What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Motability car tyres - badbusdriver

After the most recent service/inspection on our Jazz, the chap in reception dealing with me said to be aware that the front tyres were down to 3mm. I'd rather not go through winter with tyres that low, so emailed Motability to query their policy on tyres, and also, should they not be prepared to replace tham now, would there be a problem with my purchasing tyres and having them fitted myself.

Got a reply today and the Motability policy is to have the tyres replaced at 2mm, not great, given the amount of data available which shows just how much poorer a tyre grips the road (particularly wet roads), but it is a charity after all. The kicker though, and i am utterly baffled by this, if i was to replace the tyres on the Jazz, i would henceforth be responsible for the tyres on ALL subsequent Motability cars my wife gets!.

Any thoughts on this bizarre stance?. I am wondering if this might be something to do with Kwik Fit, as thet were specifically mentiond ("Kwik Fit would no longer be responsible for the tyres"), maybe them leaning on Motability so as not to lose out on business?. TBH, i am actually tempted to just fit new tyres myself for the simple reason that my nearest Kwik Fit is about 30 miles away!.

Also, i am wondering about swapping front and rear, would this be advisable?. BTW, i have just checked them myself, and i make the front ones more like 4mm, but the rears are 7mm in the middle and 6mm on the outside edges.

Motability car tyres - Falkirk Bairn

When I had fwd Hondas I would swap fronts to back at 20K.

The rears were as new and at roughly 40/45K I bought 4 new tyres.

With 4WD I swap at 15K as it is important to keep fronts & rears within 3 mm.

At 30/35K buy 4 x new tyres.

Motability car tyres - bathtub tom

Put the handbrake on HARD and spin the front wheels in first. I'm sure you could wear off a millimetre of rubber.

Motability car tyres - gordonbennet

You've got another 3 full months plus before the weather really deteriorates to cold as well as wet, if it were me i'd drive the thing hard for the remaining good weather and with a bit of luck you'll get new fronts (though they'll no doubt put them on the back for one size fits all reasons) before the winter kicks in.

Shouldn't need to apply the parking brake, if TC/ASR is turned off enough wheelspin should be found to do the trick.

Motability car tyres - Bromptonaut

Got a reply today and the Motability policy is to have the tyres replaced at 2mm,

I'd suggest that, given Motability's function and status, this is the sort of policy that might be changed by well orchestrated publicity.........

Motability car tyres - FiestaOwner

Got a reply today and the Motability policy is to have the tyres replaced at 2mm,

I'd suggest that, given Motability's function and status, this is the sort of policy that might be changed by well orchestrated publicity.........

Doubt that would make the slightest bit of difference. It's standard policy of leasing companies to change tyres at 2mm.

Although I don't agree with this practice, they will make a big saving by changing tyres at 2mm rather than 3mm. Afraid it's all down to cost.

Motability car tyres - Bromptonaut

Doubt that would make the slightest bit of difference. It's standard policy of leasing companies to change tyres at 2mm.

Point about Motability is the clientele. Message that charity is playing poker with lives of disabled, illustrated with images of disabled kids, grabs the public.

If that works there's a good chance of shaming co car leasing outfits to change @ 3mm on campaign's coat tails.

Motability car tyres - FiestaOwner

Doubt that would make the slightest bit of difference. It's standard policy of leasing companies to change tyres at 2mm.

Point about Motability is the clientele. Message that charity is playing poker with lives of disabled, illustrated with images of disabled kids, grabs the public.

If that works there's a good chance of shaming co car leasing outfits to change @ 3mm on campaign's coat tails.

Well this news item about this subject 2 years ago didn't make the slightest bit of difference, despite them trying to involve the RAC. Sounds as if the RAC backtracked with their 3mm recommendation!

www.disabilitynewsservice.com/motabilitys-tyre-pol.../

Don't believe you'll get anywhere with this. Plenty of folk complain about the 2mm limit for tyres on leased vehicles and have done for many years.

"Point about Motability is the clientele. Message that charity is playing poker with lives of disabled, illustrated with images of disabled kids, grabs the public."

I think you should be more concerned with the leased 3.5 tonne transit van which is tailgating the mobility vehicle (and has tyres at or below 2mm). That is a bigger hazard to the car occupants.

I did say on my previous post that I didn't agree with the leasing companies only replacing tyres at 2mm. In my view they should replace at 3mm. Can't see that happening though. I am waiting to proved wrong though!

Motability car tyres - Bromptonaut

I think you should be more concerned with the leased 3.5 tonne transit van which is tailgating the mobility vehicle (and has tyres at or below 2mm). That is a bigger hazard to the car occupants.

Agree with point about large vans but question posed is about Motability.

I remain of view that a well organised publicity campaign with a clear objective using social media and engaging with press, particularly the Daily Mail, would have a good prospect of success.

But we won't know until someone gets such a campaign moving.

Motability car tyres - alan1302

I think you should be more concerned with the leased 3.5 tonne transit van which is tailgating the mobility vehicle (and has tyres at or below 2mm). That is a bigger hazard to the car occupants.

Agree with point about large vans but question posed is about Motability.

I remain of view that a well organised publicity campaign with a clear objective using social media and engaging with press, particularly the Daily Mail, would have a good prospect of success.

But we won't know until someone gets such a campaign moving.

Are the Daily Mail not likely to think it's people with benefits expecting more though?

Motability car tyres - Manatee

Got a reply today and the Motability policy is to have the tyres replaced at 2mm,

I'd suggest that, given Motability's function and status, this is the sort of policy that might be changed by well orchestrated publicity.........

I for one would not support such a campaign. Motability is a charity funded willy nilly by the taxpayer through welfare payments.

There are plenty of people without such benefits having to eke out their tyres to 2mm or less, as well as sensibly rotating tyres for even wear.

To suggest wilfully shredding the tyres by spinning the wheels so as to get 'free' new tyres is also something I take a dim view of.

Swapping the tyres round is a good suggestion, while the fronts still have a reasonable amount of tread.

As for the rubbish about the consequences of putting one's own tyres on, how would they know?

Motability car tyres - Smileyman

If you fit your own tyres you will have control over brand / product etc. You could always re-fit the old tyres just before returning the car!!

Motability car tyres - Brit_in_Germany

Wait a couple of months then go back to the servicing station and get them to agree that the tyres are down to 2 mm, then contact motability.

Motability car tyres - badbusdriver

bathtub tom and GB, one thing the Jazz won't do (in my experience), is spin the front tyres, at least not in the dry. The combination of CVT transmission and 90lb/ft of torque @ 5000rpm means that even in the wet it would be a struggle to spin the tyres!. With a manual gearbox, especially on a lower spec car with narrower tyres (and no mechanical sympathy), it might be feasable!.

Bromptonaut, yes i agree, and i certainly intend to reply to the email i got from Motability, possibly with some links to tyre tests!.

Smileyman, it is tempting, and i may yet go down that route as its not like we do lots of miles and, as well as the ability to pick and choose what tyre i think best, as i said earlier, getting to Kwik Fit is not that conveniant for me (should have mentioned earlier, but Kwik Fit are the 'official' Motability tyre fitters, not the supplying dealer, though i think under some circumstances, the dealer can change them). But that is what i do with my van, choose which tyre i want, buy a set off Ebay and have them fitted by my trusted indy.

Going back to the mileage, i can't actually remember the last time we had to have new tyres fitted to a Motability car, certainly not the previous three. So i'd have to put it down to the Honda's ability to goad me into thrashing it!.

Motability car tyres - FiestaOwner

I used to drive leased vans at work. It seemed to be the policy of all the leasing companies to replace tyres at 2mm.

Most of the leasing companies insisted we went to Kwik Fit. If you went in with 1 front tyre at 2mm and the other at 3mm, they would only replace the 1 tyre.

Kwik Fit were usually very busy, so as a lease customer (with a low profit margin) we were always put behind the paying private customer.

Other tyre dealers were better, but most leasing companies insisted on Kwik Fit.

Personally I prefer to choose where I take my car for servicing/ repairs and tyres, therefore I wouldn't consider a Lease or PCP contract which includes maintenance and tyres.

Edited by FiestaOwner on 23/08/2019 at 21:53

Motability car tyres - DavidGlos
Our company lease cars are through Lex and we have to use Kwik Fit.

Not sure if this change is Lex led or as a result of the company I work for putting their foot down, but around 1 year ago, they changed from a 2mm replacement policy to 3mm.

My experience has been decent. When the rear tyres started wearing unevenly and made an unholy racket, they’d agreed to replace them with around 4mm remaining.

Not much help to the OP, but it does show that there are some out there who allow a similar approach to be taken to how a prudent private motorist would act
Motability car tyres - FiestaOwner
Not sure if this change is Lex led or as a result of the company I work for putting their foot down, but around 1 year ago, they changed from a 2mm replacement policy to 3mm. My experience has been decent. When the rear tyres started wearing unevenly and made an unholy racket, they’d agreed to replace them with around 4mm remaining

Perhaps your company's lease doesn't include tyres. Perhaps LEX or Kwik Fit is invoicing your company for tyres. If that's the case then it's in the tyre companies interest to replace tyres sooner.

LEX policy is .... "Safety - We replace tyres at a tread depth of 2mm, 0.4mm above the legal minimum requirement of 1.6mm per tyre."

www.lexautolease.co.uk/business/maintenance/tyre-m...e

Whatever the reason though, I'm glad you have a decent experience. It's how it should be.

Motability car tyres - Avant

I don't think you'll get anywhere with Motability either. That decision will have been made by men in suits who simply look at the legal minimum of 1.6 mm and fix their limit at 2 mm.

Any lobbying ought to be directed at the Government to make the minimum 2 mm or even 2.5 mm.

Motability car tyres - Falkirk Bairn

Jazz - 4mm on front & 7mm on back

Swap the fronts & backs - DIY is a hassle - my local Indie Tyre Centre charges £20 and takes 10 mins (after you get to the front of the queue) - Monday mornings are quiet so I go then.

They or you need to reset tyre pressure monitor.

A few ££s & your car will do maybe 20K before all 4 need changing - you might have another car before then.

Motability car tyres - paul 1963

Jazz - 4mm on front & 7mm on back

Swap the fronts & backs - DIY is a hassle - my local Indie Tyre Centre charges £20 and takes 10 mins (after you get to the front of the queue) - Monday mornings are quiet so I go then.

They or you need to reset tyre pressure monitor.

A few ££s & your car will do maybe 20K before all 4 need changing - you might have another car before then.

Totally agree, get them swapped round, problem solved.

Motability car tyres - John F

After the most recent service/inspection on our Jazz, the chap in reception dealing with me said to be aware that the front tyres were down to 3mm. .....

........i have just checked them myself, and i make the front ones more like 4mm, but the rears are 7mm in the middle and 6mm on the outside edges......

....... I am wondering if this might be something to do with Kwik Fit,.....

Heigh ho. Why does anyone go there.......

As said, just swap them front to back. No brainer.

Motability car tyres - gordonbennet

By swapping the car will spend this coming winter on 4 x summer tyres with around 5mm fronts and that same 3 to 4mm rears, i'd rather scrub the fronts out and get one new pair fitted late Nov early Dec.

I'm champing at the bit at 4mm on my own rubber, not a hope in hell they'll still be on at 3mm.

Lorry tyres are even lower by the way 1mm, however company policy is 3mm at the very least across the whole tread, and it shows because despite maximum weights when loaded punctures are rare and blow outs unheard of, remoulds not used at all.

Motability car tyres - snufflegrunt

What happens if you get a puncture and it is too close to the edge to repair?

Also, don't Kwik-fit always fit their own Arrowspeed (obsolete NEXEN) ditchfinders to lease cars?

Motability car tyres - FiestaOwner

What happens if you get a puncture and it is too close to the edge to repair?

Also, don't Kwik-fit always fit their own Arrowspeed (obsolete NEXEN) ditchfinders to lease cars?

Well if the tyre needs replaced it needs replaced. Don't know if the leasing company or the customer would pick up the bill. Depends what the leasing agreement states. Although I had many punctures in 20 years with leased vehicles, I never had one which wasn't repairable.

The lease companies I dealt with (apart from one small outfit) always fitted premium tyre brands (Michelin, Goodyear, Continental etc). Lex and Leaseplan always fitted the premium brands (via Kwik Fit).

Edited by FiestaOwner on 25/08/2019 at 10:29

Motability car tyres - Andrew-T

I can understand the urge to ask for new tyres at 3 instead of 2mm, but from the opposite viewpoint, why not 4 or even 5? Deeper tread will always be marginally 'safer'. I seem to remember the minimum allowed used to be only 1mm which was increased to 1.6 quite a few years ago now. Who decided 1.6 was a safe compromise, and why? Throwing away tyres with plenty of useful life is environmentally reprehensible.

As has been suggested, it is one thing to have better steering and stopping ability, but it is of limited advantage if all the vehicles close behind are not similarly equipped.

Edited by Andrew-T on 25/08/2019 at 10:41

Motability car tyres - coopshere
“So you would be happy to be the one who rams the rear of the car in front because it was able to stop on better tyres than yours”
Motability car tyres - RT

I can understand the urge to ask for new tyres at 3 instead of 2mm, but from the opposite viewpoint, why not 4 or even 5? Deeper tread will always be marginally 'safer'. I seem to remember the minimum allowed used to be only 1mm which was increased to 1.6 quite a few years ago now. Who decided 1.6 was a safe compromise, and why? Throwing away tyres with plenty of useful life is environmentally reprehensible.

As has been suggested, it is one thing to have better steering and stopping ability, but it is of limited advantage if all the vehicles close behind are not similarly equipped.

Tests show that wet grip falls away rapidily under 3mm - it's a typical "J" curve so it's possible to endlessly debate how much better 3.0mm is than 2.9mm for example.

1.6mm was chosen as the limit that could be agreed globally - many countries support the use of a 3mm limit but global agreement isn't there yet.

Motability car tyres - concrete

I must admit that the tyre swapping advice is the solution I would go for. Do you throw the Jazz around like a boy racer? I suspect not, I am sure you drive safely and steadily so 4mm and 6/7mm should do you fine.

BTW when I had company lease cars I found tyre companies like Kwikfit were prone to give a cynical reading. If they said 3mm the truth was often 4mm or more! Some lease companies were more strict then others and would do spot checks to look at worn tyres after replacement. I always insisted on like for like. If the car came with Michelin then it stayed with Michelin. I would not allow mixing of brands. If they tried it on I insisted on a letter from their legal department accepting full responsibility in the event of an accident. Needles to say I got my way. Good luck with Motability.

Cheers Concrete

Motability car tyres - nick62

BTW when I had company lease cars I found tyre companies like Kwikfit were prone to give a cynical reading. If they said 3mm the truth was often 4mm or more!

If this is true, I wonder where the removed "part worn" ones went?

Motability car tyres - badbusdriver

BTW when I had company lease cars I found tyre companies like Kwikfit were prone to give a cynical reading. If they said 3mm the truth was often 4mm or more!

If this is true, I wonder where the removed "part worn" ones went?

Sold to boy racers as 'part worn' for cash by the fitters, probably a nice little earner on the side.

Motability car tyres - concrete

BTW when I had company lease cars I found tyre companies like Kwikfit were prone to give a cynical reading. If they said 3mm the truth was often 4mm or more!

If this is true, I wonder where the removed "part worn" ones went?

Sold to boy racers as 'part worn' for cash by the fitters, probably a nice little earner on the side.

I think you are right bbd. This practice got less and less as the lease companies got wise and the likes of Kwikfit etc had to hold the tyres for inspection. I must admit though I have taken tyres down to 2mm without any detriment. Maybe I was lucky but I am a reasonable driver and careful too. It is the stopping distance that suffers when the tread is worn so you may need to be more circumspect when driving in the wet.

Cheers Concrete

Motability car tyres - nick62

I remember dad putting the fronts on the back and running them until they went flat back in the 60's on our Mini van, (but he always paid extra for seat belts)!

When was the minimum tread depth law introduced?