What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - mfarrow
Hi

I'm currently investigating the use of Biodiesel as an alternative to the ~40 years or so of fossil fuels we've got left; and it's potential, and would like the BR's comments on the subject.

For starters, what do people hear think of diesels in general? would using a 'green' diesel change their perception of it? Would they consider buying a diesel car in future if the fuel was greener and/or cheaper?

I would like as many comments as possible as it would be great research.

Thanks for your time. :-)




Mike Farrow
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - No Do$h
There have been a number of threads on the subject of Biodiesel. I you use the Forum Search (top right) instead of the whole site search (top) and enter "Biodiesel" in the subject field you will find loads of comment.

FWIW, I run a diesel and would love to use biodiesel but there are no stockists anywhere near me in Dorset. I'm not confident that making my own would be the best thing for my car.....


No Dosh
mailto:Alan_moderator@honestjohn.co.uk
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
My biodiesel supplier here in NI originally became interested after he had carried out a piece of research into the viability of electric vehicles as an alternative to transport powered by fossil fuels. His conclusion led him away from electric vehicles to biodiesel. He subsequently set up his own biodiesel production facility and has been operational for about 3 years. You can read his paper here:
www.dewinne.freeserve.co.uk/electric.htm
as well as some direct comparisons of various fuel types here:
www.biofuels.fsnet.co.uk/sustain.htm

For what it's worth, I changed from using petrol to diesel engines just over two years ago. It's unlikely that I'll ever switch away from using diesel-powered cars. Even if I weren't interested in biodiesel, for me diesel beats petrol for daily use - better fuel economy, more robust and durable engines, quieter cruising, better use of power. But that's a different debate which has been explored many times on this site and others.

andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - far0n
As it stands biodiesel is dead in the water. It will never be used in any kind of widespread capacity simply because the area of crop land required to fuel all the vehicles in London would have to be the size of Wales !

I worked as a scientist on biodiesel looking at purification and production a few years back. It's really only going to have relatively minor applications.

Considering the recent developments in fuel cell technology and hybrid petrol/electric engines, I can't see biodiesel being used for that much longer. Maybe 20-30 years maximum.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
Not dead in the water at all. In the 20-30 years it will take to develop appropriate (ie low cost, energy-efficient) fuel cell technology, I'd rather see biodiesel used to replace 15% of our current fossil fuel usage, rather than the <0.1% it currently stands at. Plus you've talked about the size of crop land required to produce the fuel - you don't seem to be considering the conversion of waste cooking oil from a toxic pollutant to a renewable fuel which is cleaner than what we currently use. Additionally, there are tremendous areas of set-aside land across the EU which could be turned over from being non-productive to producing a fuel crop - can't be any more expensive than paying farmers to produce nothing.

No-one maintains that biodiesel is the magic solution to all current and future energy problems, but today (not 20-30 years from now) with current levels of technology (ie the diesel-engined vehicles we now use and have been using for years) and without bringing in major infrastructure changes (such as LPG dispensing equipment), we can reduce the amount of finite fossil fuels we are consuming and have cleaner air to boot. Just because it's part of the solution rather than the entire solution, does this mean that the resource should not be utilised? I'm not sure what you mean by "minor applications".

I'd be interested to know where you worked as a scientist on biodiesel and in what context (eg academic, industry, government), as well as about any publications arising out of your research. I'd also be interested in reading about your conclusions, and the basis on which those conclusions were reached. The methods and technology for producing biodiesel from new and used oil have been out there for years and are freely available on the web. I hope this doesn't sound abrupt - it isn't meant to be - but sweeping statements like you have made should be backed up and reasoned.
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Soupytwist

I am keen to use biodiesel in my cars, for the same reasons as many others, articulated well by andymc below and elsewhere. The problem I encounter is that where I live (in Essex) there does not seem to be a local supplier.

I visit Norfolk occasionally and when I do buy fuel from Broadland Fuels garage in Diss (it's only a 5% blend of biodiesel). However last Saturday I was able to buy 7 litres of biodiesel made from recycled vegetable oil in plastic containers. I have not been able to put it in my tank yet as I filled up with some of the blend. When I have used this up I will put the 7 litres in and see how I get on. I have a Skoda Octavia with the 110 bhp VW diesel engine. I don't anticipate any problems. If only I could find an accessible source that I could use without paying a huge premium (ordering biodiesel from Broadland via mail order carries an unaccetably high premium sadly).


If I were to win the lottery I think I'd use some of the money to set up a little biodiesel business. Better buy myself a ticket then.
Matthew Kelly
No, not that one.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Sooty Tailpipes
I'd like to see vegatble fuel added to diesel to start with, as is done in France. There are many new crops being discovered around the world, which yield much higher oil than rape, let's just hope they can be used in their natural state and not genetically modified. There are many places where the crops can be grown, they would be a very handy cash crop for vast expanse of the third world.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Graham
I'm sure if veggie diesel had as much money spent on it as the oil industry does, a lot of the perceived problems would be iron out quickly.

Mmmm donuts....Love that smell.



Allegedly.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - teabelly
But would the heady aroma of chip pans and doughnuts coming from vehicles start to encourage the population to eat more chips and fried foods so there is a good supply of vegetable oil? Gives a whole new meaning for eating for two (me & the motor)! :-)
teabelly
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - mfarrow
Wow! didn't realise how this had attracted 8 replies! Thanks for the help guys, got it handed in now. Fingers crossed!

Mike Farrow
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Soupytwist

Quick update on the above - put 7 litres of the Broadland Fuels biodiesel in the practically empty tank last night and drove to work this morning. Car runs entirely as expected, no problems whatsoever. Maybe a little smoother, maybe a little quieter but not a scientific test.

Increased sense of wellbeing on the part of the driver who is pleased that he can manage to get to work (and back hopefully) by using a product genuinely recycled from waste material.

You can tell it's made from recycled vegetable oil, because it smells like it !

If only I could buy it locally.


Matthew Kelly
No, not that one.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
First and foremost as an old Mid-East hand I question that "40 years or so" -- sounds a bit like the alarmist greeny eco-brigade. Central Asia has yet to be fully probed for its reserves and we still have Iraq's.

What does interest me is the potential for self-renewing resources in Asia: the Philippines for example like itys neighbours produces enormous amounts of sugar cane and coconuts and while some of the by-product finds its way into bio-fuels the oil companies are not apparently that interested in doing much about it -- hardly surprising since our national oil company is 40% owned by Aramco of Saudi Arabia.

To get to your question: my guess is most people would accept whatever was cheapest without much thought as to it's "greenness". Unless governments gave bio-fuels tax breaks Joe Six-Pack is probably not too worried what goes in his tank.



Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Malcolm_L
Thankfully already happening.

I was in Northern Ireland last week (which appears to be more bio-diesel friendly than the mainland) 69p a litre for bio-diesel.

If I could get bio-diesel anywhere around South Herts/N.London/Essex borders I would but I haven't seen any garages selling it (especially at this price).

The amount of fast-food restaurants which use deep fat fryers should keep bio-diesel supplies going for a considerable time, although I believe incincerator plants do use the oil as well.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - malteser
Growler you are spot on as far as I am concerned. Although not a 6 pack, more of a Rioja fan ;) price is the absolute over-riding factor in fuel purchase, subject to the stuff not being poor quality and /or damaging to my car.
I couldn't give a fig for environmental issues. I will be long gone before any "greenie" issues arise, if they ever do and frankly my descendents can look after themselves!
Roger.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Jazzmag
SNIP

It\'s so much easier to delete than edit.

Remember that next time you try and swear. DD


Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Jazzmag
Sorry Mr. Moderator. I didn't realise that us petrol headed, beer drinking chaps would find my edited w*rd so offensive! Come on, do you honestly think they've never actually said the word themselves? To totally block an e-mail because it contained a self edited word is just a little 'nanny state-ish'....

Anyway, I respect the spirit in which the site is run and understand your need to prevent profanity so I live and learn - 'Certificate U' rated posts only!!
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
Coincidentally after making this post I came across the ff in the local rag:

www.philstar.com/philstar/NEWS_FLASH0218200415_8.h...m

I can just only guess at the competition from the old-money planter cronies with their vast coconut estates to get in on that little act......... ;+)
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Sooty Tailpipes
One of the most marvellous things about biofuel is that it offsets the emissions associated with fossil fuel use....I'll be the first to say most environmentallism is politically motivated claptrap, but the cycle to produce and burn a litre of biofuel offsets the emsissions of 2.5 litres of fossil fuel....In fact a Canadian woman raised this at a Kyoto treaty meeting and was told that this solution would not achieve the social engineering benefits that the Kyoto treaty was really about....What a scam. If the government added a proportion of processed vegetable oil to diesel, (as in France but on a much larger scale) it would be like reducing fossil fuel use by a significant percentage..
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
Ultimately it's all a great big yawn....
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
"What does interest me is the potential for self-renewing resources in Asia"
Plenty of potential for biodiesel from palm-oil as well out your way Growler. One of the reasons I like the idea of all this is that no matter what part of the world you look at, people can make their own fuel - two fingers to the oil conglomerates, most people are just trying to get along. Appeals to my self-sufficiency, do it for yourself ideals. The homebrew is going down nicely ...
If you want, I can do a bit of digging & see if there's anything happening in your neck of the woods so you can have a look at it if you're around. I seem to remember someone from the Phillippines doing a pilot project a year or two ago. Then again, could just have easily been Indonesia! Gawd, I suddenly feel like one of those tourists that ask "Dublin, that's near France right?"
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - dieselhead

If you do a "well to wheel" energy study of rapeseed oil you find the benefits are not so great. Taking into acount the extra fuel used for transportation, cultivation, fertilisers etc. you find that this is about a quarter of that contained in rapeseed oil. The situation for irrigated crops in warmer climates is far worse looking at the figures I have. Then remember yet more energy is required for conversion into bio-diesel...

Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
I'm afraid nothing that could remotely be called a project is happening where I live right now. It's all about elections in 2 months.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
dieselhead
Youn mention a few "not so great" benefits - all the same "well-to-wheel" factors apply to fossil fuels as well, only without the mitigating effects of biodiesel.

A direct quote from one of the sites I posted before states: "In round figures, one hectare of land (UK) should produce an average 3 tonnes of rapeseed at 40% oil content. Pressed at a 90% extraction rate, this gives 1100kg of oil, which is treated with 150 kg of alcohol to give in excess of one tonne (1100 litres) of biodiesel and 120 kg of the valuable by-product glycerol. It requires around 15% energy input to produce the biodiesel - almost exactly the same as for petrodiesel extraction and refining ... Biodiesel is rated (DETR figure) at almost 12kWh per litre (only 7.5% below that of fossil diesel), giving a yield of 13MW per hectare per annum ... Added to this, the 2 tonnes of oil-bearing meal produced contains an estimated 4kWh of energy per kg, resulting in an energy yield of a further 8MW per hectare."

That was only in relation to biodiesel produced from new oil grown as a fuel crop - it doesn't even include used oil that is already being produced, and otherwise ends up as either a toxic waste product or as a means of passing on BSE in cattle feed. I'd rather use it as fuel than either of those alternatives!

I'm not suggesting that biodiesel is a perfect fuel, nor an all-encompassing solution to all our fuel/energy/air quality issues. I am suggesting that it is one of the most viable and readily applicable alternatives available today. Ideally we could all drive round in super-fast, super-affordable and super-efficient hydrogen or solar powered cars. We can't, not today and not for years to come. We can use biofuels, which are cleaner and in real terms cheaper than fossil-based road fuels, right now.

Growler - I'd suggest trying to make your own bio-ethanol for fuelling the new wheels, but I somehow suspect that like me, you'd end up drinking it rather than putting it in the car ...
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
LOL Andy, I do have a few coconuts on the trees in my backyard, been wondering what to do with them, they're always falling on people and things anyway.

But then I remember the local Tanduay Rum sells for 48p for a litre bottle, maybe I should be putting that in my tank. Made from sugar=renewable resources, right? My (so rare to the point of being invisible to the naked eye) twinge of non-greenness guilt can be assuaged at last! Anyone know how to convert 90 proof to octane figures?
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
90 proof? Nowhere near strong enough! Our local "brew" tends to be around 200% proof. Yours is probably sweeter though. A favourite trick over here, especially on cold winter nights, is get boiled sweets called brandyballs, melt and mix the whole lot together and drink piping hot. You do have to be prepared to redecorate the ceiling though, for when the top of your head blows off. Naturally, this is wrong and should not be done by anyone.

In seriousness, 90 proof would have too high a water content (been saying it for years, but no-one seems to listen) for burning as fuel without harming the engine. I think that it's been fairly common to run cars on a mix of bio-ethanol and petrol in Brazil - maybe Mark could tell us if he's come across it. If I have time I'll do some more digging to find out, but I'm on my way over to York today to be a godfather on Sunday, so it might be next week.
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
You wouldn't be talking about Sid My Friend by any chance?

What a shame, I'll just have to keep drinking the stuff! But hey, that creates jobs right? That's PC isn't it?

But seriously I wish the local lads would do something with all that palm oil my country of exile produces other than fry my chips in it, tastes awful.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
Sid My Friend? Nope, no idea who/what that is. Straight over my head I'm afraid!

I read somewhere about how either veggie oil or biodiesel was extensively used in S. Africa - during the war years? in times of extreme fuel shortage anyway - unfortunately my memory is pretty hazy (I wonder why that is) and I can never remember where I picked up these particular nuggets of information.
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Sooty Tailpipes
I think the use of biodiesel in Brazil is very high too, a large percentage of all diesel in fact....

Don't forget, that the fossil fuel industry, some governments and others are poo-pooing biofuels when it suits them too, they fund research by universities and laborotories to portray it as unrealistic.....The simple truth is, there's not the complexity and infrastructure-investement required to move towards biofuels, that they require with say hydrogen fuel cells. continual obsolescence is what props up what's left of the 'industrial revolution'..
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - THe Growler
Sorry Andymc meant Siddiqui (Sid for short) which is Arabic for "my friend" and which is the staple bootleg grog for expats in (supposedly dry) Saudi. Somehow thought your post might reference this, given your allusion.

Perhaps one day in the future there will be a role for all this veggie stuff but I hear there's just been yet more reserves of oil discovered in Iran so not any time soon....


Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
Nope, just the meeting of my two interests in alternative fuels and booze! Nice tidbit though, I'll remember that one.

More reserves in Iran, eh? That'll make a pleasant change from all those nasty unstable places that are hostile to the oil-thirsty West - you know - the ones where oil is usually found ...

Slightly TIC perhaps, but the point being that we would have less cause for international conflict and hostility if we exploited our own potential for fuel production more fully. It's part of what I alluded to when I mentioned the cost of fuel in real terms - how many platoons are needed to ensure the uninterrupted supply of waste cooking oil from school canteen to local processing plant? NB Comments about the youth of today are inadmissible!

On another point, anyone been keeping an eye on price trends of crude over the last 5 years or so?
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Sooty Tailpipes
I just filled up with my first commercially available biofuel at a normal roadside forecourt - Rix Petroleum near Horncastle, it was called Bioblend 5, so maybe it only contained 5% BIODIESEL, I have searched the web, but can fin no ratios for bioblend.

Maybe I'm romanticising a bit, but I'd much rather my money went to small family businesses and British or European farmer's families, than giant global oil corporations.
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - andymc {P}
Sooty, it's fairly common to indicate the proportion of a biodiesel blend as a B followed by a number. So what you have used is called B5 - in other words, 5% biodiesel mixed with 95% derv, or ULSD. The most common ratios seem to be B5, B20, B95 and B100 (the pure drop!), although I have also come across B80 and B90.
andymc
Biodiesel for the 21st Century - Jwm
Sooty all you need to know here:

www.rixbiodiesel.co.uk/