For spark plug hole thread repair.
Since it’ll contaminate the surface and block alternatives, worth confirming its temperature resistance before application, if possible.
I used ring-pull tabs from Budweiser beer cans (“the King of Beers” yeh, right) as standard test pieces, which seemed somehow appropriate for testing “All American” JB Weld.
F7712563-5DFD-4C8F-8F7F-1C983C90D95F1920×2560 497 KB
0A0CD47E-9035-48DD-86B1-1CF41DE98311 (1)1920×2560 352 KB
They have an unpainted aluminium side (which was the gluing surface) and a black painted side, (which I used for IR thermometer upper surface readings, likely to be considerably lower than the temperature in the join).
Two tabs were glued face-to-face, and after curing for 48 hours (24 for rubber and superglue tests) the join was put under shear stress with a weight pulling the tabs apart, and heat was applied with 2 soldering irons (a 60W and a 40W) in contact with the underside of the tabs.
8E7DE145-C638-42BB-B25C-7FC9E15BA3661920×2560 479 KB
411C43ED-BE26-4AE8-9B5F-7422DF2487711920×2560 324 KB
A naked flame (from a candle or cigarette lighter) was found to blow around and give erratic temperature readings so was not used in the tests
The tabs are not perfect for the job, since the edges are crimped over and there is a slight dimple on the surface. For these tests I hammered them flat, washed them with boiling water and detergent and then brake cleaner, rubbed them on a brick, then with a stainless steel wire brush.
This probably introduces uncontrolled variation. If I was doing it again, (not planned) I would skip the hammering and brick rubbing steps
Results
Nan Pao Impact adhesive
Joints all fail immediately or in less than 30 seconds after coming under load.
Superglue Cyanoacrilate Failure Time/Max Observed Surface Temperature
1: 3 mins 18 secs at 39C 2 : 2 mins 56 secs at 33C 3: 3 mins 20 secs at 35C
JB Weld
- No fail in 15 mins/51.9C
- No fail in 15 mins/45.7C
- No fail in 15 mins/53.2C
In my hands these (cheapo hardware store) soldering irons give insufficient heat for reliable soldering, so I repeated the tests with a 100W (cheapo hardware store) soldering iron which was easier to arrange (and probably also gave more consistent, though not necessarily greater, heating).
For this series I also measured the temperature of the exposed part of the iron, which reached a maximum of around 150 to 170C.
JB Weld test pieces used previously (and therefore high temp cured) were compared with Bondite epoxy,
No failures in any samples during a maximum of 40 minutes heating.
Superior heat resistance of JB Weld over Bondite is thus uncomfirmed ATPIT, (would require higher temperatures) but Bondite is a “fast” epoxy (4 mins) so gives insufficient working time and is probably weaker. This seems to be the norm for readily available epoxies.
I would need to figure out greater (but controlled) heating for testing to destruction. GF has an inductive hot plate that might do, but she would probably miss it.
|