, indicators are just that - an indicator. Otherwise they'd be called "Definates".


Thank you, Garethj, I shall remember that one!
Roundabouts - Garethj
Told to me by a traffic policeman, I remembered it too !

Gareth
Roundabouts - matt35 {P}
Gareth,

"Told to me by a traffic policeman, I remembered it too !"

Ditto, but,

"The only thing an indicator tells you is that the bulb is working".

Matt35
Roundabouts - patently
"The only thing an indicator tells you is that the bulb
is working".


No it isn't ... oh yes it is ... no, it isn't, ... oh...
Roundabouts - HF
"The only thing an indicator tells you is that the bulb
is working".


>>No it isn't ... oh yes it is ... no, it isn't, ... oh...

Even so, it *would* be nice if people were to use them. I know we cannot rely on whether another driver is indicating properly, but my pet hate is people who are above using them on, in particular, mini-roundabouts. The hold-ups on these are frequently caused by the selfish drivers who just canot be bothered to indicate their intention.

Roundabouts - Mapmaker
Only one thing worse than people not using them, is people using them when they don't know how to use them.

Approach roundabout at 6 o'clock. Turning right, to leave at 3 o'clock. Switch on right hand indicator.

Go round 270 degrees, and turn off left, with right hand indicator blaring away. Particularly unpleasant if you're a cyclist trying to cross the junction.

Certainly not 'definites' (I like that!), but not even indicators. Just 'bearers of confusion'.

Roundabouts - AR-CoolC
Or the one where entering at 6 o'clock to go straight on, in the right hand lane indicate right and go straight over turning on the left indicator as they leave the roundabout.

AAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!
(Glass-Tech)
Roundabouts - No Do$h
Funnily enough I was taught to do that one by my driving instructor. Has taken years to get out of the habit.

Silly me, should have just bought a beemer, would have lost the habit of indicating in a flash (pardon the pun).
Roundabouts - Mapmaker
Sometimes makes sense on a big roundabout to do that. A car that's not indicating at all you wonder what on earth it might be about to do...
Roundabouts - David Horn
Actually, the thing that annoys me most on roundabouts (medium sized two lane ones) are people that use the wrong lane. (eg using the right hand lane when they're going straight on.)

I've always been taught that it's correct to use the left hand lane for turning left and going straight on, and the right hand lane for turning right and going full circle.
Roundabouts - No Do$h
It's a shame that various highway authorities can't agree on that. How many of us have reached an unfamiliar roundabout in what the Highway Code says is the right lane, then found that the road markings 20yds from the entrance tell you otherwise.
Roundabouts - Garethj
Actually, the thing that annoys me most on roundabouts (medium sized two lane ones) are people that use the wrong lane. (eg using the right hand lane when they're going straight on.)
I've always been taught that it's correct to use the left
hand lane for turning left and going straight on, and the
right hand lane for turning right and going full circle.

It's permissable in the highway code to use the right hand lane for going straight on.

Gareth
Roundabouts - Mapmaker
There even used to be a picture on the front cover illustrating this, iirc.
Roundabouts - Cliff Pope
>>
It's permissable in the highway code to use the right hand
lane for going straight on.



That's what I've always assumed. I knew I must have read it somewhere.

But the question then often arises, who has priority when such a driver wants to cut across and exit? Does a car in the innermost lane always have priority by virtue of being always on everyone else's right?
Roundabouts - BazzaBear {P}
In that situation I would have thought the car in the outside (left) lane had right of way, since the car in the right hand lane would have to cut across the left lane in order to exit the roundabout.
Roundabouts - Malcolm_L
Agreed, whenever I've seen two lane roundabouts which have
single lane exits there's normally an arrow on the exit
indicating that cars in the right hand lane should move into
the left hand lane.
To me this implies that they should give way to the left hand
lane, so summing up you should give way to the right when entering and on the roundabout but not when coming off - AAAARGH!
Roundabouts - patently
Over the years, I've developed the distinct impression that on leaving a roundabout, the one going fastest and sounding the horn has right of way.
Roundabouts - No Do$h
Unless traffic is queuing, in which case priority goes to the one prepared to edge their wing across the front of the other driver.
Roundabouts - BazzaBear {P}
I'm sensing some cynicism developing in this thread....
Roundabouts - matt35 {P}
At a few of our local roundabouts, they have marked the inside lane to be 'Exit Left' or in the case of there being no left, staight ahead only.
Traffic leaving the roundabout has separation hatchings keeping it to what is the outside lane for about a hundred yards...good idea in principle - provided drivers notice the paint on the road.
For the first few weeks it was safer in Iraq!

Matt.
Roundabouts - kithmo
Actually, the thing that annoys me most on roundabouts (medium sized
two lane ones) are people that use the wrong lane.
(eg using the right hand lane when they're going straight on.)
I've always been taught that it's correct to use the left
hand lane for turning left and going straight on, and the
right hand lane for turning right and going full circle.

I think you'll find you've been taught wrong david. You can go straight on from either lane, unless otherwise marked on the road, when there are two lanes. The ones that annoy me are those that are in the left hand lane and are turning right.
Roundabouts - Chuffer Dandridge
I agree the h/way code does say you can use the RH lane to go straight on. But am I alone in finding it dangerous and antisocial when people use this as a means of overtaking, especially when they cause vehicles in the LH lane who are legitimately going straight on to have to take avoiding action.
Roundabouts - Dynamic Dave
I agree the h/way code does say you can use the
RH lane to go straight on. But am I alone in
finding it dangerous and antisocial when people use this as a
means of overtaking....


Hmmm, I think we've been here before:-

www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=16697
Roundabouts - David Horn
I don't think you can beat the technique everyone in Devon uses:

1) Coming up to roundabout, aim your car so you're driving over the middle of the white lines separating lanes, and on a course that will take you approximately straight through the roundabout.
2) Assume no one is coming.
3) Close eyes.
4) Floor it.
5) Rely on the edge of the pavement to guide your wheels in the right direction.

Never fails. ;) If you see another car on the roundabout, continue as normal while sounding horn and shaking fist. After all, it's YOUR roundabout...