What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
- hissingsid
Re "Small Torque", the most reliable torque converter automatic supermini most people have never heard of is the Daihatsu Sirion. It is a Toyota Yaris with a different body, and ceased to be imported in 2010.
My wife bought one new in 2009 and ran it for seven trouble free years.
- GingerTom
JA of London highlights the problem many will face when electric cars are eventually forced upon us. OK for the general short journey but entirely useless for the long ones. We must not be deprived of a reasonable range of at least 500 miles via conventional engines before appropriate charging times of at most 10 minutes and charging locations are in place.
Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - glidermania
JA of London highlights the problem many will face when electric cars are eventually forced upon us. OK for the general short journey but entirely useless for the long ones. We must not be deprived of a reasonable range of at least 500 miles via conventional engines before appropriate charging times of at most 10 minutes and charging locations are in place.

To be honest, I thought the original writer's comments condescending and even the above appears written by someone with an uninformed knowledge of EVs. 'Oh, there's unlikely to ever be charging points in North Cumbria'! You what? Do you think we all wear clogs, get around by horse and cart and light our home via candles?!

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - Boshy
JA of London highlights the problem many will face when electric cars are eventually forced upon us. OK for the general short journey but entirely useless for the long ones. We must not be deprived of a reasonable range of at least 500 miles via conventional engines before appropriate charging times of at most 10 minutes and charging locations are in place.

To be honest, I thought the original writer's comments condescending and even the above appears written by someone with an uninformed knowledge of EVs. 'Oh, there's unlikely to ever be charging points in North Cumbria'! You what? Do you think we all wear clogs, get around by horse and cart and light our home via candles?!

Maybe ginger Tom regularly drives from London to Aberdeen (500 miles) without stopping during the 9 hr drive.

for me with a daily commute of less than a hundred, I just plug in when I get home. Not for everyone but really enjoying mine and with a weekly mileage of around 400 miles I never need to use public chargers.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - Engineer Andy
JA of London highlights the problem many will face when electric cars are eventually forced upon us. OK for the general short journey but entirely useless for the long ones. We must not be deprived of a reasonable range of at least 500 miles via conventional engines before appropriate charging times of at most 10 minutes and charging locations are in place.

To be honest, I thought the original writer's comments condescending and even the above appears written by someone with an uninformed knowledge of EVs. 'Oh, there's unlikely to ever be charging points in North Cumbria'! You what? Do you think we all wear clogs, get around by horse and cart and light our home via candles?!

Maybe ginger Tom regularly drives from London to Aberdeen (500 miles) without stopping during the 9 hr drive.

for me with a daily commute of less than a hundred, I just plug in when I get home. Not for everyone but really enjoying mine and with a weekly mileage of around 400 miles I never need to use public chargers.

A long journey will likely necessitate stopping once or twice, but normally they are at motorway service stops, which 99% charge about 30%+ more for fuel than ones off the motorway. It's not always easy to stop for fuel at one of those, especially during the rush hour, as you could be delayed quite a bit (and cannot park up to rest, use the loo [if they have any for customers]) trying to navigate local roads getting to the filling station and back onto the motorway again.

That's when having an ICE car with either a large fuel tank or, with modern petrol-engined cars or diesels in general, they can manage the whole journey on one tankful. Many people (like me) live in properties such as flats or terraced housing that means you can't recharge at home, meaning you have to rely on either public chargers or the few at workplaces, neither of which you can guarantee are available when you arrive or are working properly. Besides, EV range is a bit more spotty to determine in winter and thus you may have to charge up early, just in case, making you late.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - jchinuk

Once EVs become 'normal' places like supermarkets will install charging points, a "free charge while you shop" will replace the "5p off a litre" offers to get customers into the store. If a big store installed solar panels on their large flat roofs the running costs will be minimal. Incidentally, no one should driving 500 or even 250 miles without a break anyway.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - groaver

Once EVs become 'normal' places like supermarkets will install charging points, a "free charge while you shop" will replace the "5p off a litre" offers to get customers into the store. If a big store installed solar panels on their large flat roofs the running costs will be minimal. Incidentally, no one should driving 500 or even 250 miles without a break anyway.

Will they also be installing a large "super battery"?

They'll need that to store excess energy from generation at times when demand is low or sunlight is stronger to enable it to be released at times of high demand or less light.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - galileo

Once EVs become 'normal' places like supermarkets will install charging points, a "free charge while you shop" will replace the "5p off a litre" offers to get customers into the store. If a big store installed solar panels on their large flat roofs the running costs will be minimal. Incidentally, no one should driving 500 or even 250 miles without a break anyway..

For info, the Lidl supermarket in Holmfirth (in the wilds of the North) installed a charging point last year.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - GingerTom

Glidermania seems to have decided to read stuff I didn't write. If you bother to read it again I was pointing out that for the long journey that we need to make now and again an electric car with a 150 mile range is no good unless we have more charging points and faster charging times. I don't think this is unreasonable. I don't fancy shelling out 30k for an electric car that cannot do my trips to Devon without sitting in a charging station for an hour or so to complete the trip I can currently make in one go.

- trevor 166
Are you sure VW only make electric ups now? The 1.0 petrol is still listed on ntheir website
Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - Avant

The VW website is still listing the 60 bhp and the 115 bhp (GTI) petrol engines - not the 74 and 89 bhp models, which is a pity. They're trying to steer you toeards the e-up, or the electric-only Citigo or Mii.

- B Whinnie
I have read your weekly comments for as long as I can remember, but I am getting fed up with the endless problem stories with German cars, We all seem to have been brain washed with the myth of German quality, see also John Cadogan's Auto Expert on YouTube. I am puzzled as to why you continually recommend them?, award 5 stars (I know you reduced the Golf to 4 in the past). The very top of my requirements from a car is reliability!! If they are so good why don't they come with a decent warranty? (5 years minimum) the same applies to Honda and Mazda, even Renault has 5 years now.
Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - G Jones

German vehicles;

Whenever there's some terror incident in London I'm appalled that 95%

or more of police/ fire & ambulances in attendance are imports from Germany.

Now we've left the EU I sincerely hope that public procurement rules are changed so

they are weighted towards UK manufactured fleets, wherever feasible.

Do you see anything but nationally produced emergency vehicles when you drive in Italy,

France, Germany?

As always the UK gold-plated EU Procurement rules, whilst

other EU nations ignored and supported their local manufacturers.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - Chris C

German vehicles;

Whenever there's some terror incident in London I'm appalled that 95%

or more of police/ fire & ambulances in attendance are imports from Germany.

Now we've left the EU I sincerely hope that public procurement rules are changed so

they are weighted towards UK manufactured fleets, wherever feasible.

Do you see anything but nationally produced emergency vehicles when you drive in Italy,

France, Germany?

As always the UK gold-plated EU Procurement rules, whilst

other EU nations ignored and supported their local manufacturers.

Really? How do you know they are made in Germany (or at least carry the badges of German manufacturers) and not converted in the UK from base vehicles imported from overseas given that equivalent UK built vehicles/marques no longer exist? Don't blame the EU, blame a domestic political/social/financial system that failed to recognise/support UK manufacturing.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - galileo

German vehicles;

Whenever there's some terror incident in London I'm appalled that 95%

or more of police/ fire & ambulances in attendance are imports from Germany.

Now we've left the EU I sincerely hope that public procurement rules are changed so

they are weighted towards UK manufactured fleets, wherever feasible.

Do you see anything but nationally produced emergency vehicles when you drive in Italy,

France, Germany?

As always the UK gold-plated EU Procurement rules, whilst

other EU nations ignored and supported their local manufacturers.

Really? How do you know they are made in Germany (or at least carry the badges of German manufacturers) and not converted in the UK from base vehicles imported from overseas given that equivalent UK built vehicles/marques no longer exist? Don't blame the EU, blame a domestic political/social/financial system that failed to recognise/support UK manufacturing.

I believe many ambulances are built on Mercedes and other base chassis by a company in Brighouse, as one example of conversions.

Honest John’s Motoring Agony Column 15-02-2020 Part 2 - Miniman777

It's horses for courses.

Most UK police forces use BMWs for motorway patrol and X5s as ARV response vehicles That's because the are reliable, comfortable, take high mileages comfortably and are a match against most cars on the road - and in an X5, plenty of space for the gun safe. I suspect forces buy in bulk too, so get extra discounts which offset the fitting of specialist equipment. If other manufacturers cant/wont give such discounts, you can hardly blame those in procurement for spending taxpayers cash wisely. I'd add the Beamers dont have leather seats, just fabric. Given comments on this site about JLR products, it's no surprise they are not widely used. Also, British Transport Police have a number of Kuga's on the fleet.

In Leicestershire, local beat cars are Astra estates, community support vehicles Corsa's and the force has recently acquired a large fleet of Vauxhall Insigna 2.0 diesels as response cars.West Midlands police use lots of Insignia's too. Elsewhere I've seen Peugeots, Hyundai's, Kia's, Fords and Skodas.

- glidermania
Lots more broken links in Part 2 as well.
- zundapp
I tam getting fed up with reading endless negative remarks about German cars
Italian cars are hardly bomb proof either.
I have owned 14 VAG cars in the past 30 years, all Audi’s or VW,s, I am currently running a 18 reg Golf GTD.
Admittedly, they were all young or brand new and changed at regular intervals, but they were all reliable.The last 5 cars have all been high power diesels with DSG boxes and I have never had a gearbox problem with any of them .
I suspect a lot of the DSG problems are caused by a combination not having them serviced and drivers sitting on the brakes in traffic for long periods,with the car in gear.
Ever heard of neutral?
Running on quality fuel helps as well.
I’m not quite ready for a Nissan Micra yet!!

- stojom
Vag boxes

Is there anyway of telling which dsg box Is fitted to a vag model. Ie. Plate in engine compartment.
Big Question and long distance care - IrishNeil

Big question 'That mileage is about to increase further as we now have to put my father in a care home, which will involve about 3x100 mile round trips per week on the motorway.'

Your continued connection with your relatives is not only admirable but the distances you encounter are increasingly common.

Please take this in the spirit of good advice, as part of my job I try to persuade caring supportive families to consider moving their loved ones closer to them, cutting out distance in times of emergency and keeping an important connection alive.

I dont know your personal circumstances nor your father's health needs but in my experience a carehome is still a carehome no matter where it is situated, CQC is a useful guide.

If consent is an issue, I would consider a best interest & least restrictive option to promote the move closer to your home.

I accept I have not considered other family members and perhaps my suggestions are void based on that alone.

I hope you and your father have many happy visits together.

Edited by IrishNeil on 16/02/2020 at 13:02

- B Whinnie
Well I seem to have generated some interest on the merit of German cars, First if they are that good put a decent warranty on them (they carry a 5 years in other parts of the world) As to selling in huge numbers, just shows the power of advertising! "There's nothing more reliable than a Volkswagen". I notice that other nations TV shows inevitably use their own brands, As I say watch John Cardugan on YouTube. My experience would say if you want Quality buy from Japan, Korea, etc.
- Marcus T.
re.- pressure moments
My local Honda dealership say that the only problems they have encountered with the Honda TPMS sytems have been when they are fitted with mismatched tyres as per the author of the email. My CRV's have run with the same factory fit tyres and I have not had any issues..