What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

Hi, not hugely knowledgeable about cars but looking to soon buy a new family SUV and hoping for some advice... My situation is that I've just paid off our Toyota CH-R which is a 19 plate and should have decent trade in value. Looking to switch it for similar but slightly bigger & better equipped car - something like a Q5, X3, Toureg, XC40 etc. I'd like to do what we did with the CH-R, which was to buy it 'nearly new' (up to a year and a half old sounds about right) and pay the bulk of it off up front. Given how similar the cars I'm interested in are, I'd love any advice on where people feel the best value would be found currently? Specifically, I'm wondering if any of these models are slightly less fashionable and thus depreciate a little quicker (giving me more value at point of purchase - it'll probably be our family car for a good few years). Other than that, any opinions or advice on purchasing most appreciated! As soon as you walk into a showroom and mention that you're not interested in PCP, you can visibly see a switch turn off in the salespeople's eyes - the ones at Audi and VW couldn't have been more disinterested! Thank you.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Adampr

I'd be looking at Seat (Tarraco), Skoda (Kodiaq), Hyundai (Santa Fe) and Kia (Sorrento). All are as good as those you've named, likely to be cheaper used and will have better dealers. They'll be used to older and less flash customers who just want to buy a car, often not on finance. Both Seat and Skoda are essentially the same as VW, so no real reason to buy a Touareg ahead of them unless you care about badge.

If you really don't care about image, you might look at a Ssangyong Korando or even MG HS.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Metropolis.
A Touareg is a step above the Terraco and Kodiaq, you might be thinking of the Tiguan. Blimey what awful names..
Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Adampr
A Touareg is a step above the Terraco and Kodiaq, you might be thinking of the Tiguan. Blimey what awful names..

I think you're right. I kind of lose track once they get to enormous. The names are truly awful. I think people flock to the Mercs, BMWs and Audis because they all just have a number or letter.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

I'll definitely look into all of them. Part of the problem is the variations in trim etc - it's just so time consuming to get to grips with any one model - let alone all of them! It's such a congested category! Thanks for the advice.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - SLO76
I’d keep the Toyota. It’ll still be running long after any of the potential replacements you mention have been turned into baked bean cans. It’ll offer lower running costs and vastly superior reliability.
Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - daveyjp

Swap it for a Toyota Rav4.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

I haven't discounted that! Our previous car was an Auris that we ran into the ground. Not going to lie, part of wishing to upgrade is badge vanity. We've never had a 'premium' car and I am tempted. But only if it delivers a tangible difference we enjoy for the years we have the new car. You're not wrong about the longevity of Toyota's though - extremely good reliability and value.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Adampr

I haven't discounted that! Our previous car was an Auris that we ran into the ground. Not going to lie, part of wishing to upgrade is badge vanity. We've never had a 'premium' car and I am tempted. But only if it delivers a tangible difference we enjoy for the years we have the new car. You're not wrong about the longevity of Toyota's though - extremely good reliability and value.

In that case, I would look at a Lexus NX above all others. A posh Toyota has to be the answer..

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

Funnily enough, been reading about it today. Looks like it's let down a bit by its infotainment being a bit fiddly - but that's not such a big issue if it's comparable in quality to 'The Germans' in other aspects. Nice looking car and it being a bit less in demand would fit my logic/hope of their being more value in a year old model.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Theophilus

- but that's not such a big issue if it's comparable in quality to 'The Germans' in other aspects.

I'm sure the German manufacturers would be delighted that their marketing departments have successfully impressed with their image of "quality", but in terms of quality where it really counts - reliability and consequent maintenance costs you will find far higher quality at lower expenditure with another Toyota / Lexus or a Honda CR-V

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

Yeah, I’m embarrassingly uninformed about cars - didn’t even get my license until I had kids. As a result I’m no doubt more susceptible to reputation than I should be… Will be looking closer at Lexus, as well as some of the other models mentioned above. Are Mercedes SUVs any good? They don’t seem to be as popular as others (at least from personal observation on the road)…

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - SLO76
Don’t touch a Mercedes. BMW or Audi unless you have reputable specialist in town. Main dealer will rob you blind for servicing and repairs and these cars don’t have a great reputation for reliability either. I have 100% faith in a used petrol or petrol hybrid Toyota or Lexus however and their dealers are generally ok, as long as it’s not a certain national chain with the initials AC.
Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

Thanks. Comments like yours and others, along with my experience at my local Audi and VW dealerships, are turning me off going that route.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Brit_in_Germany

My own personal experience is that Honda and Toyota have more technical problems than Jaguar and Alfa Romeo. So much for Japanese quality.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - mcb100
Strange times at the moment with used cars - after a couple of years of sky high prices, over the past few weeks the larger stuff has fallen off a cliff. To the tune of hundreds of pounds a week in value in some cases.
Small cars are, largely, holding firm.
So don’t expect to get what you’d have got a couple of months ago when it comes to trading in your car.
There are lots of dealers out there who’ve paid big money for cars now worth considerably less than when they were taken in.
Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

I guess as long as any value lost from mine is matched by the one I’m buying it will even out??? Is there an ill wind afoot with used cars in general do you think? It has crossed my mind that I could buy one and see a sharp drop, if the cost of living issues we’re all feeling get really dicey…

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Adampr

I guess as long as any value lost from mine is matched by the one I’m buying it will even out??? Is there an ill wind afoot with used cars in general do you think? It has crossed my mind that I could buy one and see a sharp drop, if the cost of living issues we’re all feeling get really dicey…

Very broadly, the bigger and more full of kit a car is, the more it will depreciate. Even worse if it has a large or otherwise inefficient engine. Unless you have a particular need, I would hold on to your CH-R for now. As a good-looking, reliable and efficient car, it will hold its value better than the others you have in mind.

Equally, if you've paid off the CH-R and are at all concerned about cost of living or the economy, financing something fancy is not the best strategy. From what the radio ads keep telling me, Toyota will extend your warranty by a year every time you get a service, so sticking with the CH-R for now is the sensible option.

Maybe stick the money you were going to spend on finance into premium bonds for the next six months or so?

All easier said than done, as my bank balance will tell you.

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - Prince Ruprecht

Lol, wise words. Reassuring to hear that my CH-R should hold value, relatively speaking. I’m certainly not in any rush. Doing my research now in the hope that if a good deal appears I’d be informed enough to spot it - and to avoid Finance where possible… Cheers!

Audi Q5 - Buying an SUV - help! - badbusdriver

Unless the C-HR is too small for your needs, I would keep it.